Bad Love? Butters Stotch x Reader

1

My name is Y/n L/n.

I am born different I guess you could say I don't have emotions so I usually fake it all... And I feel like I was meant to be a sociopath... I mean... My parents died before I turned 5 years old. They had died in a burning house started by me... Yes they don't live because of me. I've been in the orphanage as long as I can remember but I am 9 years old now and a family has decided to adopt me.

"Y/n? Here are some people who'd like to meet you!" Miss Lucy says with joy and I turn to see a family of four "Hello y/n, I'm Sheila Broflovski" the woman says "hello Sheila" I say "I'm Gerald her husband" the guy says "greetings Gerald" I say and I look at the two boys. "Well hello and you two are..." I say trailing off.

"Ike!!" The young boy says "I-I'm Kyle" the older boy says "hello to all of you my name is Y/n L/n" I say getting up and shaking each of their hands. "Dad why we we here?" The older boy says "were going to adopt a sister for both you and Ike" the dad answers. "Are these the great people you mentioned miss Lucy?" I say.

"Yes they are! Would you like to go home with them tomorrow?" She asks "I would love to have a family again" I say smiling. "Wonderful! Now if you'll follow me and we'll get this situated" miss Lucy says as the boy named Kyle glares at me.

~Skip to the next day~

"You have all you things packed?" Miss Lucy says "yep I do" I say "there they are!" She says with joy "yep my new family" I say watching as they pull up "ready?" Gerald asks "ready Gerald" I say with a smile "please call me dad if you want and you can call Sheila mom as well" he says.

"Goodbye miss Lucy" I say and she gives me a big hug "goodbye y/n" she says and I leave as Gerald opens the door to let me in the car "thank you" I say as I sit down and he closes the door. I wave bye to miss Lucy as we drive away. "So y/n are you excited to see your new room?" Sheila asks "I get a room?" I ask "yes you do!" She says.

"Then I am!" I say with a smile "good to hear!" Gerald says "haha" I laugh and the little boy Ike laughs to. "Oh hey Ike is also adopted!" Sheila says "really? I guess there are two now! Unless Kyle is to" I say looking at him "no! I'm not" he says in a yelling sort of tone "Kyle no yelling at her" Gerald says and I give a slight smirk to my self.

~2 hours later~

"Were here! South Park! Home sweet home" Gerald says as he pulls up to a house. "Whoa" I say looking at their house. "Come on we'll show you your room" Sheila says I look around to see other kids staring at us. I follow Sheila to a room up stairs "here it is!" She says showing me a room with a bed with plain white sheets and a plain white dresser with a desk for me to sit at.

Some small stuff animals laying along the bed as I walk in. A few children's books set on my new desk "do you like it?" She asks "I love it!" I say and she smiles "perfect now you can unpack and we'll show you the rest of the house" she says and walks out. I start to place my clothes into the dresser along with my notebook no one knows about. After putting in my underwear in the bottom drawer I place a little bottle in the back. That little bottle has a liquid in it known as poison the best way to murder someone...

I closed my drawer to hear a knock. I look over to see the boy Kyle standing there "my mom asked me to show you around town if you'd like" he says seeing his expression he didn't want to "I'd like to" I say grabbing my jacket. He sighs and mumbles as I follow him downstairs to the living room.

"Ok mom I'm going to show her around town now!" He yells "ok be careful!!" She yells back "lets go" he says and we walk outside. Putting on my I'm lets do this!' Face so I look natural "let go introduce you to my friends" he says as we make a turn at the corner then seeing four boys playing basket ball or what looks like it.

We got closer to the basket ball court and the one is an orange parka notices us and Kyle yells "hey guys!" Catching all of their attention "who is this?" One boy asks scanning my face "Y/n and now its Y/n Broflovski" I say holding out my hand "wait what!?" They all get shocked "this is my new adopted sister y/n" Kyle says.

"And y/n these guys are Stan, Eric, Kenny, and he's Butters" Kyle says pointing at each boy "hello" I say holding my hand out to Stan and he shakes it. Next I went to shake hands with Kenny but he pulled me up to his body and my reflex kneed him in the crotch "sorry" I say and go to shake hands with Eric "sorry I don't touch Jews especially girl Jews" Eric says.

"I'm not Jewish I'm adopted idiot" I say skipping him and walking to Butters interesting name for a boy. "H-hello! I'm Butters!" He says with a lot of joy "Hello Butters I'm Y/n!" I say with fake joy. His face seemed to turn a shade of pink as I shake hands with him.

"Dude she's weird!" Eric says "shut up fatass" Kyle says "I'm not fat you Jew! I'm big boned" He yells "funny I didn't know bones resemble jello" I say making them laugh. "That's not funny Bitch" he says with a growl "well if its not funny then they wouldn't have laughed" I say with a monotone voice.

"Come on y/n I'd better show you around so my mom knows you actually seen it" Kyle says grabbing my arm "ok." I say as we walk through town "hey kyle, whoa this? Is she your girlfriend?" A boy with a blue chullo hat says "no she's not Craig she's my new adopted sister" Kyle says "adopted?" Craig repeats.

"Yes adopted, my name is Y/n!" I say with a smile but he flips me off "That's not nice!" I say with a small fake pout "its his natural instinct" Kyle says. "Bye now" Craig says then walks away.

~few minutes later~

"Mom were back!" Kyle yells "great! Right before dinner!" Sheila says from the kitchen so I go in there "hello y/n how was it?" She asks "it was great!" I say "I have a question" "what is it?" She says "are you guys Jewish?" I ask "oh why yes we are! I forgot to say" she says "its alright!" I say and she smiles.

After we ate dinner we got ready for bed because I was going to school the next day. Something though didn't seem right... Meeting that boy Butters has changed something for my future I can tell...