What Could Have Been ( Jeff the Killer x Female Reader) DISCONTINUED

Chapter 5: Why did you do that?

Your pov

It was my little sister. Memories started flooding back about before I moved out and how much my sister looked up to me. This was my first mission, I couldn't disappoint boss or I would be punished. I whispered to Masky " that girl in the blue shirt is my sister, I won't be able to kill her... I need you to." He nodded simply. The group eventually split into two groups, one of two and one of three,They were going two different directions. They couldn't make my job any easier. I smirked "Toby and I will take the boys. Hoodie and Masky take the girls. Masky remember what I told you." I said quickly. Masky nodded and followed the group of girls. Hoodie following close behind. Me and Toby slowly followed the boys until they got to a place where they wanted to rest. One of the boys turned around. Which was their last mistake. I quickly grabbed the boy, covered his mouth, and slit his throat. I watched as he fell to the ground. I couldn't help but smile, it felt good watching people die. The other boy noticed this, screamed (like a little girl), and ran Toby was waiting for him at the end of the path. The boy spotted Toby with his axes ready. He began to turn around, when he did he saw me with my knife ready. I smiled creepily at him. Toby and I slowly walked closer to him until we were feet apart. Toby took his axe and in one swing his head was off.  I smiled until I heard something in the distance. It was screaming, my sisters screaming. I heard a loud thud then the screaming stopped. I began to cry and drop to my knees. Masky quickly ran around the corner and picked me up " Hey, shh its over now." He said in a comforting tone. I buried my face into his chest. He carried me back to the mansion. When we walked in everyone noticed I was crying and that Masky was carrying me. " Masky I'll take her to her room." I heard Jeff say. I felt myself being placed in Jeff's arms. I was still crying when i heard Jeff trying to calm me down. He went into my room and placed me on my bed. He sat down next to me. "(y/n) tell me exactly what happened." He said in a caring voice. " M-my sister was one of t-the fans and I told M-Masky to take care of h-her but I h-heard her screaming. M-my sister is dead!" I said and began to cry harder. He placed me on his lap and cuddled me. " Look its over you gotta forget. I know that seems harsh but you have your whole life in front of you. Is ok shh." He held me tighter. I buried my face into his chest. Jeff kissed me on the head. He lifted my face and wiped away my tears.