Cheated [Cheater Kuroka x OC x Akeno & Rias]

Chapter 4: Second Chances!?

A few days since Makoto and Akeno's breakup has passed. The two were somehow able to manage without each other but they were still heartbroken.

However, a certain nekomata has been closer to him with everyday that passes. She knows that she missed up when she kissed him but he wasn't upset about. He passed it off as a 'heat of the moment' type thing.

Although everything has seemed to be in the clear. And for Makoto, things were going great since his best friend, Rias Gremory, was visiting him.

"Makoto-kun, it has been awhile. I've missed you so much."Rias said as she gave him a tight hug. He blushed from embarrassment and hugged her back. "I missed you too, Rias-san."

While in embrace, the pair felt something (or someone) was watching them. Looking around, they saw Kuroka watching them from a distance and when she got caught she started whistling innocently.

"So have you and Akeno been? Is she treating my little Makoto alright?" She said as Makoto sweat dropped and shook his head.

"Akeno-san and I, have broken up. I needed some time without her because we had been butting heads recently." He said as Rias gasped but then she began to question why they were arguing.

"We were arguing because I felt bad for making Kuroka-chan cry. And Akeno-san was saying that she was causing me pain and didn't care so why should I care about her." He explained and Rias nodded then questioned him.

"Do you still have feelings for Kuroka? If so, now ask yourself if you have the same feelings for Akeno?" She said and Makoto nodded and thought about it.

He had forgave Kuroka for cheating on him. Then, of course, he knew she still was in love with him and he was happy because of that. Although, he wasn't sure if he really loved her like he used to, he was sure that he had some feelings for her.

As for Akeno, his feelings for her were more decisive. She was his best friend. She helped him be happy when he was depressed because of Kuroka. His love for her as a friend and as a lover wouldn't falter that easily.

He was conflicted. Both of them were very attractive and loving. Well Kuroka was loving to him when she didn't cheat on him. Anyways, he had strong romantic feelings for both and he just couldn't choose who to pick.

He loved them both. If he wanted one of them back, which he did, then someone was going to get hurt. Makoto didn't want that. He couldn't choose between them and he didn't want too. He was content with being lonely, as long as no one got hurt, he was fine with anything.

"I have romantic feelings for both Kuroka-chan and for Akeno-san. However, I won't them or myself in a situation where I have to pick one over the another. I'll just keep being single for now." He said as Rias looked at him with an irked expression.

"You have feelings for both of them? Kuroka cheated on you many times. Akeno was completely loving and faithful. How is that even a hard decision?" Rias said as Makoto sighed and shrugged his shoulders.

"Kuroka-san used to be loving and faithful. Before she met Issei, she was the best girlfriend ever. I guess that's why I loved her and still do to a certain amount." He said and Rias nodded with a semi skeptical look on her face.

"Well, let me know whenever you decide to choose a girl as your lover. I'll relay the message to whoever is the lucky lady." Rias said and he nodded. As she left, Makoto felt pressured and he wanted to make sure he picked the right girl.

Unbeknown to Makoto, Kuroka and Akeno overheard his conversation with Rias. "I really hope he comes back to me. I've missed my dear Makoto. If he chooses you Akeno, please take care of him and love him for the both of us." Kuroka said which surprised Akeno.

"Y-Yes. And if he picks you then please love him for me as well. I love Makoto and it would mean the world to me if you made him happy. He is my king. I love him and his little cute face." Akeno said and Kuroka nodded.

"I also believe that Makoto has a cute face. I just hope he didn't regret picking whoever he picks." Kuroka said with a small smile. If Makoto tries to pick that bitch over me, I'll kill her and take my sweet Makoto and make sweet love to him forever. I will not be rejected. Makoto will be mine again! Whether he likes it or not!

After a couple hours passed, the tension was at it's all time high. Soon Makoto walked in the living room, where Akeno, Kuroka, and Rias were sitting down and talking.

"I've come to a decision." He said as nervousness ran through both Kuroka's and Akeno's body. Makoto released a small sigh before speaking.

"I've decided that I want both of you. Either we are all together or we're not together at all." He said as Rias, Kuroka, and Akeno all looked at him with a confused expression.

No one was expecting for him to say that. They thought it would be strictly one girl but they were wrong. How will Makoto's life be different with having two girlfriends now. How will Kuroka deal with this? Will she become crazy and try to breakup Akeno and Makoto? Or will she become subdued and more loving to Makoto?