Ben Drowned: You were at the creepypasta mansion, bored. So you decided to go through the closets like the nosy bitch you are. (In a good way) You were in Eyeless Jack’s room when an idea popped into your head. Finding a black hoodie you yanked it on, and a mask similar to Jack’s. Running to the kitchen you opened the fridge and pulled out a kidney.
“Hey y/n?” You heard Ben call “In the kitchen!” he came in and as soon as he saw you said “Nope.” And walked out while you laughed your ass off.
Slenderman: You loved video games. It was something you did a lot in your free time. Secretly you loved Ben’s Link costume (Even though he’d never admit that’s what it was!) and one day you decided to steal it.
You dressed up, even put on a blond short wig, you ran into the kitchen and saw Slender there. Carefully you snuck up behind him and whispered “You shouldn’t have done that.” Before squeezing his ass and running off. He yelled “Ben what the fuck!” Ben walked in “What?” they both turned and looked at you. You gave a small wave before running upstairs into Slender’s bedroom and flinging yourself onto the bed.
You hid under the covers until Slender came to cuddle.
Eyeless Jack: In art class you had been assigned a project to make a mask. So here you were at the kitchen table, white mask in front of you, paint beside you.
You had no idea what to do with it. Until Masky walked in. Smiling sneakily you took the black paint and made the lips and eyeholes black. Skipping upstairs you stole one of Masky’s hoodies and pants. Even though they were too big on you. Then you ran into Jack’s room. He looked at you from the bed “Masky what do you want?” “Cheesecake!” you screamed as you threw some that you had grabbed out of Masky’s room. Jack was not happy about having to clean off cheesecake for the rest of the night. But he did like when you bathed together~~.
Jeff The Killer: You were watching Dr Smiley perform on one of his ‘patients’ (I say that word loosely) when his surgeon mask caught your eye. You wanted to try it on. After he finished up and the patient was dead you asked if you could borrow it. He reluctantly agreed. Taking a lab coat you threw both them on.
Then you went upstairs to where Jeff and Ben were sitting playing video games. You crept up behind them and when Jeff lost you screamed “I’ll fix you!!” causing Jeff to give a scream of surprise. You laughed your ass off. He wouldn’t talk to you until you took off Smiley’s mask.
Masky: Masky was terrified of Jeff. More then scared. Really you didn’t know why. But maybe that’s because Jeff is really just vicious and has random outbursts. So you decided to dress up like him.
Taking your makeup you drew a ‘carved smile’ and made your eyes widen by applying black eyeshadow all around them in a perfect circle. Using powder to make your face pale white you threw on a black wig. Taking a plastic knife you went to your room where Masky was sleeping on the bed. You pressed the knife against his neck and whispered “Go. To. Sleep.” Masky jumped a mile in the air and ran out of the bedroom. Eventually coming back unamused to find a laughing you, crying your makeup off.
Hoodie: Slenderman had recently given you an idea, you decided you wanted to dress like him. Just for a day.
You got a suit and tie and walked around, making sure to be polite about everything. And frankly it had been creeping Hoodie out. “Y-y/n could you p-p-please change b-back into your n-normal clothes?” He tried pleading with you “Don’t be rude child!” you said in a deep voice, Hoodie eventually gave up and decided to sleep until you decided to take off the slender clothes.
Laughing Jack: Jeff and you were both equally bored out of your minds so Jeff decided to dress you up (He’s a fashion designer now bitches) and after an hour of applying the perfect makeup you were ready.
Taking a knife in your hand you crept up behind Jack and whispered “Go to sleep.” He turned around and facepalmed. “Really y/n?”
Ticci Toby: You knew how much Toby liked to annoy Masky. So you decided to dress up as him. Pulling on a mask and hoodie you and Masky went and got plates of cheesecake.
“Hey Toby!” he turned around and you all threw the cheesecake at him. But it backfired when he started to chase you around.
Lost Silver: You decided to dress up as Sonic exe, putting fake blood dripping out your eyes. You snuck up behind Silver and screamed “I am God!” causing him to freak out and ran away, but he hit the door face first.
He started to cry and you kissed him and hugged him to calm him down.
Smiledog: (Dress up as enemy. Whatever.) Since Jeff was his owner it made sense to dress up as Jane the killer. The actual Jane helped you, as she has a sense of humour. With a black wig (if your hair is not black) black contacts, and a black dress, you were ready to go. You went into Jeff’s room where Smile was sleeping at the foot of Jeff’s bed. You went up to him and whispered “Don’t go to sleep you’ll never wake up.” Smile awoke.
Growling at you, since he thought you were Jane, he chased you around the house but realized who you were before you got seriously injured.
Dark Link: You decided to annoy Dark but dressing up as...yes you guessed it...LAUGHING JACK (You were expecting Ben or Link weren't you? Well too bad) you walked around with an old halloween bag filled with candy and made sure to laugh for no reason at all.
Dark eventually locked himself in the closet where Tom Cruise was (South Park reference? No? Okay.)
Glitchy Red: You were staring at your overflowing wardrobe, finger to your chin. In deep thought you tried to pick out what to wear. Red came in and chuckled at the sight of your morning routine. It always took you hours to pick out clothes. He came up behind you and wrapped his arms around you, kissing your cheek. “Babe why don’t you just dress like Hoodie? He wears the same thing everyday.” “Good idea!” you ran into Hoodie’s room and stole some clothes.
When you came back Red face palmed “I didn’t mean it…”
RadioFace: “Please Silver.” You begged, you had a complete Pokemon trainer but needed a hat. Silver couldn’t resist when people begged him. So he gave you his hat. “Yay! Radio look at me!” you screamed.
The rest of the day Radio kept glaring at Silver causing him to cry.
Homicidal Liu: (This one will be a bit different so…enjoy xD )
Liu was sitting on the couch. The two of you had been watching a movie when you left and it had been 20 minutes. You still hadn’t returned and Liu was getting impatient. “-Bitch where are you?!-“ Sully yelled. Silence. Liu got off his lazy ass and went to look for you. Heading upstairs he went into your room and there he saw you.
You wore a bright bleach blonde wig, neon green contacts, and leather pants. You wore no shirt or bra. “I’m Sully in another life! A hoe!” Sully burst out laughing while Liu just stared at you before cracking a smile.
