Sealed Shut(Creepypasta X Reader)(Very Slow Updates)

Chapter 4

Jeff's Pov

"No...Who listens to Jazz these days BEN?" I asked while slapping the back of the elf's head. He had turned around and punched my shoulder while pouting. Why does he make that face? He's starting to act like Sally. And not in a good way!

"I do! 'Who listens to "Rock" these days' JEFF!?" BEN mocked me while playing a bloody knife like it was a guitar. Wait a fucking minute...Is that my knife!?

I started to check my pockets frantically. BEN had noticed and looked at the knife along with myself, BEN slowly got off the bed and headed for the T.V. I had gotten up and chased him around until I grabbed his elf cap. I felt my ankles breaking on me as BEN moved side to side, evading all my attempts to grab him. He eventually hid behind (Y/N), he thought he was 'protected' by her. I walked up to both (Y/N) and Jackie and pointed with my right hand and held BEN's cap in the other.

"I believe you have something that belongs to me?" I asked sarcastically while holding my hand out.

"Let me wear his hat and you can have him~!" she said sassily while holding her hand out. She held it out the same way I did.

I started to snicker at her remark as she protected BEN. To be honest, this girl has the chest big enough to talk back to me. Smart kid......R e a l  S m a r t... (Y/N) and her friend stood up and gathered around BEN.

"Look, kid, I'm not here to play games with you nor am I here to kill you. But if you don't move I'll lock you in your closet. And I'll do it out of spite and just because you look like Kermit the Frog that had gotten into a fight with a bus right about now." I heard Jack snicker behind me. I felt a hand land on my shoulder as I started to growl.

"Jeff, she's not laughing right about now, and she doesn't look scared." Eyeless Jack stood next to me with his hand still on my shoulder. Jack faced in my direction, he can't see, but I know he can even without eyes.

We both have eye problems. He doesn't have any to begin with and I just can't close mine. His eyes were scooped out with a spoon and I burned my eyelids off with a lighter. I use eyedrops if anyone asks 'how do my eyes not dry out'. He hides his face with a mask, I show my smile off freely. As much as I pity Jack, it's his fault things like that happened to him.

BEN was staring at me like I was a deranged husky. Isn't that what we call a..."Smile dog"? I can see him wiping Mr.(L/N)'s blood on the back of (Y/N)'s sleeve.

~T A U N T I N G  M E  L I K E  I T'S  N O T H I N G~

I can see he wants his hat back, he's covering his head with (Y/N)'s hair. I looked at BEN then back at Jack. I held out elf boy's hat in return of my knife. (Y/N) surprisingly took hold of my knife from BEN and held it out in front of her. We both reach for the items and snatch it back quickly. BEN jumps up and down in glee as (Y/N) holds his hat. She holds the hat in front of her and stares at it intently. Didn't she say she wanted to wear it earlier? Oh BEN's gonna shit his man-skirt when he sees her wear it! Ha~!

Third Person's Pov

(Y/N) had continued to stare at BEN's hat. She then placed and fixed the cap on her head and looked at Jacklynn. She had a wide grin on her face as BEN's face was instantly filled with shock and hatred.

"How does it look on me-"

"GET MY CAP OFF YO DUSTY ASS HEAD!" BEN cried.

BEN pulled the cap off of (Y/N)'s head and started to shake it. A couple of things fell out:

A Hentai Magazine

A full unopened pack of Yu-Gi-Oh cards

And his cursed version of Majora's Mask

(Y/N) looked at the fallen items and just looked up at BEN with the same menacing grin that she gave earlier. BEN's face was twisted into a disgusted look, was she on his hit list at last? Jeff had coughed to break the intense situation that was going on. Then suddenly... 

Tap Tap

"Hey Jeffy, could I feel your thingy?" (Y/N) asked politely.

Eyeless Jack, Jeff the Killer, BEN Drowned, and Jacklynn Von Kasimer was looking at (Y/N) (L/N). Did she say something wrong?

"What's up with y'all?" She said while tilting her head in confusion.

Jackie proceeded to cry mentally and facepalmed physically. Jeff's face started to glow pink as he reached for Jack's shoulder and hid behind him. Jack just stood there, but if his mask wasn't on, you could see the devilish grin that he had plastered on his face. BEN was mentally scarred by what he had heard. BEN spoke up.

"Why would you want to touch Jeff's.....Carrot?" BEN asked. (Y/N) looked at BEN curiously then her face turned pink at the sudden saying.

"I DIDN'T MEAN HIS 'THINGY'! I meant his smile thing! On his face!" She screamed out. 

Everyone besides Eyeless Jack had to sigh in relief. Jeff came out from behind Jack and held his knife towards (Y/N).

"Keep your fingers away from my beautiful face, you little shit." He threatened. BEN started laughing and grabbed Jeff's knife again. He then ran towards the T.V and successfully reached the screen without a problem. Jeff was infuriated and he shouted imperiously. Jack had moved toward the window and started to crawl out without cutting himself on the sharp shards sticking from the edges of the window frame. He seemed to crawl out without a problem. Jeff trailed behind Jack and looked at the two girls.

"Get this room cleaned before we come back. And it won't be such a nice surprise to see me with a sharper knife-"

"That's only if you get it back from BEN." Jack had shouted lowly from downstairs in (Y/N)'s backyard and had cut Jeff's sentence off early. Only loud enough so all three of them can hear it.

Jeff had jumped from the window down to her backyard as well. (Y/N) had looked at Jacklynn and shrugged.

"Hey wait! What are we gonna do about the bodies!?" Jacklynn shouted outside. Loud enough that the neighbors might hear it. 

Jacklynn watched as Jeff and Eyeless Jack hid in some bushes and stopped moving. After about 4 minutes of looking around the house, Jacklynn's phone buzzed. Jackie looked at her phone and nodded silently. BEN had just texted her.[B/I BEN]

"Yo! The power's back on and we'll send some of our peeps over there to pick up the bodies."

"Also, tell (Y/N) that she left Booty Crumbs on my damn cap now Smile can't stop itchin'."

Jackie reached for the lights and turned the main hallway lights on just to take a look at (Y/N)'s partially ransacked house. Jackie headed for the stairs and started going down.

"Jackie! Where are you going!?" (Y/N) said sadly while looking at Jacklynn.

"I'm cleaning downstairs first. And BEN told me to tell you that you gave his smile 'Booty Crumbs' from wearing his hat." Jackie laughing mentally at BEN's childish humor.

(Y/N) started ranting on and on about how she could become BEN's friend and stop him from verbally bullying her. Yes, she is adorable and kind of crazy at times, but she'll make you laugh at some point. But, you gotta love her~

_____-------_____------_________-------

WoRD cOuNT-1,305