Ben Drowned: Ever since you had first met Ben you had never seen him take off his hat. Ever. Not even for you! And believe me you had tried, it seemed at least twice a day you tried to convince him to let you wear it. But so far no luck.
You were up in your room thinking about a way to get the hat, you looked at the sleeping Ben beside you. That gave you an idea. You snickered as you went to grab the hat but suddenly Ben's hand shot up and grabbed your wrist as your fingers were inches away from the hat. He pulled you into his arms. "Sorry but not today y/n." he chuckled, you couldn't help but pout.
Slenderman: One day you and Slender were sitting on the couch, reading quietly when you looked at him and asked out of the blue "Can I wear your tie?" Slender blinked (Er...sort of) "I don't see why not." He reached undid the tie and knotted it around your neck.
You grinned. Slender knew right away it had been a terrible mistake. You ran around the house screaming "I'm sexy and I know it!" all the pasta's laughed at Slender's attempts to get you to come back. "Never!!" you screamed, looking back you tripped over something and flew into the air but Slender caught you. You kissed his cheek. But you refused to give the tie back for two days.
Eyeless Jack: You had never seen Jack's real face, ever. Only his lips. He refused to take off his mask, said it was the only way he could see. But you wondered if the real reason was because he was insecure.
One night he was taking a shower, and your mind couldn't help but wonder if he showered with the mask on. Curiosity eventually got the best of you, you creaked open the door and heard him singing in the shower. You saw his mask sitting on the counter. Bingo.
Carefully you crept over and swiped the mask, flying out of the bathroom you smiled in triumph! Now you would have to see Jack's face! Looking down though you couldn't help but put on the mask and feel badass. You hadn't realized the shower had stopped. Suddenly the mask was swiped away from you and you turned to see EJ with it on before he pulled you into his arms.
Jeff The Killer: Jeff had gotten blood all over his hoodie, again. When you first met him his hoodie had been a little dirty but still a nice white. But now it was covered in mud and blood, it smelled awful. He had come home from a killing spree "Hey babe." He went to hug you but you stopped him "Not with that thing. Let me wash it." After a few moments of convincing Jeff reluctantly handed over the shirt.
Happily you went and cleaned it while he waited. Once you washed it was a beautiful aluminous white you couldn't help but try it on! You spun around hugging the warm fabric. You heard chuckling, swinging around you saw Jeff standing there. You blushed.
You went to take off the hoodie but he stopped you "Don't, you look cute with it on."
Masky: Recently you had been trying to steal Masky's mask, no particular reason, just because of the fact that he wouldn't take it off!
He was sitting on the couch watching a tv show, you crept up behind him and reached for the mask, within moments you were pinned to the couch and lips were sweetly kissing yours. You wrapped your arms around Masky's neck and deepened the kiss. After a few moments you both pulled apart. "Nice try y/n."
