Supernatural x Y/N

The Ride Back Home

The ride back to the bunker began in total silence. Dean driving, Sam in the front seat nursing his cut hand and you in the back seat, holding your knees to your chest and staring out the window. A good hour had passed before Sam spoke up.
"Okay, are we going to talk about what happened back there or what?" He questioned. You looked up to see Sam staring at the road ahead and Dean eyeing you in the rear view mirror.
"What happened to you guys?" You asked the brothers, trying to deter them from asking about what they had so clearly witnessed in Lucifer's bedroom.
"Same old stuff." Dean began "Lucifer held us in cages, tried to torture us but forgot that we're Winchester's, and you should never leave us alone." Sam turned around in his seat and looked you directly in the eyes.
"Y/N, I don't know what he said to you but I do know what we saw him doing to you. That isn't typical Demon torture." You sighed, rolled your eyes and stared up at the roof of the car.
"Can we please not talk about it." You replied quietly as you closed your eyes, hoping Sam would drop this embarrassing detail of your mission.
"No, we need to talk about this" Dean began "Because we need to know exactly what Lucifer was trying to get out of you and why he felt that tickling you was the only way to get it."
That word!! Your face turned a deep shade of red the instant Dean said that word. You leaned your head forward, now in the foetal position and sighed a long sigh. Dean studied you from the rear view mirror and Sam remained in his half twisted position. He reached out and placed a comforting hand on your knee.
"Y/N, I know this is hard for you but we just need to know what Lucifer wants- did he ask you for anything? Did he threaten you with anything? Did he give you an ultimatum?"
Sam continued to look at you, trying to get your eye contact. You lifted your head and stared out the window, deciding on what to share with them. There was no way you were going to reveal to the boys that the King of Hell had discovered your kink and was going to exploit it!
"Look," You began "Lucifer just said that he wanted to punish all Hunters. He said that he didn't want to mark my body but had ways of making me suffer. He'd only been in that room with me for maybe an hour before you boys showed up. Thanks for that, by the way." You finished your explanation by turning your head to Sam and smiling.
Sam looked at you puzzled. He wasn't buying your story- but it wasn't like you had lied- you just left out the last little part of the story.
"It just doesn't make sense." Sam began "he could have obliterated you with the snap of his fingers, yet he didn't. Why would he keep you? Lucifer must be up to something."
Sam left the conversation at that, and you continued your journey in silence for the next half hour. The silence was broken by Dean in the front seat.
"So Y/N," he began, looking at you in the rear view mirror. "Ticklish hey?" He raised his eye brows as he said this and you covered your face in embarrassment. "I mean, you're a tough chick, I'm surprised that of all things, that is your weakness."
You groaned loudly as you realised this meant you had to entertain the idea again.
"Can we please not talk about this Dean?" You begged the older brother.
"I think it's kinda cute" Sam butted in almost instantly. You groaned again and buried your face into your knees. "At least Lucifer helped us find out her weakness, should she need convincing at any time."
The brothers looked at each other and grinned as you groaned louder in the back seat, hoping that by not adding any substance to this discussion, they might drop it.
"Dean," You perked up from the back seat. "Can you put your Metallica playlist on please? I need a good 10 minute drum solo in my life right about now."
Dean excitedly got his tapes out as Sam looked swiftly back at you with an evil look. You dodged a bullet now, but with Sam's look, you're sure he will repay the favour.