Evan Peters Character Imagines/One Shots

First Time Saying "I Love You" Preference

Evan- You and Evan first met on the set of AHS. It wasn't exactly love at first site but it was friends at first site. You both grew very fond of each other and both had a hiden crush of one another. Of course, both you and Evan thought the other didn't share the same feelings, even though it was obvious to all the other co-workers. Sarah seemed to be the one who shipped you guys together most, always joking around and hitting of you guys being together.

One day, you and Evan were having a movie night at his place. It become sort of a tradition every Sunday night before you both had to go back to work the next day. You were watching the movie but realized at the corner of you eye, Evan wasn't watching it at all, he was watching you.

"What?" You asked with a nervous chuckle. Evan had a readless expression in his face and you were starting to gey worried. "What?"

"I love you." He suddenly said, catching you 120% off guard.

"W-what?"

"I have for a few months now, and I just can't keep it inside anymore. I love you, Y/N." You felt like doing flips, this was by far the best moment of your life.

"I love you too, Evan."

Tate- Your family had moved into the Murder House a few months ago. You met Tate when you were unpacking in your room and he claimed to be a neighbor. Of course you eventually learned what he really was, after a bit of getting used to, your feelings for him didn't change. Friends soon turned to more. You both were now listning to Nervana while cuddling in your bed. Suddenly Tate sat uo, taking your hands in his and looked into your eyes intensely. You just smiled lifting you brow, waiting for him yo say something.

"I love you." He said, your smile grew wider not hesitating a moment to  reply.

"I love you too."

Kit- You and Kit met inside the Asylum. As soon as you walked into the common room and you both said your first hellos, you knew Kit was innocent and Kit thought the same for you. So for the next few weeks you both planned an exscape, it took everything to not just give up after a few failed attempts. But you both never did, thinking of the other as their motivation.

You both had another plan you both knew would be risky. The nighy before, you both layed on your beds since you guys were bunked with each other in a room. You knew that you loved Kit and it haunted you that something may happen to him. Knowing this may be the last time you both had together, you had to say it.

Taking a deep breath, you closed your eyes.

"I love you." You spurred out quickly. Wincing when you didn't get a response right away, wishing you could see his reaction from the bunk above you. Suddenly the sound of him moving around echoed through the room and the tap of his shoes hitting the floor from him jumping down off his bunk. You sat up, looking in his eyes as he kneeled down beside you, looking your E/C eyes.

"I love you too, Y/N. We're going to get out of here. I promise." He assured making you smile at his accent that seemed to be the only thing thay relaxed and calmed you now adays. You nodded and placed a kiss on his cheek making him smile wider.

Kyle- You and Kyle have been friends since childhood. You went through a lot together. You both were there for eachother when Katrina struck and you lost you mom and Kyle his dad. Senior year of high school you and Kyle's relationship grew into something more.

Graduation was the day you both confessed your love for each other, you both were going to the same college and couldn't wait for the future. The adrenaline in throwing your caps up and thinking of the future made you both breathless and 100x more happy. So when you both looked into each others eyes, everything seemed to click.

"I love you." You both found yourself saying at the same time, causing you to bust out laughing and kissing each other while Kyle picked you up, spinning you around.

Jimmy- You and Jimmy met at the freakshow of course as kids, Elsa was your aunt and when your parents died at the age of two, she took you in. When Jimmy and his mom came when you were both seven, you immediately became friends. As you grew up, you grew a crush on Jimmy. But seeing him sometimes bringing girls home always put you down, making you self conscious and wishing you looked like them. For a few weeks Jimmy asked what was wrong and insisted you tell him since he was your best friend, that only made you hurt more. You wish you guys were more, and that soon lead to you avoid Jimmy.

One night, there was banging on your trailer door and as you opened it, there stood Jimmy. You were caught 100% off guard and didn't know what to say.

"Y/N, you're my best friend. You know me better than anyone and I care about you a lot. I know you're avoiding me, please tell me what's wrong." He pushed, gesturing his fuses hands as he talked. You smiled bittersweetly and opened the door wider for him to come in.

You bith sat down and you confessed what was wrong.

"Y/N..." He began surprised that's what was wrong. "You and my mah are the only girls in my life I truly care about. I only ever brought those girl home to get my mind off of you..." He confessed making your eyes widned.

"Really?"

"Really, I thought you didn't feel the same way I do. But the truth is... I love you, Y/N. More than a friend."

"I love you too, Jimmy. More than a friend." You replied with a smile, Jimmy mirroring your expression.

James- James wasn't much to showing his feelings, he always kept it inside thinking it showed weakness. You knew he loved you and vice versa, but it always bugged you that he always tried to bottle it all up. But you loved the way James was and wouldn't change a thing.

One night, you and James layed in bed tangled in sheets (😉😉). Your head layed on James chest and his thumb rubbed circles in your side.

"I must say, I am very fond of you, Y/N." He said breaking the silence making you smile.

"I'm very fond of you as well, James." You replied, once again you both layed in silence. Just when your eyes were getting heavy and you were about to fall into a deep slumber, James voice eachoed through the room, making your eyes snap open again.

"I love... You." He said slowly. You were a lost for words for a moment surprised at his sudden words.

"I love you too." You replied smiling to yourself and falling asleep soon after.

Peter- Peter and you have been friends ever since you both helped break Magneto out of the Pentagon. Since you both lived close by, you stayed in touch, becoming very close friends. After a while, it become something more.

Once you and Peter both moved into Charles school, your relationship became more serious but you still haven't said I love you quite yet.

One night you both snuck out of the mansion and went out to dinner. The whole night you knew Peter was nervous about something. You decided to confront him halfway through dinner.

"Peter you've been practically shaking all night, what's wrong?" You asked concerned.

"Okay... Um... Y/N, you're the most amazing, smart, kind, and funny person I have ever met. Not to mension beautiful. I can't wait to see what happens in our future and I can only hope you are with me in that future. What I'm trying to say is... I-I love y-you." He said fast but you've gotten used to it by now. You smiled widely.

"I love you too." You blushed going back to your dinner smirking at Peter relieved sigh and hin going back to his dinner as well.

Hey guys! I'm sorry it's been a while but my computer isn't working at the moment and I prefer writing on my laptop, since I get less typos. I apologize for any mistakes in this, I'm too lazy to edit it lol. Hope you enjoyed!

-Kayla