Love Me, Love Me Not (Will x Reader x Bill fanfic)

The Truth

Y/n, Your POV

My hangout with Bill was so much fun. I didn't really like when that she-Demon started flirting with him but I think I handled the situation well. Guess I got too jealous huh? I've been thinking about Will alot more than usual. At first when I left, he was the only thing on my mind. Whenever the days u could go see him came I would practically bounce around the rooms, packing and getting ready. But, afterwards when he stopped waiting for me, my mind moved on to Bill since he was giving me so much affection and attention. He would do the sweetest little gestures to make me smile. And they worked every single time. Now that Will's back though, he's been cold and uncaring so my hearts starting to crack. 'I feel as though we were in Undertale and he's continuously attacking my soul, waiting for it to shatter.' (comment if you know Undertale)  I'm feeling like Will is slowly breaking a part of me whereas Bill is trying his best to repair it. Maybe I should talk to him. That didn't turn out to well last time. Screw it imma do it.' I teleported to Will's room which was next to mine to find him sitting on the floor, lotus style, as though he were meditating. "What do you want y/n? I'm kinda busy." He looked at me with irritation. "I need to talk to you. So listen up. I ain't gonna repeat myself. You've been acting like a downright jerk towards me when I haven't even done jack fucking shit to you. I'm sick of it." *Le gasp. Reader-chan. Your badassness is showing.) "All you've done since you got here is make me feel bad. You don't talk to me, you don't look at me. He'll you don't even seem to care that in a fucking living, breathing being. Well here's what Will Cipher. I don't give a shit anymore. Do whatever you want because I don't care." His face had a look of pure agony. I couldn't understand it but that's what I saw. His forehead was creased, nose scrunched up and he looked.....scared? Tf. "Y-y/n. I..I'm so sorry.  I wasn't even thinking straight. I didn't realise I made you feel like that. 'Don't trust  him y/n.' 'Huh.' 'He's lying to you. He's just toying with your feelings.' 'How the fuck would you know.' 'Because he's been so harsh and cruel towards you. Why is he suddenly apologizing now?' 'Y.....you make quite a compelling case.  What should I do?' 'Tell him that you won't stand for it.' I listened to the strange voice in my head. "Listen here buddy. I don't know if you're trying to make me fall for the pity act like before but it's sure as hell not gonna happen. Stop messing with me. It's not like you actually even ca-" I was cut off by lips on mine. His somehow cold yet smooth lips lightly pressed against mine. I missed this feeling. As though they remembered their past relations, our lips moved in sync as the kiss became deeper and more passionate. His tongue lightly graze over my bottom lip, begging for entrance. I decided to tease him and denied. My breath hitched as I felt his hands trail up my shirt towards my breasts. His palm brushed against my right boobs and he suddenly squeezed it a bit harshly, causing me to release a moan of pleasure. In the short period my lips were separated, his tongue slithered into my mouth. We fought for dominance but eventually I lost. He explored every inch of my mouth leaving nothing unattended. During the kiss, he had at some point, backed me up against the wall opposing the door. His hands trailed to my thighs as he gingerly lifted me up, wrapping my legs around his waist and pressed into me more. I moaned from our contact into the kiss. It had only just occurred to me that I had not needed air for 15 minutes. Perks of being a demon I guess. My fingers found their way to his hair as I gently pulled and played with it. His moans were muffled by the kiss. After about 25 minutes of full on making out, we finally pulled apart, small single string of saliva connecting our lips. Our foreheads met and we looked at each other, only to stare into each other's eyes. "Y/n. I've missed this. I've missed us. Most of all, most importantly, I've missed you." My eyes welled up. "I've missed you too blueboy." He chuckled softly at the nickname I had given him so long ago. I pulled back, he put me down and I looked at him seriously. "Why aren't you scoring or looking at me like you want me to burst into flames?" He visibly tensed as his entire body went rigid. "Because I'm speaking to you in a dream. Ever since you 'woke up' you've actually still been asleep. I can't meet with you outside and you need to learn to build a wall around your mind." He had a point. I can't have people travelling in and out of my mind as they wished. We practiced for 2 hours straight. Every time I shielded my mind, it would push him out and take form. When it went down he reappeared. " "Nice shield. F/c suites you. Then again it is your favorite colour." He smiled. "You can't even begin to understand how much I've missed you." "Well. Why did you stop waiting for me at the house? Every time I visited you weren't there to see me. You left me." Tears welled up in my eyes and a few escaped. "No no no no no n/n(nickname) I never left you. I just wanted to get you back so badly. I have plan to beat Bill and get you back." I bit my bottom lip guiltily. 'I'm talking to him about his leaving me though I myself am the one who isn't loyal. Wait. Can you read someone's mind from inside.' Will looked at me blankly. "Yes. You can. What do you mean 'Not loyal.' Explain now." I looked at him sadly. "Sorry Will but I've developed feelings for Bill while I've been here. He's just been so kind and considerate and a true gentleman. Yeah he causes alot of trouble but he takes care of me nicely. I've realised that I actually love you both but it seemed like only one of you actually loved me back. I guess I was wrong." He looked at me and pulled me into hug. I felt the tears hit my shoulder before I heard the sobs. "Don't love him more than me y/n. I don't want you to leave me again. Promise that even if you love him, you'll still love me just as much." I pushed him back for us to look at each other and pushed some of his hair away from his eyes. "I promise Will. Now I believe it's time to wake up no? You need to call off your plan." He nodded. "I understand. Oh congrats on learning about you dreamon heritage." "Oh