Him

Part 7

Caleb: "Yes! That sounds fun. I'll go first. Truth or dare Noah?"
Noah: "Dare."
Caleb: "I dare you to dance to the Stranger Things theme song in front of us all."
Noah: "Okay, who has the music?"
You: "I got it!"
You play the theme song and Noah dances like an idiot in front of everyone and has everyone laughing.
Noah: "Alright Sadie, truth or dare?"
Sadie: "Truth."
Noah: "Kiss, marry, kill with Finn, Gaten, Caleb."
Sadie: "Yikes that's difficult. Uhm... kiss Gaten, marry Caleb, and kill Finn."
Finn: "I feel offended. How dare you kill me?"
Sadie: "I'm sorry!"
Millie: "I guess we know who she really likes in the group. Kidding!"
Sadie: "Very funny. (Y/N), truth or dare?"
You: "Truth."
Sadie: "Who from the cast would you date?"
Gaten: "Alright getting interesting now!"
You: "In all honesty, I would probably date Noah because I know him best."
Everyone is looking at you, but you look at Noah and see him start to blush and look down when you say that you would date him. It's the truth, and you actually think that you might have feelings for him, even though you just became friends the day before. Will was always your favorite on the show, and you would stalk Noah's Instagram because you practically loved him. Now that you're here, hanging out with him, you're starting to develop real feelings, not just fan girl feelings.
Millie: "Okay (Y/N), give someone a truth or dare!"
You: "Fine. Millie, truth or dare?"
Millie: "Dare."
You: "I dare you to kiss Gaten' hand."
Gaten: "What?!"
You: "You heard me."
Everyone starts laughing as Millie walks over to Gaten and kisses his hand.
Gaten: "What a nice kiss Millie."
Millie: "Wow, thanks."
Everyone breaks out in laughter again and Millie asks Noah truth or dare.
Noah: "Dare again."
Millie: "Okay, I dare you to kiss (Y/N)'s hand!"
Noah: "Easy."
He walks over to you and gives you a soft kiss on your hand and you feel like you melt inside. He sits down confidently.
Noah: "Finn, truth or dare?"
Finn: "Truth."
Noah: "Who from the IT cast are you closest with?"
Finn: "I'm going to let someone else answer that because surely someone knows."
You: "Jack?"
Finn: "Yes! I feel like everyone should know this by now."
Noah: "Oops."
Finn: "Caleb, truth or dare?"
Caleb: "Dare."
Finn: "I dare you to pick up Sadie and walk around the room for a minute."
Caleb: "That's weird, but okay."
Caleb picks up Sadie very fast, making her scream a little when he suddenly picks her up. You watch them laughing because it's ridiculous how Caleb is struggling and almost drops her. You're really staring to bond with this cast and everyone has been so amazing.
You: "What movie are we going to watch?"
Noah: "I actually have a special one planned for you guys."
Millie: "What do you mean?"
Noah: "I got a copy of the movie Love, Simon! We're going to watch that if it's ok with all you guys."
You: "Are you serious? I've wanted to see that movie for so long!"
Everyone heads into the movie room and takes a seat. You're so excited to watch it! Noah sits down next to you because you chose an end seat.
Sadie: "Guys, let's make a deal."
Caleb: "What do you mean?"
Sadie: "Well, I'm assuming we've all wanted to see this movie. Right?"
Everyone agrees.
Sadie: "How about no one talks at all during the movie, so we can enjoy it more."
Caleb: "I'm down."
Finn: "Yeah, sounds like a good idea."
Sadie: "We can laugh and maybe cry if we need to, but no talking."
Noah: "Okay. That's the one rule we will follow."
Noah turns on the movie and you look around and everyone smiles, excited to watch it.
After about an hour and 15 minutes pass by, there's a really sad part in the movie and you start to tear up. You look over at Noah and Finn sitting next to him. They both are fine and have no tears, but all the sudden you have tears streaming down your face. Noah's hand is open on the arm rest of his chair and you take it. Noah is confused at first, but then looks at you and understands. You look at him and he has a small smile on his face and that makes you happy.
Another 10 minutes pass by, and you're still holding Noah's hand. You look around and everyone is tearing up and crying. The movie had another emotional moment and there isn't a dry eye anywhere. You're crying the hardest though, but you don't know why. Noah notices and gives a small laugh only you can hear. You lean into him and rest your head on his shoulder while you're crying.
When the movie is over, you're still laying on Noah and everyone notices, but no one says anything because they're all a crying mess.
Millie: "That was really good."
Gaten: "Yeah."
Everyone agrees and is wiping their eyes and Noah stands up.
Noah: "Who needs tissues?"
You: "I think I need them the most. I was crying for like the last 45 minutes."
Everyone starts laughing and you guys discuss the movie.
Noah: "So, what did you guys think?"
You: "I loved it. It was such a beautiful story honestly."
Sadie: "Yeah, same. I'm glad we all agreed to never talk because I enjoyed it more that you guys weren't talking all the time."
Finn: "I would've been talking like the whole time."
Millie: "Finn, we already know this."
Finn: "Oops."
Sadie: "(Y/N) do you want to go upstairs with me and get something to drink?"
You: "Sure."
Millie: "I'll come with you guys too, I'm super thirsty. What cups do you want us to use Noah?"
Noah: "Just use the plastic cups."
Millie: "Okay, we'll be back."
You walk up the stairs with Millie and Sadie and they make sure Noah's mom isn't around and you're confused.
Sadie: "Okay. We saw you holding Noah's hand and leaning into him during the movie."
Millie: "Do you like him? Does he like you? Are you secretly dating? What is going on?!"
You: "Woah, slow down. Me and Noah aren't dating, but I think I might like him. I mean he's super sweet and nice to me and I don't even know why! I was just some fan that was saying hi at the grocery store and he's been so nice ever since. Also he's really good looking, if I do say so myself. But when he kissed my hand for that dare I felt like happy inside and I don't really know what is going on with me. I've never had a boyfriend or had someone I was majorly crushing on until I met him!"
Millie: "Aww! That's so cute."
Sadie: "Yeah, I totally ship you guys. You were so cute earlier."
You: "Haha thanks guys, but I feel like there could be a chance he could like me back."
Sadie: "What do you mean?"
You: "Well, when I said I would date Noah, I looked at him and he was looking at the ground blushing. I don't know if this means something though, because this has never happened to me before."
Millie: "Well my advice is, whenever you're ready, tell him how you feel and see how it goes."
You: "Thanks guys. I'm so glad I have you as friends here."
Sadie: "We're glad we met you."
You guys hug and get your water, but you have one last question for them.
You: "Should I tell him about how I feel?"