Falling For Dean Winchester

A New Case

Chapter 11

Once I arrived home, I immediately parked my car before heading inside the house and into the kitchen. As I walked in the kitchen, I saw Dean washing up the dishes and making everything clean while Sam was still in the living room on the phone.

"Well isn't this a great sight to see," I said, causing Dean to turn his head around to see me.

"Do you not have guys often in your home?" Dean asked.

"Well with a five year old daughter and being a hunter as well as being a supernatural creature, life gets a little complicated," I answered.

"I can imagine," Dean said.

All of a sudden, Sam came back into the room.

"Hey," I said.

"Hey," Sam said before taking a seat.

"What's wrong?" I asked.

"Sammy?" Dean asked.

"Look Dean, you're not going to want to hear this but I've got a source that's told me that we've got a vamp kill in Carencro, Louisiana," Sam said.

"And why wouldn't I like to hear that?" Dean asked.

"Because the source is Martin Creaser," Sam answered.

"I'm sorry but for a minute there I thought you said Martin Creaser," Dean said.

Sam said nothing to this.

"Crazy Martin from the looney bin?" Dean questioned.

"They discharged him last month," Sam said.

"And?, shouldn't he be assembling toys in a patted room?, what's he doing back on the job?" Dean asked.

"I asked him," Sam answered.

"You what?" Dean questioned.

"Look, he called me when he got out, okay?, asked if I had anything for him that might help him ease back into the game, he seemed okay mostly so I said okay. I've been having him track Benny for the last week," Sam explained.

"Yeah, Benny Lafitte," I sniggered.

"Yeah, that's right. How do you know Benny?" Sam asked.

I then said nothing at first as the boys began to look at me for a moment before I finally said...

"Uh guys, I was just kidding. Benny Lafitte is in Purgatory, it was just a joke," I said.

"Well Benny isn't in Purgatory anymore, I got him out," Dean said.

"Wait here a minute," I said before leaving the kitchen and heading into the living room.

I then grabbed one of my photos before heading back into the kitchen and putting the photo on the kitchen side.

"You mean this Benny?" I asked as I showed the boys the photo of Benny and myself.

"Yeah that's him," Dean said.

"So, you got Benny out?" I questioned.

"Yes," Dean answered.

"Oh my god," I said as I stood there in shock.

After some moments of silence, Dean then turned back to Sam and said...

"You put mostly okay Martin on Benny?, what is mostly okay doing hunting at all?" Dean questioned Sam.

"Not hunting, Dean. Tracking. Observe and report only, I was crystal clear about that," Sam said.

"Wow I can't believe that," Dean said.

"Really Dean you don't believe that?, because Benny's a vampire and any hunter with a soul isn't going to let one walk around freely like that so I had Martin keep tabs on him and right now it's looking like I made the right call," Sam explained.

"Look Sam, whatever you may or may not think, I've known Benny for a very long time and he's not bad and that's the truth," I said.

"And how long is a long time?" Sam asked.

"Since before you were born," I answered.

"People change and maybe now I finally have a proof of what a bad guy Benny is," Sam said.

"So Martin's saying that Benny did this?" Dean asked.

"Yeah," Sam answered.

"Okay," Dean said.

"Okay?" Sam questioned.

"If Benny is in Louisiana draining folks then we should look into it," Dean said.

"But he's not," I said.

"We'll see," Sam said before heading out of the kitchen and out of the house.

After he left, I watched as Dean finished the washing up before I turned to him and said...

"Dean, you know Benny. Just like I do and we both know that Benny is not capable of doing this," I said.

"I know, which means that this will just be proof that Benny is a good guy and hopefully it will convince Sam that he can trust Benny," Dean said.

"I like the way you think," I said.

"Come on, lets go," Dean said before we left the kitchen and out of the house.

Once we left the house, we all got into the impala before driving off down to Louisiana...