Fulfilling a Promise ([Ib] Garry x Reader)

A Pleasureable Night (LEMON ⚠️)

(Warning: sexual content and profanity ahead! This is just a continuation of the previous fluff chapter, it does not add on to the story, so you do not have to read it if you don't want to. Thank you, and you've been warned.)
I look over at (Y/N). Their head is in the nook of my neck, their (S/C) skin tinted gold from the light, and (E/C) eyes bright, intrigued. I smile lovingly, and guide their chin with my hand to face me, as I gently press my lips against theirs. After the release, I embrace them and whisper into their ear,
"I love you, (Y/N)."
"I love you too, Garry."
I place my hand on (Y/N)'s face and gently caress their cheek with my thumb. As they nuzzle against my rather large hand with the side of their face, their eyes flutter open and look deep into mine. They give me such a tender and warm smile, but their (E/C) eyes say quite the contrary; they're luring me in. I kiss them again, this time with a hint of heat. (Y/N) responds to this by gently grazing their tongue over my bottom lip, wanting in.
Damn, someone's a bit eager, huh?
I open my mouth but only to tackle their tongue with my own, getting a moan from them as a reward. My hands trail down to their waist, as I gently yet firmly pull them closer towards me. They wrap their arms around my neck and sink their hands into my lavender hair after taking off the beanie I was wearing and tossing it away. As our lips separate and the thin string of saliva breaks, we look back into each other's eyes, both of us knowing what the other wants. (Y/N) speaks, their voice a bit huskier.
"I think you know what I want, Garry..."
I attempt to tease them.
"Do I?"
"You just want me to say it, huh?"
I give them a suggestive smirk, but to their surprise, I loop my arms under their legs and carry them to their bedroom.
I'll spare you this time, (Y/N).
As I walk in the open door with them in my arms, they cup their hands around my cheeks and kiss me deeply. I gently put them down on the bed and straddle their waist, pinning their arms above their head and attempting to kiss them even deeper. This kiss has gone on for quite some time, and has evolved to more than just a passionate kiss. We've started grinding against each other and moaning into each other's mouths in the heat of the moment. As the need for air finally comes, we break the kiss, and I let go of their hands. I cup my hand around the side of their face and caress their cheek with my thumb as I look at them with as much warmth and care as I can.
"Are you okay with this?"
Their face flushes a bit as they look away bashfully.
"Y-Yes. I can't think of anyone I'd rather have my first time with."
I smile warmly and plant a small kiss on their forehead.
"I'll be gentle, don't worry, (Y/N)."
I again press my lips against theirs, but not for long, for I soon trail kisses down their jaw and soon to their neck, as they tilt their head up in pleasure. Hesitant moans escape from their vocal chords as I get closer and closer to their sweet spot. They shiver as I tease the spot once I find it, and after a bit of this I stand up from the bed and pull them up with me. I pull them closer to me by their waist as I kiss them deeply once again, starting to trail my hands around their figure, as they do the same. They start to tug on my flannel, so I quickly take it off and pin them to a nearby wall with their arms up, beginning to strip them down.
Only in their undergarments now, looking a bit timid and flushed, they start to do the same to me, lifting up my tank top as I raise my arms up to help them. They then try to unbutton my jeans, but they seem to be really nervous, and their hands are shaking quite a bit. I chuckle as I guide their hands to the button and zipper, patient, yet eager for when their hands want to travel lower still.
"(Y/N), are you okay?"
"I..I think so, maybe a bit nervous.."
Once they manage to unbutton my pants, I hold both of their hands and look into their eyes.
"You're going to be fine, (Y/N). I have no intention of hurting you or making you feel unworthy. I love you so much, and I just want to show you just how much that's true."
I embrace them, and like a habit, they wrap their arms around me as well.
"Thank you, Garry..I love you just as much."
They give me a small peck on the lips, and takes a deep breath before sitting back down onto the bed. With their permission, I hesitantly take off the little they have left on their beautiful body, and kissing them deeply once again while holding them close and letting my hands help themselves. Mid kiss, they reach for my underwear, oh so timidly.
They were acting all frisky in the beginning, did I do something wrong?
Once they remove my underwear, I look at them tenderly.
"So..what should we do now?"
"Um..I was thinking something like this, if you're okay with it..."
Before they finished their sentence they slid down the edge of the bed and got on their knees and looked up at me, all flushed and helpless looking. I was taken back a bit, but..seeing them on their knees for me like this..Fuck, they look so good..H-Hey now, calm down, Garry.
"I'm alright w-with that if you are, (Y/N)..."
They hum in approval, then soon after, they take my cock into their mouth, gently suckling. For a virgin, they're quite good at this, and before long I'm moaning and panting like an animal. Occasionally, they open their eyes and look up at me with an expression I can only describe as playful yet helpless, even slightly manipulative, (in a good way of course) like they know how good they're making me feel. It gets to the point where I can't help myself anymore. I want them. I need them.
"Okay, (Y/N)..that's enough.."
They look up at me with curiosity.
"Oh, I'm sorry, did I do something wrong?"
"Not at all, sweetie,"
I say as I reach over to their bedside drawer, reaching for a condom.
"I just don't think I'm able to control myself anymore~"
(Y/N)'s face turns completely red, and they make a small whimper of wanting. After putting on the condom, I pick them up and set them back on the bed, right before kissing them deeply once again. I whisper to them to turn around and get on their all fours, and they behave very quickly. They might be just as eager as I am. I get into the position I need to be in, but I ask them something before I start.
"Are you absolutely sure you're okay with this?"
"Of course. Just please, go easy on me at first? I've never done this before.."
"Okay then. Tell me if you need me to stop, alright?"
After a hum of approval and a deep breath, I insert myself inside them slowly. They flinch just a bit at first, but once their whimpering stops, I know that they're ready. I set a slow, steady pace at first, and we're already moaning huskily, eager for more. After awhile, I start to pick up the pace, and the both of us become even more animalistic, eventually getting to the point of nearly screaming each other's names in ecstasy. Then comes the orgasm, and all of our tension is resolved with satisfying exhaustion following suit. I pull out, and after disposing of the condom, I lay with (Y/N) on the bed, embracing them fully and gently squeezing them.
"I love you so much, Garry.."
"I love you more, (Y/N)."
"You sure about that?"
"Let's save that for tomorrow. Just get over here and rest, sweetie.."
With no hesitation after those words, they snuggle up even closer to me as we get underneath the covers. I kiss their forehead one last time before drifting off to sleep, both of us with slight smiles on our faces.

1417 words

Hope y'all enjoyed, ya freaks~