Cheated [Cheater Kuroka x OC x Akeno & Rias]

Chapter 12: Recollection!

If I didn't have Yuuto, Rias, and Akeno I would've did something really bad by now, like taking my own life. Do you remember me saying that?

Of course not, because I said that way back when it all began. How could I've been so blind? How could we've be so blind?

Why do you even try? She doesn't love you back. You know this to be true. So tell me, why do you keep running back to the person who hurts you? If she cheated, then she didn't just cheat on you, she cheated your relationship. Leave her for someone who will treat you better. I wish listened to you, Akeno. Maybe things would've been different if I did.

"It's gonna be okay, buddy. I promise." He said reassuringly. You lied, Kiba. What the hell are you anyways? I haven't seen you since then. Maybe you're doing your thing with Tsubaki.

"We were arguing because I felt bad for making Kuroka-chan cry. And Akeno-san was saying that she was causing me pain and didn't care so why should I care about her." I explained and Rias nodded then questioned me. Kuroka knew I would argue with Akeno about it, of course. She's more clever than I accounted for.

"I just wanted to say that I'm sorry. I'll get better for you Makoto-kun. Then you will love me again. I know it'll take time but I'm willing to do anything for your redemption. That's all I wanted to say. Bye for now." Kuroka said maturely. You didn't want to work for anything. You guilt tripped me.

"I've decided that I want both of you. Either we are all together or we're not together at all." I said, leaving them with confused facial expressions. How stupid of me. Why would you take her back, Makoto?

"Ngh!" Her hymen had broke and she started bleeding, symbolizing that she was no longer a virgin. Do you remember that, Akeno-chan? When I took your virginity and I gave you mine.

"Makoto, I want you~" Kuroka said as she stripped down, becoming fully naked as did Makoto. She got into doggy style position, using her hands and knees to support herself. No. You never wanted me, you wanted what hid in my pants.

As I opened the door, I saw a sight that brought tears to my eyes. Kuroka was being penetrated from the behind by Issei. Akeno looked at Kuroka, tears brimming in her eyes. She was hurt because I was hurt. Akeno didn't want someone like me to be in anymore pain but Kuroka had hurt me to many times to count. Well, I should've seen it coming. Why didn't I?

"Akeno-chan, I love you but my heart will always yearn for Kuroka and it hurts to not be with her. She was my first true love, and now she's gone." I sobbed. I never meant to make you feel so unneeded. I love you, Akeno.

Rias had a sultrily expression on her face as she brushed her hand softly against my thigh. Her blue eyes never mine; She had a gaze of hunger, it sparked greater than anything I ever seen before. Have you always been attracted to me, bestie?

She took my full length in her mouth, gagging slightly. Her tongue swirled around the tip of my cock, and she licked my urethra which made me tremble underneath the intense pleasure. I shouldn't have let you have your way, Kuroka. You fuck up too many things. I should've listened to Rias instead.
______________________________________________

He couldn't contain it any longer. A hot white thick liquid dispersed from Makoto's urethra and went into Kuroka's mouth. Her eyes widened when she realized how much he came but she still drunk it.

Not a single drop escaped her lips.

"That was... Fun. That's all I'll do for today. I need to rest. Let's do that again, soon. Bye, daddy." Kuroka said, pressing her lips against his cheek before walking out of the bathroom.

"Shit." He muttered, feeling the intense sensation of guilt overcome him. How will he deal with this?

How would he react when he saw Akeno at the other side of the door. Why was she here? Rias told her everything, even about how she came onto Makoto.

Akeno wasn't angry about that, but she was furious that he would allow Kuroka to do sexual with him, especially since he hadn't touched her since Kuroka died, two months ago.

Why did Akeno have to play fair and not break his heart when he broke hers? Why did she have to continue playing this unfair game? She just wanted to quit. Maybe her and Makoto weren't destined to be.

He exited the bathroom, his pants still unbuckled and he was met with the sight of Akeno, tears staining her pretty magenta eyes.

"You kissed Rias?" she asked rhetorically, Makoto stood there, speechlessly. "If you would've told me, I wouldn't have broken up with you. But you let Kuroka suck you off. Are you fucking kidding me, Makoto?"

"Akeno, I-"

"No! That's it, Makoto! I'm tired of all this bullshit. You're always sorry and I'm always forgiving you. Well, no more. Go find someone else to deal with your crazy ass." She spat, hatred laced in her voice.
______________________________________________

You were right for snapping on me, Akeno. I never realized how bad of a boyfriend I truly am. But I never regretted anything about us. I loved you, and I still do love you.

I think that you're the prettiest, smartest, kindest woman alive. You're a good person, and I'm a good person somewhere deep down. We are good people, Akeno.

We just weren't good together.