stepbrothers: dolan twins fanfic

[No, It's Wrong!]

I wake up in the middle of the night, to hear Avery crying. "Baby, its ok, its ok." I say to her comforting her. After a couple of minutes, she goes to sleep and I head back as I spot Ethan in the living room.

"Hey, E, you ok?" I sit down next to him. "Yeah, just stressed." He said running his hand through his hair. God that was sexy. Fuck! No! I'm with Gray!

I don't know what I'm doing as I climb onto his lap. "Cara, what are you doing?" He asks. "Shhhh." I say totally not thinking. I put my finger on his lip and drag it down to his chest.

"I love you so much E." I say as I kiss him and bite his lip as I pull away. "Cara, this is so wr-" I cut him off by kissing him again. This time he doesn't deny.

I don't know what I'm doing, but I care about him way too much, to see him stressed and worried. I may even like him more than I like Gray.

We make out for a while, and I feel is smile under the kiss. He wraps his hands around my waist and pulls me in closer. "Fuck, your so beautiful ." He says as he pulls away.

"Ethan, I love you so much. I just don't know what to do right now, with Avery and all. We can talk about this with Gray tomorrow." I say kissing his cheek.

"Night, Cara." He says giving me a hug. I hug him tightly and just hug him like that for a minute. I sink into his huge arms and I feel comforted. He gives me one last kiss on my forehead and I go back to the room.

"Where were you Cara?" Gray asks. "Oh, I was getting water." I say. "I can't sleep." I say as I get into bed. He cuddles next to me and I put my head on his shoulder.  I want to have a relationship with Ethan, but Grayson gives me so much love, and he's the father of my child.

I try to makeup my mins, and each time I always find myself leaning towards Ethan's side.

————-

Next Morning:

I wake up to hear the boys conversing outside. "Hey morning." I say sitting next to Ethan, which for some reason makes Shawn jealous. I feel so confused. Who am I supposed to fall for?

I see Avery in Gray's arms. "Precious little thing." He says kissing her nose. "Cara?" Ethan clears his throat. Oh no. Not right now. I don't wanna ruin this peaceful moment.

I don't answer and Ethan decided to say something. "Gray, we need to tell you something." He says. "Yeah?" He says looking up from Avery.

"Cara, and I we um, we made out last night." He says. Gray gives him a blank expression. He goes to put Avery down in the room.

He comes back with anger. "Cara!" He says loudly at me. "Your a hoe. That's what you are. And don't act depressed and shit, because that's the truth. You need to learn how to face it!!" He says in an even louder tone.

"And you, Ethan! I've always protected you as my brother, letting everything go. But this is too much. My gosh, we have a baby together. What kind of parent are you?!?" He says looking at me again. I have a blank expression on my face.

"I...Gr-....Sorry Gra-" Words can't come out of my mouth. "Oh don't say your fucking sorry, because your not. You have feelings for him, goddamnit." He says. Shawn sits their quietly, as more jealousy forms in his eyes.

"Can we all just calm down for a second?" I ask. "Fuck, calming down." Gray says.

I feel everything crumbling.

___________

📔 NEXT CHAPTER TMRW OR WEDNESDAY
📍apr 25/26
📚 follow me on insta: @mendespiano
@jaanki.shah