The Bad Boy is My Best Nightmare

No It Isn't!

I'm sitting in the apartment Dalton and I share, crying into Cole's arms.

"Sweetheart he'll be fine, this isn't the first time." Cole says, rubbing my back, kissing the top of my head. Him and Dana are like brothers to me.

"What are you gonna do with that big fat butt...." Cole's phone blasts.

"I gotta take this." He says taking the call. I hear muffled voices from the other room.

"Fuck what happened, where is he?" a few second pause, "Dana! Fine, I'll be over in a few. I know, I'll call Jessica." Cole walks out after that.

"I gotta go but I'll my girlfriend Jessica to stay with you. I'll tell her to buy Ben and Jerry's so you two could a movie night. Dalton won't be back tonight but I will, except late." I nodded as he sent a text.

"She'll be here in 20."

"Okay"

Twenty minutes later there was a knock at the door. Cole opens it an a tall girl with dark brown hair walks in, bags from Wegmans in hand.

"Hi I'm Jessica" She says all cheery.

"Hi I'm Sutton"

"Alright I'll leave you two. Bye babe, bye Sutton." Cole says kissing Jessica's lips and my head. We wave goodbye as he walks out and shuts the door.

"Alright time to get down to business aka ice cream and movies!" Jess squealed happily. "We have 'Chubby Hubby' and 'Chunky Monkey' for ice cream and then 'Prom Night' and 'There's Something About Marry' for movies."

"Let's watch 'Prom Night'" I said taking the 'Chubby Hubby' ice cream and a spoon.

"Before we start I gotta learn a little about you, I bought you ice cream and movies." Jessica says laughing. I nod as I stick a spoonful of ice cream in my mouth.

"Well, my name is Sutton Robinson, I'm 17, almost 18. Dalton is my boyfriend who won't tell me shit and Cole and Dana are like older brothers to me."

"Well I'm Jessica Montgomery but soon-to-be Pendery, I found an engagement ring in Cole's room. I'm 18. Cole is my boyfriend, obviously and Dana is like an older brother to me too."

"How long have you and Cole been dating?"

"Five years"

"Wow"

"I know."

We talk about who we are. I found out Jessica is a laid back person who isn't really girly. She moved out here with Cole two years but they don't share an apartment even though she's normally at his.

"Okay, okay so Cole pissed his pants because he was scared of a snake?" I asked laughing as Jess was telling me a story.

"Yeah, it was only a garden snake too." She barely gets out.

"Wow"

"I know! Cole is such a baby!"

"I'm such a what?" a voice says. We turn to see Cole standing at the door.

"Oh hey babe..." Jessica says attempting not to laugh.

"What are you talking about?"

"Oh nothing.." I say bursting out laughing.

"Oh nothing?" he asks as he makes his was over towards me. His hands come at me and start to tickle me. "What did Jess tell you?"

"About..how...much of..a...fucking...sissy...you are." I barely get out in between laughs.

"Oh really now Jessica." He says making his way over to her. "I guess I have to punish you." He says smirking.

"Oh really. What are you gonna do Pendrey?"

"This!" He yells tickling her.

"Sutton, help me!" Jessica screams.

I walk over and start to tickle Cole. It's an all out tickle war until the door opens.

We look over and Dalton walks in.

"Cole I thought you said he wouldn't be home tonight!" I yelled storming off to the bedroom. I lock the door, grab my headphones and blast 'Goodbye' by My Darkest Days to drown out Dalton and Cole's pleading. I laid on the bed and sobbed so quietly over tonight that not even a bat could hear me.

The door opens but I don't look up, I hear Jessica tell the boys to leave and I'm encased in a hug seconds after that.

"It's going to be okay." Jessica attempts to comfort me.

"No it isn't!" I barely get out. "You and Cole have it so fucking perfect! Dalton and I are a wreak!" Saying that causes me to sob harder into Jessica's shoulder.