Confused And Conflicted. (SPN+Avengers reader insert)

Chapter 1

A year later Sam gets into an argument with John, bad enough that he leaves the hunting life- taking you with him. When Sam approaches Dean about it, Dean is hesitant at first. He eventually folds when he sees Sam's logic.

Within two years Dean, Thor and Loki have become nothing more than a vague memory. For you, your family is just Sam... until Sam meets Jess. You aren't sure of her at first, but eventually warm up to her.

When Halloween rolls around, Jess takes you trick-or-treating. Sam has to laugh when the two of you get back.

"Well someone's tired." Your brother says picking you up when he notices that you are half asleep. You mumble something in response but it's pretty much gibberish. Sam chuckles as he kisses your forehead before he carries you to his room and gets you ready for bed. He then sets you down on your small bed before turning out the light and leaving the room.

There is a sound outside of the apartment, which sets Sam on edge. He then notices that there is a man inside his apartment. Sam lunges forward and grabs the man by the shoulder. The man knocks SAM's arm away and aims a strike at your brother, who ducks. The stranger then sends your brother into another room. Eventually the stranger knocks Sam on his back and pins your brother to the floor.

"Whoa, easy, tiger." The man says. Sam instantly recognizes the voice. It belongs to Dean. Sam lets out an exasperated sigh.

"Dean?" Sam questions. Dean laughs. "You scared the crap out of me."

"That's 'cause you're out of practice." Dean replies. Sam grabs his brother's arm and slams him to the floor. "Or not. Okay get off me." Sam lets go of Dean and helps him to his feet.

"What the hell are you doing here?"

"I was looking for a beer." Sam throws his brother a bitch face. Then Jess turns on the light. She is holding your hand, apparently when your brothers were rough housing they woke you up and you went to Jess because you were scared.

"Sam?" Jess asks. Both men have a deer in the headlights look. Sam then realizes what happened.

"Hey Jess." Your brother says as he walks over to the both of you. "Dean, this is my girlfriend, Jessica. You already know Y/N."

"Wait, your brother Dean?" Jess asks as you tiredly walk over to Sam.

"Yeah." Sam replies as he picks you up and sets you on his hip. Dean asks if he could borrow Sam for a little bit. "No, whatever you want to say, you can say it in front of Jess and Y/N."

"Fine... Dad hasn't been home in a few days." Dean comments.

"So he's working overtime on a Miller Time shift. He'll stumble back in sooner or later."

"Rephrase... Dad's on a hunting trip. And he hasn't been home in a few days."

👑 👑 👑 👑 👑

Loki walks to the Bifrost to talk to Heimdall. The guardian of the Bifrost is the only one that actually knows your exact location.

"Is Y/N still in California?" Loki asks.

"No my prince. She is in a car, so I can't pinpoint her exact location." Loki sighs.

"Thank you Heimdall. Do you know where Thor disappeared to?"

"He's with my sister and the warriors three on Nidavellir, at the moment, celebrating their latest victory."

"Getting drunk on dwarven ale. I should've known." Loki mutters. "Also, I think that's the first time that I've heard you openly admit Sif is your sister." Everyone on Asgard knows about Heimdall's kinsmanship with the Lady Sif, but the two siblings rarely talk to one another- besides the two of them look so different that it's hard to believe that they are related.

👑 👑 👑 👑 👑

"Why does daddy have an eye patch?" You ask, catching both Sam and Dean off guard. Sam walks over to you.

"Baby, dad's never had an eye patch." He comments.

"What?" Your (eye color) eyes go wide, and your bottom lip trembles. With a sigh, Dean pulls out a picture and hands it to you. The picture is of your brothers, and a man that looks vaguely familiar to you is holding a bundle of blankets- you, more than likely.

"That's Dad." Dean says pointing to the man in the picture.

"Not that dad."

"Sweetheart, we only have one dad."

"What about the All-father?"

"All-father?"

"Dean, I think she means Odin from Norse mythology." Sam says, standing up and walking over to his bag and starts digging through it. He then pulls out a picture book of various Norse myths. "Which is completely my fault."

"You read that to her?"

"She wanted to know the legend about Loki convincing Thor to wear a wedding dress for some reason." Dean looks like he's about to say something but he decides against it and just shakes his head.