13 Reasons Why Imagines

Justin Foley - Forbidden

Request: Well if you're not tired of writing about Justin then a Justin x Reader where the reader is the Scott's little sister/twin sister (whatever you like better) but Scott and Justin do not like each other, which is why Scott does not approve that the two of them are getting closer.

You and Justin had slowly started to become closer and closer the more you spent time together. You'd been tutoring him for a while now, helping him get his grades up so he could graduate with your class after the five months he spent homeless on the streets.

You still couldn't fathom how someone your age could live like that with no support, family or home. You really wanted to help the boy and you felt yourself liking him more and more after every tutor session.

However, your twin brother, Scott, did not approve of you tutoring Justin, he didn't hate the guy, but he merely disliked him and thought he was a bad influence on you, telling you constantly that he was a heroin addict and who knows what doing time in juvenile prison had done to him.

Nevertheless, you defended Justin to Scott, knowing that he has a rough family background and has gone to hell and back. You appreciated your brother looking out for you, but he couldn't change your opinion on Justin and you were in too deep to pull out now.

"(Y/N) I don't want you tutoring him, he's a bad influence on you and the guy let a guy rape his girlfriend, what the fuck are you doing spending so much time around him?" Scott said to you, outside the library at school.

"You were fucking best friends with the rapists Scott, do you remember that?" You replied, getting pissed off that he'd even brought that up.

"I regret that, you know I do, (Y/N)-"

"Well so does he, he lived on the streets for months just so Jessica wouldn't have to see him again!"

Scott sighed, clearly understanding that he couldn't change your mind.

"Well, just, make sure it stays at a tutor, student level okay? I don't want you becoming friends with an addict who's relapsed and hasn't even been properly rehabilitated." He said.

"Scott, that's not your place t-"

"I forbid it," He growled, turning around and walking off angrily.

You waited a while longer before Justin showed up for your session, a smile forming on his face when his eyes met yours.

"Hey (Y/N)," he grinned.

"Hey."

"What are we doing today?"

"I was thinking we'd work on essay writing?"

"Sounds good to me," he said, smiling like a happy kid.

He was wearing clearly what was one of Clay's cardigans and his hair was neatly styled, you wouldn't have the slightest clue what he'd been through from first glance.

You spent an hour in the library together after school, helping Justin with his studies and marking his work, he'd made solid progress in the time you'd been tutoring him and you were almost certain he'd be able to graduate with your year.

"You know (Y/N), getting to know you more though these tutoring sessions has made me realise I want to get to know you even more, but like you know, not at the library but maybe somewhere else?" Justin asked, nervously.

"Is the Justin Foley asking me on a date?" You gasped sarcastically.

"I think he is," Justin laughed, the sound like music to your ears.

"Well, I, (Y/N), happily accept," you smile.

"Perfect," Justin grinned, taking your hand in yours as a sign of affection.

"What the fuck is going on here?" Scott interrupted.

You looked up at your fuming brother who looked like he was about to tackle Justin.

"Uh..we were holding hands?" Justin said, stating the obvious, not realising Scott's question was rhetorical and simply a sign of his disapproval.

"Yeah, I can see dumbass, get your hand away from my sister's, (Y/N), we're going, mom wants us home now." Scott said.

"Who are you calling a dumbass, dumbass?" Justin growled, standing up to size up Scott.

"Both of you just stop, please," you pleaded.

"I told you not to get close to him, and you fucking did it anyway!" Scott yelled, now drawing the attention of the whole library.

"You're not my fucking dad okay? Just quit it, you're causing a scene," you said sternly.

You turned over to Justin, "I'm really sorry, I've got to go now, but I'll see you tomorrow."

"It's fine," he said, with a weak smile, then going back to death glaring your brother.

You followed Scott as he stormed out of the library. You looked back at Justin and mouthed, 'text me'.

He laughed and nodded, giving you a thumbs up.

Little did you know that was the beginning to a forbidden relationship.