Creepy Pasta Boyfriend Scenarios

When he finally asks you out

Ticci Toby
"H-hi Y/n..." Toby's says stuttering.

"Hey Toby!" I say happily.

I give him a hug like always. But what I don't know is that under his mask he's blushing. I pull away a couple seconds later not wanting to leave his grasp. I don't know why I feel like this but I do...

I hear him mumble something under his breath. It was to quiet for me to hear so I asked him what he said.

"N-n-nothing..." He answers quickly looking away from me.

I cup his cheeks my face not far from his.

"Answer me." I say bluntly.

"O-okay fine.... Will you go out with me?" He asks looking at his feet shyly.

I smile widely before giving him a hug and nodding into the nape of his neck
Jeff the Killer
"Hey Y/N." I hear Jeff say quietly.

Weird... That's not like him at all. Hmm, probably nothing I'm overthinking... Something I'm good at. At least I'm good at something.

"Umm... Hey." I say awkwardly. Great. He probably thinks I don't want to talk to him...

"I wanted to ask you something..." Jeff says shyly.

"Sure." I say looking at him.

"Wouldyouliketobemygirlfriend?" He says quickly and in a whisper.

"Wait... What?" I ask.

"Would you go out with me?" He asks grabbing both my hands into his and staring me in my eyes.

"Yes!" I say excitedly.

"Good. If you didn't agree I probably would've killed you."
BEN Drowned
BEN jumps out of my tv and sits next to me really close.

"Hey babe." BEN says confidently.

"Uh.. Hey?" I say confused.

I'm suddenly pulled onto his lap while he stares at me with his black eyes. I watch the ooze looking thing come out of his eyes while I sit on his lap. My face is probably beet red.

"You're beautiful, you know that?" He says in a not so flirty tone, surprisingly.

I get embarrassed and push my face into his neck. I do not want him to see me like this.

"Hey beautiful I need to ask you something." He says sweetly whispering into my ears tickling me slightly.

I shiver at the warmth of his breath as it hits my skin and sends shivers down my spine. I move to actually look at him and I continue to stare into his eyes.

"Yes..?" I ask quietly.

"Would you go out with me?" He asks sweetly staring at me.

After a minute he starts to look worried and not confident for once. I start laughing since I haven't seen him like this since I've met him.

He pulls me closer to his body making sure to move my legs first so I'm straddling him. I blush darkly as I realize how we must look.

"Do not laugh at me." He says darkly,"can you please answer me?"

"Okay, okay! Fine!" I say still laughing.

Suddenly his body shifts and forces me onto the couch. My back hits the cushions as his hair falls onto my face tickling me slightly.

"You're so cute."
Eyeless Jack
"Hey Jack!" I say while basically skipping into my room.

I already know he's here since he's here basically everyday. Suddenly I'm picked up off the floor and then slammed into my bed. I scream as I close my eyes tightly. My back collides with my bed as the air leaves my lungs.