Ordinary // Peter Parker x Reader

Mind Made Up

Y/N POV:

It was Friday and I could not be more excited for the next day. Peter and I were going to a coffee shop near my apartment that had recently opened up. I was really excited to check it out, as I had heard good things about it. Apparently their chocolate chip cookies and bagels were to die for.

I was also excited because it would be our first time hanging out just the two of us. We did go to the emergency room together, but I wouldn't really consider that a good first date.

"Was this a date?" I thought to myself walking to school.

I was so confused. I really like Peter, and I have since I first laid eyes on him a month and a half ago. But 2 weeks ago, Todd walked into my life, or rather I bumped into his life, but nonetheless I had feelings for him too. "But who do I choose? Would I have to choose? God I hope not," I thought to myself as I reached the front doors of the school. "Why is this so confusing?"

Walking in, Todd spotted me and came up to say hello.

"Hey N/N (nickname), how are you?" Todd asked walking towards me.

"Hey Todd, I'm good, just tired," I said whilst opening my locker and getting my materials for my first period.

"Hey so I've been thinking," Todd said looking down shyly. I thought this odd, as he has a very bold personality. Then my heart started to flutter. "I uh, I..." he stumbled with his words as if he was on trial for murder.

"Is everything okay Todd?" I asked getting to be a bit worried that something was wrong.

"I uh, meet me after school in the courtyard okay? Around 3:30?" he said looking at his phone for the time.

"Sure, I'll see you then I guess," I said to him as he waved goodbye. "Weird," I thought as I started to walk to my next class.

I walked in the class and I saw Peter sitting at his desk rummaging through his backpack probably looking for the notes from last class. I saw him get a little look of fear when he couldn't immediately find them, but relief took over when he finally pulled them out of his backpack, letting out a small sigh of relief.

I let out a quiet laugh and looked at him a second more before sitting down at my seat, diagonally from Peter.

He looked up from his notes and smiled in the cute way he always did. Almost like he was relieved to see me.

"H-Hey Y/N," Peter said.

"Hey Peter," I said with a smile.

And just like that the conflicted feelings were back. Todd or Peter? I thought of Todd, but the second I did I looked back at Peter. I smiled and continued with the notes in class, knowing I had made up my mind once and for all.

Hey guys woah it's been a long time sorry for never updating I just guess I got bored with the story. If enough people want me to continue I will but I'm also starting a new book for Peter Maximoff (I got a thing for Peters haha). Also thank you guys for 3k reads! I can't believe it! I love you all and couldn't have done it without you! I'll start writing the other book pretty soon here and update this from time to time as more of a casual thing unless a lot of people really want me to continue. Until the next chapter!
- Mia