Bad Love? Butters Stotch x Reader

3

I was in my room minding my business when Ike entered.

"What are you doing?" He asks "nothing that is in your concern" I say as I continue to read information from different books. "If you not busy there is a boy at the door for you" he says then leaves. A boy? Oh no. He can't be part of the plan I just planned.

I go down to see Butters at the door. "Hey butters" I say and he looks up "hey y/n!" He says "what do you want?" I ask "I wanted to know if you wanted to go to the park? Everyone is going" he says. Everyone. Even the red head girl.

"Ok why not" I say and put on my shoes. We both walk outside and to the park. As we got closer I seen everyone ice skating and some on a playground. Red head was on the playground.

(Ye I'm going to add a park)

"I have a little question" I say "w-what is it?" he says "why did you bring me here?" I ask "well your my friend and everyone is here mostly" he says. "Thank you" I say.

"Hey Butters!!" Someone yells distracting Butters. I watch as the red headed girl that pushed me yesterday walked on the playground going up the stairs to the slide. I run away from butters real quick and go up the stairs quietly but fast. As she slowly walked to the slide I slowly followed behind.

She made it to the end and was going to turn around when I made my chance and pushed her real hard making her go flying hitting the slide then hitting the ground probably breaking something. I hear her cry as I smirk to myself then I see Ike's eyes watching me...

I just slowly walk away making my way back to Butters as their conversation seemed to be almost done. I stand right where I was then he turns "what happens to her?" He asks "I don't know" I say "she broke her leg!!" Someone yelled and I tried not to laugh in front of everyone like a psycho.

Sometimes I scare myself. I think as I watch her mother run to her. "Butters I'm not comfortable here" I say tugging at his sleeve "o-ok lets go I guess" he says and we walk away. He took me to a place called Tweak Bros, It was a coffee place. Once we walked in it smelled so nice.

"Gah! Hey Butters and oh no i forgot!" He yells "I'm y/n" I say "m-my name is Tweek, what do you guys want" he says and Butters get a what he wants and I get (drink you like). Butters paid for mine and I kept trying to give him money for mine but he rejected it.

"Ok guys ill bring it r-right over once its done!" Tweek says and we find a table. "Do you think she's going to be fine?" Butters asks sounding worried "who" I say "the girl by the slide!" He says "why?" I say "because she's just a kid like you and me" he says pointing to me then himself "yea all she hit was her leg when I-" I covered my mouth.

"What? Say that again" "I said she'll be fine she broke her leg right? A doctor can fix that in no time" I say covering my mistake "well I guess your not wrong they did fix my eye" Butters says "what" I say looking at his eyes noticing a scar. "What happened" I say looking at it "a ninja star was thrown at my eye by my friend Kenny" he explains.

Now that I notice his left eye is a lighter blue than his right. "When?" I ask "like a few months ago? I'm not sure it feels like a long time ago" he says. "Oh did it hurt really bad" I say and he nods. Most of the time he talked, he did have interesting stuff to say that I didnt even know I would want to hear.

But since time sucks we had to go home. "Bye y/n!" He says walking his way since he walked me home "bye butters!" I say and go inside. "Where were you?" Kyle's voice says "I was with butters" I say and look at him "Ike told me you pushed someone and hurt them" he says "why would I hurt anyone?" I say

"Maybe to get revenge" Kyle says "or maybe someone else has the same (hair color) as me or even the same shirt" I say trying not to stab daggers at him "or I can believe my brothers words and say its you!" He yells "how do you knowm" I say back. "Ike has proof" he says all cold. "Momma!!" I yell "what is it y/n!?" Sheila says coming in.

"Kyle" I say pointing at him "what!?" He says "Kyle is being mean!" I say with tears forming in my eyes "Kyle go to your room you can come out when dinner is done!" She orders and he scoffs then goes to his room.

Haha.. Ok now to figure out a plan to meet this professor chaos.

~time skip to the next day~

I walked into the room and sat down in my spot next to Kenny. "Did you really push red??" Kenny asks "no, I'd never hurt a soul" I say and the intercom comes on.

"Y/n Broflovski come to the counselors office m'kay"

"Ooooohh" the kids say as I leave to the counselors office. I knock on the door "come in" he says and I do. I see the red headed girl sitting there with a broken leg and I try not to smile. "Take a seat y/n" he says and I do.

"Red told me your the one that pushed her causing her to break her leg m'kay" he says "I wouldnt do such a thing" I say "lies!" The red head yells "is it lies to say your pushed me down yesterday!" I yell at her "is this true red?" He says "so maybe it is but I'm not budging" I she says "I have a bruise to prove it" I say showing him my arm.

"Seeing this made me sad to think I've been hated on the first day" I say sounding depressed "liar" red says "I think y/n needs to talk to a relative m'kay?" He says and does the intercom again.

"Kenny McCormick to the counselors office m'kay"

Wait what. The door swings open "what I do now Mackey" Kenny says entering "Kenny I would like you to talk to your cousin for a bit to clear things up with her m'kay?" He says "red isn't my cousin" Kenny says "not her, y/n" he says and Kenny looks at me.

"What..." He says "you guys are aware your cousins right?" The counselor says "we are cousins!?" Kenny yells. "Ok ill explain red go to class" Mackey says and she does.

"I cant believe your my cousin" Kenny says "yes I didnt think id be related to a parka kid" I say looking at him. We turned our attention to the counselor and let him explain.

"Y/n your records say that your mother is Kenny's mom sister making you and Kenny cousins" he says "it also says your dad is-" "we dont need to know" I say cutting his sentence off.

"So does that mean I have to meet my aunt I never knew about?" I say "that's only if you want to m'kay" he says "so now I know were you get your stunning beauty" Kenny says "that's gross your my cousin" I say staring at him.

"So now that is clear I want you two to talk to each other to help y/n m'kay" he says and walks out. "Your ugly" I say to Kenny "you are to" he says "I'm sorry ive just been wanting to say that" I say "what do we talk about" Kenny says. "I dunno" "did you push red?" Kenny asks "no I didnt" I say and he looks at me closer.

"Not lying? Hmm" he says "if I lie I wouldn't be here" I say "wanna know something?" Kenny says "what" I say "I can't die" he says. Liar. "Wanna know a secret?" I say and he nods "I don't give a dam" I say and he looks shocked.

"Still don't see how your my cousin" he says "beauty remember?" I say to him reminding him of his words. He's a perv, and I'm pretty sure being cousins isn't going to stop him. "Why are you always straight faced?" He asks "because I... Would you like to know a actual secret and since your my cousin you cant spill" I say and he nods.

"I was born emotionless, I say broken" I say "but you were crying yesterday and smiling" he says confused "its called acting" I say "oh... That must be hard" he says "not at all!" I say and remember and emotion I felt that was real. "Hey Kenny?" I ask "yea?"

"Whats Love"