Five Nights at Freddy's (Natemare Story)

Night Five (Part 1)

Lily went straight to bed, but didn't fall asleep, curiosity getting the best of her as she was on her laptop. Going to YouTube, she typed in a name, seeing a bunch of videos popping up that they did. Clicking on the video of "Mangled", she skipped through a little bit of it until Natewantstobattle appeared, playing his electric guitar.

We're back, revamped! The madness never ends!

We're not alone. This time we brought some friends.

No doors. No hope. But you keep comin' back!

But if this is what you want, than you can be just like us.

"Wait a minute..." She said, pausing it at a moment where he was facing the camera. Her hand flew to her mouth. "Oh my god..."

He had the same features: the same color skin, the same size hands, the same black hair, and the same blue streaks on either side of his face. This isn't possible. He's too nice to be someone like that! But he looked exactly like him. Setting her laptop down, her eyes were still wide, figuring out why he would do this. Grabbing her phone, she called Mark again.

"Mark, it's me..I need to tell you something.." She said, not waiting for him to say anything after he picked up.

"Well hi to you too." He said. "What is it now?"

"I found out something big..and it's kind of..not good."

"And that is?"

She took a breath. "I looked up one of Natewantstobattle's videos..and it was bugging me all day so..I compared his voice...he's Natemare...he's the guy that saved me from being killed but..I think he's also the one controlling them.."

Mark scoffed. "You can't be serious..."

"I'm deadly serious!" She exclaimed. "It's him! He has the same exact voice and the same looks just more makeup!"

He sighed on the other end. "Well..if it is him...He's probably too far gone.."

"Which is why we'll stop him from doing more harm at night." Lily said.

"Wait you said 'we' in that sentence.."

"Yes I did. Because you're coming with me tonight, remember?"

Mark totally forgot, letting out a groan. "Dammit...that's right...alright fine..."

"Like I said before I'll be there at 11:30 tonight."

"Okay." Mark said, and hung up.

Setting her phone down, she climbed into bed, immediately falling asleep right away.

***

It was now after eleven at night, Lily awake and getting ready earlier than usual to pick up Mark. She's kinda curious to what his reaction will be once he sees what she's been telling him. All this time he hasn't believed her, but hopefully this time he will.

Once she had her uniform on, she brushed through her hair before grabbing her phone and flashlight before heading out. Locking her door, she went to her car, quickly backing out and leaving to go pick up Mark.

She saw him waiting out on his porch as she stopped by the driveway, watching him walk up and get in.

"Ready?" Lily asked.

Mark shrugged. "Mentally...no...physically...maybe."

Chuckling, she drove them to the pizzeria. She knows exactly how he feels. The first night she came to this place, she wasn't ready for what was in store for her. But now, she was prepared for the worst, ready for their attacks.

Once she parked by the place, they got out, walking up to the front doors.

"I already don't like the look of this place." Mark said as she opened the door.

"Trust me...it's not as pretty inside either." Lily said, leading him to the office.

But what made them stop, was a man standing there, their back turned to them.

"Mike?" Lily asked, recognizing the uniform jacket. "What're you still doing here?"

Mark raised an eyebrow as he slowly turned to face them.

"Oh you think I'm Mike?" He asked, lifting up his head, his raven black hair falling back just enough from his face, the blue streaks running down both sides of his face. "Guess again."

Lily's eyes widened, her hand flying to her mouth.

He's been Mike all along...everything is clicking into place now.

He's really Natemare.