✔ Game Over (Tyler Joseph x Reader)

My First

"Good morning beautiful," you heard as you made your way into the kitchen, catching sight of Tyler making breakfast. It wasn't technically morning, being as it was around 12 p.m., but it was sort of morning for him so you went with it.

"Hi handsome," you said, getting on your tiptoes to place a kiss on his lips. Your body ached from last night, luckily Tyler was prepared with having Tylenol for you on the counter top with a glass of water next to it.

"I figured you may be a little sore from everything last night," he chuckled while scrambling eggs in a pan.

"Right you are!" you said, doing finger guns at him which you realized was beyond cringey only after doing so.

Tyler giggled, reaching into one of the cabinets to grab plates for you both. He really went all out for you two, making everything from bacon to eggs to pancakes.

"All of this for us?" you asked with a smile as you started to make yourself a plate.

"All for us," he said, giving you a hug from behind.

"Are you doing alright from last night?" he asked, placing a kiss on the top of your head.

"Yeah...just...a little tender is all," you said, pouring syrup onto your pancakes.

"I'm sorry baby girl," he said, sitting down on a bar stool.

"It's okay," you said, taking a seat right next to him.

"So...how many people have you been with?" he asked, making you choke on a piece of bacon.

"Sorry," you coughed out, "uh...I mean like...what do you mean?" you asked cautiously.

"Like...how many people have you had sex with?" he said, sipping on his coffee.

"I..um...the number after zero but the number before two," you muttered, shoving food into your face.

"What?" Tyler asked, stopping what he was doing to stare at you.

"The number after zero but the nu-," you tried repeating, with biscuits and gravy causing it difficult to say again.

"No, I heard you. You've only been with one person?" he said, completely in shock.

"y-yes?" you stuttered out nervously.

"Me?" he asked, a smile forming on his face.

"You," you replied.

"I had no idea," Tyler said, running his fingers through his hair.

"Is that not okay?" you asked hesitantly.

"I just...would've done things a lot different," he admitted.

"Well I mean like I've been with people but I've never been penetrated or anything like that..." you went on.

"I would've never been so rough as I was last night... I'm sorry babe," he said, hanging his head low.

"Issokay," you said, smiling and rubbing your hand on his tattooed arm.

"Are you sure?" he asked, looking up at you with heavy eyes.

"I love you, and I thought about who I wanted to be my first for quite sometime. When it came time for you, there wasn't anything stopping me from saying yes. So therefore, I'm pretty sure it's okay," you smiled.

Tyler scooped up some eggs before starting to chow down on them, a small smile coming from him.

"Oh, but one thing..." you said, sipping on your water.

"Yeah, baby girl?" Tyler asked, looking at you with concern.

"It didn't help that you're cock is the biggest fucking thing to roam this planet," you teased, lightly nudging him. He laughed pretty hard with you, only stopping once you heard a knock on the hotel door.

Tyler stood up, making his way over to see who it was. Seeing through the peephole on the door, it was Josh. Opening up the door, Josh smirked at Tyler.

"What?" Tyler asked, looking at his best friend with a furrowed brow.

"Dirty dog, you," Josh said, punching Tyler's shoulder.

Debby came running around the corner, barging her way into the room and making her way over to you.

"Well hello to you, too," Tyler said, staring at her as she ran by. Josh followed in behind her.

"Sooooo..." Debby whispered, taking a seat in Tyler's spot.

"Yes?" you said, looking over at her and wiping crumbs off your cheeks.

"How big is he?" she giggled, still whispering so as to not have Tyler and Josh over hear.

Your jaw dropped to the floor. What the hell? How did Debby know you and Tyler had sex?  

"We could hear you guys," she said while winking and stealing a piece of Tyler's bacon.

"Hey! That's mine!" Tyler said running over and grabbing his plate.

You laughed at his innocence and took a piece of your food, placing a strip of bacon on his plate to replace what he'd lost. He smiled at you before rolling his eyes.

"What are you guys doing here?" he asked, looking at both Josh and Debby.

"Well, I figured we could all go out and do something again, 'cause you know I appreciate your presence sometimes," Tyler jabbed.

"Ditto," you said, smiling at Tyler.

"Shut up." Tyler said to Josh, walking to the other side of the counter top to eat his breakfast.

"We should watch a movie!" you suggested.

"That'd be fun," Debby responded.

"I mean I'm down," Josh said, leaning his arm down on Debby's shoulder.

"Alright, movies it is." Tyler said.

"We should do it here," you said smiling.

"We should! Grab pillows and blankets and huddle up around the T.V. with snacks and popcorn. It'd be so much fun!" Debby cheered, excitedly clapping her hands.

Tyler and Josh stared at one another with a small eye roll matching the others.

"Oh come on it'll be fun," you said to Tyler and Josh.

"Four dudes in a pillow fort? I'm not so sure about that," Tyler said laughing.

"Fine then it'll be just Y/N and I." Debby teased.

Ahhh Debby Dun is my best friend okay let's do this

"Heck yeah!" you said, both high fiving one another.

"And what does that leave us guys to do?" Tyler asked.

"I dunno, that's on you guys," Debby teased.

"Let me go get changed and we'll go grab some snacks," you said, hopping off the bar stool and grabbing your keys.

"Can Josh and I come with?" Tyler said.

"I mean I suppose," you teased.

***