Love Me, Love Me Not (Will x Reader x Bill fanfic)

Me or Him

Will's POV

The next day I woke up and saw y/n sleeping next to me. I started blushing madly as I recalled last night's activities with her. I looked at her to see her snuggling into my chest. I pulled her closer to me and kissed her forehead. 'She's so cute' I couldn't stop thinking about how cute she was. I felt a presence with her. I realized it was Bill and entered her mind to face him.

Inside your mind ~

I entered y/n's mind and sure enough I saw her and my brother but they were talking. I couldn't tell what they were saying so I went closer. I couldn't believe what was happening.

Bill's POV (AT LAST)

"So you and my brother became something. I saw what you did last night. You're pretty loud for a soft spoken girl." Y/n blushed as she thought of me watching her and my brother. "W-why were you watching us. T-that was personal." "Ahahahahaha. I'm an all knowing demon. I don't care about what humans think is personal. I actually came here to talk about you. I don't like that you're with Will. I don't want you to be with or anywhere near him. You belong to me. I fell for you the first time I saw you but instead you went for Will. Did you ever wonder why I didn't give you brain melting nightmares. I wanted you to love me back. So I will do the only thing left. TAKE YOU AWAY AND KEEP YOU TO MYSELF. AHAHAHAHAHA. YOU WILL BE MINE FOREVER. BETTER SAY GOODBYE TO WILL. BECAUSE IF YOU DON'T ....... I'LL KILL HIM. See ya later toots." With that I left her mind. I knew that Will was listening so I entered his mind. I saw him and went over. "I know that you heard what I said so you better obey or else I will give you a very slow, painful, torturous death." I left again and this time for good.

Your POV

I woke up and got breakfast after changing into my clothes. If I stay with Will then Bill will kill him. If I go with Bill then I'll never see Will again. I was so sad I couldn't think straight. "Y/n  I know what's going on. Please stay." Will's voice stated. "But if I stay then you will die and I'm not taking that chance." I placed my hand on his cheek but I was burned. "Ouch." I pulled my hand back. I had a thought. I poked him and was mildly electrocuted. "Bill spelled you. He made it that if I touch you then I'll be hurt. Why can't I just be with you. I don't love Bill I love you." "I love you too y/n and I want you to stay. I don't care if I die. I just want you with me." "OK. I'll stay." I couldn't tell if he knew I was lying. I don't think so because he was smiling and was really happy. I didn't show it or think about it but I will go with Bill after Will Falls asleep.

Timeskip to night-time brought to you by ~ Mettaton. Enjoy darlings

Will was fast asleep and was lightly snoring. Without him knowing, I had packed my bags with my necessary things and wrote him a letter saying goodbye. I grabbed my bags, placed the letter where he could find it and went to the living room. "Bill where are you." I whisper shouted, careful not to wake up Will. "I'm right here sweetheart. Grab your stuff and we'll be going." I nodded and picked up my bags. He snapped his fingers and we arrived in a lovely building. Most likely a mansion. "Where are we?" I couldn't help being curious. "We're in the mindscape dollface and this is where you'll be staying from now on. Let me take those." He snapped his fingers again and my bags were floating around him. He showed me to a room with a white door which was covered in hearts. Cuuuute. He opened the door and the first thing I saw were the red and blue walls. I wonder if he'd let me paint designs on the walls. "Why of course you can paint the walls. It is your room. I want you to be happy and comfortable here with me." I just nodded, took my bags from him and closed the door before he could come in. I unpacked and decided to take a shower. "Y/n what are you doing? Are you trying to escape? I'm coming in." He entered without permission and searched for me. He probably heard the shower by now because he was coming closer to the door. I grabbed a towel and wrapped it securely around me. The bathroom door opened and he came in. He pulled the curtain aside as I shut off the water. I didn't give him the light of day as I walked past him to get changed. He watched me as I picked out my PJs. I looked at him finally. "Do you mind." I was very cold towards him and he was a bit taken aback by my behaviour. He just turned around and stood facing the wall. I sighed through my nose and just changed. I took out the book I was reading the day before, climbed into bed and began reading, not even bothering to acknowledge Bill who kept looking at me. He came over to me and sat with me. "You like reading huh?" "Yh so what?" "Come with me." I followed him downstairs and into the second room to the right. I walked in to see that it was a library. "Wow. Have you..... read all of these books." "Most of them. You can come here anytime you like." "Um thank you Bill." He nodded. I took a tower of books and he was surprised when he saw how many as I put the pile down. "Need any help with those." "No thanks. I've got it." I used my bracelet to teleport the books and myself to my room. Bill came in a few seconds after. "You used that bracelet even though you didn't have to." "What do you mean by 'I didn't have to'. This bracelet is the only way I can use magic." "No it's not. I sense great levels of magic from within you. You have magic without that bracelet." I suddenly did something that just occurred to me. I took off the bracelet and removed the gem. I put the bracelet on and looked at the gem. I thought about the gem being in Will's hand but not before conjuring a little one side window to see him. The gem appeared in his hand while he slept, glowed blue and was absorbed into him. I closed the window and looked at Bill. "Here's the thing Bill. I don't know you at all. Therefore I don't love you. I love Will. You say you want me to be happy then why did you take me away from him." Tears were freely flowing from my eyes. "Look y/n, I know you love Will but I have loved you since I first saw you when you moved to Reverse Falls. I thought that you could never love me so I never approached you. Why can't you just love both of us." "Because I hardly know you. When I do know you better then maybe I can love you. But keeping me away from Will isn't going to make me fall in love with you. Do you understand what I mean?" "Yh. I understand. You can see Will three times a week. Any three days you want." "Thank you." I hugged Bill for his kindness and climbed into bed. I thought about Will as I went to sleep.

Word count ~ 1320 yayyyyy. I am sorry if my story is a bit boring but I promise you that things will pick up next chapter. It's going to get fluffy with you and Bill so keep reading. Remember to vote, comment, share, follow and tag. Bye bye💖💖💖💖💖💖