Ben Drowned: Ben and you were at the mall, sitting in the food court. You were nibbling on a salty pretzel while Ben was digging into a huge pile of nachos. He picked up a chip and allowed the cheese to drip into his mouth.
You giggled as some of it dribbled onto his chin. He reached for a napkin but you stopped him “I’ll get it.” You licked his upper mouth softly. “I need more cheese.” He blushed and ran off with his nachos. Sitting back in the chair it was silent and calm for a few moments until you felt a tap on your shoulder.
Turning around, you saw that there stood your ex boyfriend Michael. You narrowed your eyes “What do you want Michael?” He looked at his foot, rocking back and forth on his heels. “I’msorrywebrokeupwillyougooutwithme?” he said quickly. “Excuse me?!” you heard a familiar voice say. Behind you was Ben and his eyes were glowing red. “I’m her fucking boyfriend! Get out of here!” he dumped the nachos on Michael who after that ran off.
You kissed Ben “Thanks babe.”
Slenderman: You used to date this girl named Cynthia, the two of you would go to the woods all the time while you dated. Which is why it didn’t really surprise you to find Cynthia swinging on a tree in the woods while you were on a walk with Slender.
She grinned at you, pushing her blond hair out of the way. “H-hey y/n!” You frowned. “What do you want Cynthia?” “I thought I’d find you here!” she grabbed your hand and swung it gently. “Want to go to a movie sometime?”
That was enough for Slender, taking his tentacles he ripped her in half. You giggled and kissed his cheek.
Eyeless Jack: You were walking around the mall with Jack, tons of bags in your hands. “Hey babe? I’ll be right back. I have to take a piss.” Jack told you, you nodded and he ran off. As soon as he was gone your ex Tiffany came running up to you, her blond curly hair bouncing.
“Ohmygosh y/n it’s been too long!” she hugged you before you could protest. “It’s been that way for a reason. Now leave me alone.” “But I want to ask you if you want to get a cup of coffee sometime.”
“Get away from my girlfriend!” you heard Jack yell. He came up and glared at Tiffany who ran away screaming. Jack sucked on your neck leaving a hickey. “Mine.”
Jeff The Killer: Sorry but we all know Jeff would just kill them. Which I’ve already pretty much written about.
Masky: Your ex boyfriend Chad had been calling you non stop. Texting you everyday trying to get you back together with him.
Masky eventually had enough and sent you with a cheesecake filled with poison. As Chad fell lifeless you heard Masky laugh.
Hoodie: Hoodie and you went to get some frozen yogurt, your favorite treat. The two of you got your delicious teat and sat down at a table outside. You smiled as some icecream got on Hoodie’s mask, taking a napkin you wiped it away.
