Accidentally In Love (An IM5 fanfiction)

Chapter 3- Trapped

Cole's POV

I walked out of Annabelle and I's room, quietly so I didn't wake Annabelle up, she would yell at me if I did. I walked into the living room, but didn't see anyone. I already knew Mr.Johanason was at a meeting for the weekend, so it was just us 10.

I peeked into everyone's room- that just made me sound like a stalker, so just don't take that the wrong way, their doors were open. They weren't in the rooms. I looked all over the house but there wasn't anyone. I headed to the kitchen to check when I bumped into Annabelle. I decided to be somewhat nice today, if she didn't act like a jerk.

"Hey, have you seen the boys or the girls?" I asked.

She looked at me weird, like she was wondering why I was being nice, but she didn't saw anything and shook her head.

"No, did you check the basement? Wait, of course you didn't, you wouldn't think to check their favorite place." She said, rolling her eyes. Jerk.

We walked to the basement door, her in the lead.

She tried the door, and it was surprisingly open, then her eyes widened when she realized that she didn't have her key, but she shrugged it off and went downstairs, me hot on her heels.

"Hello?" She called into the empty basement. Everything was normal, except for the fact that we were the only ones in here.

We heard the door slam shut, and I raced to see if it was unlocked, but of course, it wasn't.

"UGH! I should've known they would do this." I heard Annabelle say. I walked over to her, and see her holding a note.

Have fun in here together today, but not too much fun. ;) - Kristie, Dana, Will, Theresa, Gabe, David, Sophie, and Lea

I rolled my eyes. I went over to the couch and sat down, looking at Twitter. I decided to look and Annabelle's account, because I was bored and wanted to know if she was always a jerk.

While the page was loading, I heard her in the recording studio, trying to start it up.

The page loaded, and I saw a picture of her and another guy. Wait, who's he?

I looked at the comments on the picture, and I saw that he was her boyfriend, and they had been dating for six months.

I looked up when I suddenly heard music coming from the recording studio. I slipped into the sound booth, and turned up the volume .

" I drove by all the places we used to hangout getting wasted. I thought about our last kiss, the way you felt, the way you tasted." My eyes widened when I realized she was singing Amnesia by 5 Seconds Of Summer.

I sat in the chair and listened to her sing the rest of the song. When the song finished, I braced myself for when she noticed me. But she never did. A new song came on.

Counted all my mistakes and there's only one, standing out from the list of the things I've done. All the rest of my crimes don't come close to the look on your face when I let you go." She was now singing Where Do Broken Hearts Go by One Direction. Okay, I don't really hate 1D, I just wanted to look bold in front of the girl, like I was important and daring.
I looked into the recording studio and saw Annabelle singing with her eyes closed. I smirked. I had an awesome idea.

While she was singing the chorus I quickly slipped in and put some headphones on and started singing the next verse in a different mic.

Her eyes widened, and I thought she was going to kick me out, but she just smiled at me and sang the chorus with me.
"Now I'm searching every lonely place
Every corner calling out your name
Tryna find you but I just don't know
Where do broken hearts go?
Where do broken hearts go?"

When the song finished, she looked at me and smirked.

"You know what Pendery? You're not so bad." She said, pushing my shoulder. I laughed and we spent the next two hours recording and getting to know each other. It felt good not fighting with her, she was actually really sweet, nice, and funny.

After, we went on Netflix, and watched her choice for a movie. This just so happened to be Divergent.

We were both a mess after the movie, we cried into each others shoulders over Will and Natalie's. When we realized we were cuddling, we separated quickly.

I heard the basement door unlock, and I raced to see who was there, but they were already gone. I got Annabelle, who had fallen asleep since it was 11 at night, and carried her to our room.

I put her in her bed and threw the covers over her. I went and sat in my bed, reading Divergent. Okay, I admit it, I really really really like this series.

I read for about fifteen minutes until I heard Annabelle in bed, tossing and turning, while moaning and saying names.

I rushed over to her and heard the names she was saying.

"No, Kristie... please no, not Dana, no don't, take me instead, no please especially not Cole please no Cole."

My eyes widened when she said my name. I started shaking her.

"Annabelle, wake up, come on Annabelle wake up!" I said desperately.

She shot up in her bed, looked around to where she was, and started sobbing. I wrapped my arms around her and rubbed her back. She cried into my chest as I sat down on her bed.

"What happened Annabelle? You were having a nightmare." I said worriedly.

"I-I was b-being held by th-these guys and they h-had you in a line, a-all nine of y-you, and-and they were shooting you, and they m-made me watch." She said, while sobbing.

"Shhh It's okay Annabelle, we're all fine." I said, resting my chin on her head. Once she calmed down, I got up to go to my own bed, even though I wanted to stay with her for the night. Wait, what?

As I stood up, I felt a small hand wrap around my wrist. I turn to see Annabelle's tear streaked face looking at me desperately.

"Wait, Cole, will you stay with me tonight?" She said timidly.

I felt my heart leap in my chest as I nodded my head.

I lay down next to her and she snuggled up to me.

It wasn't long until she fell asleep. I kissed her forehead just before falling asleep myself.