In Another Life (A Allison Argent Fanfiction)

Chapter Thirty - Four: Old High School Drama Part 6

Derek is kneeling down tied up with ropes by Jackson. He got up and when he turned around Allison had a gun in her hand pointing at Derek.

"Give me the gun. You don't have to go through with this. It's over now. He won't be able to hurt us anymore. I made sure of that."

"What because he's tied up by a piece of rope?! No you're wrong he's crazy. He won't stop until we're dead."

She looked around the empty room.

"You see this is how far he is willing to go for revenge. How twisted is that? Now I'm the one holding the gun to his head."

"Allison, please think of our daughter. What would she think of you if you go through with killing him? I'm not saying he doesn't deserve to die. I mean, I've thought about killing him too. He's done unspeakable things to me too."

"That's right! So why are you siding against me." She asked him lowering the gun at her side.

"I would be doing both of us a favour here right by doing this."

"But I've come to realise he wasn't worth getting my hands dirty."

"All that he's done...I thought Lydia done it. But it was him along this time. He paid off the sick bastard there."

She looked at the hired thug dead on the floor.

"Yeah I did pay him by only to kill Jackson. I didn't want anyone else to get hurt. Lydia hired him to kidnap you Allison. She wanted you to suffer and then kill you. So I paid him triple to keep you safe and out of danger while he did what Lydia told him to do. I had to make it believable. I'm so sorry. Okay. I told you everything I've done so do it. Now that I told you what I did. Kill me." Derek said looking up at her.

"What?!" Allison asked in confusion.

"I said, 'Kill me.' If anyone going to do it, it might as well be you. I caused you so much pain up until now. I want to die by your hands. I want you to put me down but before you do. I want you to know that I will never stop loving you."

Allison lifted the gun slowly to Derek's head.

He closed his eyes waiting for Allison to pull the trigger.

"Do it Allison! Kill me!" Derek said begging her.

Jackson looked at Derek and then at Allison and he noticed her hands started shaking.

"I-I... I can't kill you."

Derek opened his eyes and looked up at her.

"What?"

Allison dropped the gun and Jackson picked it up.

"I want you to suffer like I didn't for all these years I've been with you. I admit that having sex with Jackson was wrong but what you did is a lot worse. I won't give you an easy way out. Look at where we are right now. I think you need a psychotherapist. Look at all you have done here lying to everyone about you feeling towards me and Jackson, kidnapping Stiles, Jackson and I, framing Lydia and almost murdering Jackson again. You will pay for everything you did to me but until then I can't forgive you. If you want me to forgive and believe you can change and all can be friends, you'll have to prove it to everyone have hurt today even if you didn't mean to do so."

"After all I've done you and Jackson, you still won't kill me. You would rather forgive me for everything. You're a better person then me." Derek said with remorse.

Derek started breaking down in tears and Jackson and Allison looked at him.

"I thought I could get you alone by using Lydia as a cover. She planned on killing you, me and Jackson for what we did to her."

"Wait! So your big plan was to let her kill me?! Then you would save Allison and Stiles and be the hero of your little story then live happily ever after!" Jackson asked in an angry tone.

Allison looked at him.

"This is so messed up." She said to herself.

"Yeah, tell me about it. Why isn't Stiles back yet?"

"Don't worry I will go and get him. You stay here with Derek please don't kill him. Okay. Give me the gun."

"Hey you won't kill him just go and see what's keeping Stiles up."

Allison started walking towards the door then as she was about to reach for the handle to open it.

"Oh Stiles I was about to come and get..."

"Surprise!"

"What the hell?!"