yeah. But who did I get it from. It couldn't have been my parents right?" "Actually no. One of your ancestors married a female dreamon. She birthed a female half dreamon but after the child was born, it was revealed that the child's power was actually the lost power of the she demon. In short. She gave all of her demonic essence to the child. That child married another dreamon and the process continued until your grandmother g/n(grandma name) She was a half dreamon but she married a mortal man thus the birth of your mortal mother who also married a mortal man resulting in you. However, it seems that though she created your mother, her power went to you instead. If grandma used it means you were chosen instead of your mother." I took everything in then nodded while smiling wryly. "Thanks for clearing that up. But umm. Why didn't you tell me before?" He raised his hands defensively. "Didn't want to freak you out." Sensible. Suddenly I was pulled into another kiss. "I missed this you know. This feeling of your lips on mine." I of course kissed back. "I missed it too." We pulled back. "Now go call off your Bill Eradication squad so we can be normal outside my head." We chuckled and he nodded. "I'll see you soon my n/n" "Can't wait for it blueboy." And with that he left and left and I actually woke up. I made sure I was actually up this time. I was.'Should I explain everything to Bill? Nah I'll wait till Will gets back.'" "Morning Bill." He laughed loudly. "Star it's like 3 in the afternoon." I blushed from embarrassment. "Shut up." He laughed more. "So how did you sleep?" "Fine. You?" "The same. No sleep remember. Technically you don't need to sleep often due to your Demon side. So I guess that when you lock into it for too long your mortal self sleeps longer to recover. If you don't manage both sides one might overpower the other." I nodded. Just then Will walked in. "Bill, y/n I need to speak with you both." He led us to Bill's dining room. "I gotta confess this and get it over with. Bill I'm not actually turning evil. I.....it was just a part of the plan I  made to get y/n back. Part of it was creating your Cipher wheel and sending you back actually. But y/n fell in love with you. I don't want to do anything if she loves you unless you mistreat her. So watch it. Another thing is I returned Reverse Falls to normal. No weirdness in sight. Sorry about that. The power sorta ran to my head." Bill stared at him for fora good while. "I felt something was a little sketchy with all this but for this I'll let it slide. I know you only did it to get her back. I would've done the very same thing. However, y/n says she loves us equally. Therefore I guess we gotta share or compete. I vote compete." "Well I choose share. I don't want her to end up choosing you over me. I'd be too heartbroken. I'd give up my immortality just to die from the lack of her." Bill went silent then nodded. "You make a good point Will. I guess we'll share this beauty huh?" "Hey guys. I'm still here." "We know." They both chimed causing me to laugh. "Oh right. I was thinking. You guys are like everliving beings. Does that make me immortal?" "Actually yes but in in a different way. You will become immortal when you stop aging when you're 25. If you are in a life or death situation,  the choice would be brought between your mortality or immortality. You will go through a sort of test to see whether or not you agree worthy of immortality." "Okay then." Without warning Bill pulled me closer to him. "Well Star. Since Will and I agree and are really sharing you,  doesn't that basically mean I'm your boyfriend of sorts." I blushed. "I guess it does." He smirked and pulled my face to his in a kiss. Unlike Will's kisses which started soft and gradually become passionate, his were full on from the start. He bit my lower lip hard causing me to separated my lips as his tongue slipped in. We basically made out for five minutes until Will cleared his throat to grab our attention. "Hey Bill. If you're done shoving your tongue down her throat I'd like to ask her on a date. I haven't exactly been able to hang out with her since I've ween her again. "I'd love to go out with you Will." I said After pulling away from Bill. Should I go get ready now?" He nodded and I left. I went to the shower and took a 15 minute bathe. The outfit I wore was a baby blue top that had a criss crossed front. It was a bit figure hugging but but it but it was absolutely adorable with a heart dark blue in the middle. I wore it with my blue denim shorts and a pair of white sandals. I put my hair up into a h/s and went back downstairs. When Will saw me his jaw dropped. "Y-y/n you look g-great." He struggled to say without becoming too flustered. "Shall we go." I nodded. "Let's go. And Bill. No stalking us." He laughed. Alright Star. Enjoy your date." I thanked him and left with Will. 'I wonder where he's taking me.' We walked to different places. A demon museum which told many histories of Demon kind, the aquarium where saw where I saw all kinds of unnatural fish, the zoo and lastly an ice cream parlour. Most of the flavours were for demons but I found the one I wanted most. "Can I have an f/fl (favourite flavour) please. Two scoops." I got it. Will got blueberry which honestly didn't surprise me one bit. "Hey Will this was fun. I had a great time with you." "I had fun too. We should do this again sometime." He leaned down, since he was slightly taller, and placed a kiss on my lips.  I kissed back and it lasted for 3 minutes before we pulled away. I'm glad I have both of them in my life. I wonder how on Earth this is  gonna work out in the end. I guess we'll have to wait and see.

Word count issssssss ~2324 wordsss. T'was fun. So yeah. If you didn't expect to be dating both of them well.....SURPRISE. A good friend of mine who will sadly not be named, came up to me while I was writing and said, 'if you don't write a threesome lemon I'm gonna kill you.' Tbh I was rolling in laughter from this because her face looked so freaking serious. So in order to lead up to that ,yes I'm actually gonna do it, I gotta make the three of you a thing. No Will and Bill aren't bi they just can't stand being without you. Awwwws. Anyways new chapter'll be up on Saturday so be thereee. Bye and remember,
REALITY IS AN ILLUSION
THE UNIVERSE IS A HOLOGRAM
BUY GOLD BYEEEE ~💛💛💛💛💛