Creepy Pasta Boyfriend Scenarios

When he asks you out on a date

Ticci Toby
You lay on the grass in your backyard as you listen to music. Suddenly you feel arms wrap around your and you scream as you weren't expecting it. You open your eyes quickly as you realize it's just Toby. You glare at him as you lay still in his arms. You turn and stare into his eyes and you smile softly.

"Would you go out with me..?" Toby asks softly.

I smile widely as I process what he said.

"Of course!" I say happily.

I wrap my arms around him and hug him.
Jeff the Killer
Arms wrapped around my waist as I was lifted into the air. I kick around trying to hit whoever is holding me. I finally calm down as I was starting to get tired. I look behind me and see Jeff holding me. I blush but he can't really see my face because he's holding me so I'm not facing him.

I'm on the ground again as Jeff finally decided to stop being a jerk. I realize that I'm in his room and I sit on the bed. I know he won't let me out since he's to stubborn. I sigh as I lay down on the bed, his bed is really comfortable.

Suddenly I feel Jeff hover over me as I'm trapped between his legs. I glare at him. I don't even know why he wants me here anyways.

"Will you go out with me?" Jeff asks a blush covering his face.

"Yes!" I say with a smile.
BEN Drowned
I was playing some games and suddenly I feel arms wrap around my waist. I get pulled into the persons embrace. I feel cold radiating from the body and I pause my game and look at him. I realize that it's BEN. I lean into his embrace as I close my eyes.

"It's been awhile I'm sorry for not visiting lately..." BEN apologizes.

"It's okay." I say in a hushed tone.

I smile softly as I grab my controller again and continue playing.

Suddenly my game starts glitching as I realize it says some words. 'Would you like to be my girlfriend?' I smile softly as I hug my game system.

"Of course!" I say.

I already know it's BEN I just want to bug him. I look at him happily as he looks shocked. He moved and sits beside me.

"That was meant for me to ask you out." He says.

"Sorry, I'm already taken." I say jokingly.

"By who?" He asks curiously.

"You." I say as I give him a hug.
Eyeless Jack
I sit watching tv as I realize hands have snaked around my body.

"Would you like to accompany me on my walk?" He asks kindly.

"Of course." I say smiling.

His hands find a way to mine as they intertwine. Jack leads me out the door and into the forest. We walk on a trail in silence as my hand starts to sweat from the warmth radiating from his hand.

I see a tall and slender man standing off into the distance. I let go of Jacks hand hoping he'll follow me. I walk off following him. I realize soon enough that I have no clue on where I am.

Arms wrap around my waist as a familiar voice whispers in my ear. I could recognize this voice anywhere. I hug him as I realize it Jack.

"Hey, I'm sorry I had to leave on such short notice... I had business to take care of." He says quietly.

"Okay..." I say inching back slowly.

"Hmm, I wanted to get you alone because I was wondering if you wanted to go out with me?" He asks shyly.

I smile as I nod happily.
Sonic.EXE
"Okay Y/N your my girlfriend now..." He says bluntly.

I just nod as I continue playing on my phone as he cuddles me.
Laughing Jack
"Hey my lollipop!" He says in a cheerful tone.

"Hey Lj." I say playing a game on my phone.

My phone soon enough was snatched away from my grasp. I see Lj run away with my phone. I sigh as I chase after him.
Time skip...
I finally catch up and I tackle him to the ground straddling him. I grab my phone and hug it muttering 'I love you to it'

"Would you love me?" Lj asks shyly.

My face flares pink as I realize what he just said. I smile and nod and hug him after that laying on the ground cuddling him.
Masky
Me and masky were baking cheesecakes as he was icing and I was making a second one it was
F/C/F. 

I went to check on maskys and he covered it and said no peeking.

"Fine..." I whine. (That rhymed)
Time skip...
I finish mine and do does masky. We put ours in front of each other and reveal it. I unveil mine first and he says F/C/F is his favourite too.

It was his turn as he unveils his I realize it says some words. I read them out as it says 'will you go out with me?'

I hug him swiftly as I yell yes in his ear. When he pulls away he grips his ears as if he went deaf.

"That's good but right now I need to worry about my ears..."
Dark Link
"Hey sweet cheeks." Dark says.

"Oh hey Dark." I say continuing to play my game.

"Why don't you play with me?" Dark says sexually.

I blush darkly as I realize what he says. I pause my game quickly and glare at him.

"I'm joking." He says laughing a little after.

"Wow okay then I guess I could ignore you." I say continuing my game.

He snatches the controllers from my hands as he pulls it out of my reach. I try grasp it as I trip over my own feet and fall on top of Dark.

He pulls me closer as my face almost connects with his. I blush as I try and pull away. 

"Darling, would you like to be my girlfriend?" He asks confidently.

I smile and nod and hug him.

"Aww I was hoping for something else... More fun." He whispers in my ear.

I shiver and shake my head.
Lost Silver
"Hi Silver!" I say happily.

"Oh... H-hey." He says quietly.

I run to him and hug him quickly.

"I haven't seen you in like forever." I say.

"Me t-too... I-I've been thinking..." He says in a hushed tone "I-If you would like t-to b-be-e my g-gir-lfriend?"

I smile softly as I hug him and softly whisper 'yes'

Hey guys! Sorry for not updating recently I've been busy and I just couldn't think of anything... And I've been busy with school. But anywaysssss I hope you guys enjoyed!

Byeeeeee 💕