𝐹𝒾𝓋𝑒 𝒽𝓊𝓃𝒹𝓇𝑒𝒹 𝐹𝒾𝒻𝓉𝓎 𝐹𝒾𝓋𝑒 (Five X Reader)

Chapter FIVE: The Boy With A Painful Past

"So guys, um, what's going on?" I asked. Me and Y/N sat in the living room, my siblings crowding us. "We have a reasons to believe that Y/N is Leilani." Klaus said.

I shook my head. "Can't be. Leilani, she jumped off a bridge. She's dead. She's gone." I denied. Klaus shook his head. "She isn't. Allison knows all about it." I looked to Allison who looked at the floor.

"Have you ever wondered why none of us could remember why Liam ran away?" Vanya said. "Klaus was obviously too high and you were definitely with her. So, I have reason to believe that Allison knows all about it."

I looked at Allison, who was still looking for he floor. "Allison, do you know what happened with Y/N?" I asked, standing up to face her. She looked up at me.

"She does know." Y/N assured me. "Allison, tell us what happened." I pressured her. "Father said that I had to use my powers on all of you. He said that Leilani was too powerful, so he had to send her away. He said that I had to erase her memory of us and the Academy and I had to make all of you think that she ran away." she confessed.

I looked at her. "So, you made me go through all of this pain, all this suffering, just to make the old shit happy?" I said and Allison nodded slightly. I threw my hands up in the air.

"Do you know what I had to go through?"

-flashback-
"Where's Leilani?" I asked making Klaus shrugged. "I don't know." he said and looked to the left. He shook his head. "Ben doesn't either."

I ran down the stairs as fast as I could. "Do any of you know where Leilani is?" I asked. Vanya looked at me with sad eyes. Allison looked at me as well. Luther stares me down, per usual.

"Where is she?" I demanded. "Number Five." I heard my father's voice. "Where. Is. Leilani." I repeated. He stepped to me and I looked him straight in the eye. "I want to know where she is."

"She ran away." he said blandly. I shook my head. "No, she wouldn't. She said she be with me for forever. You're lying. She'd never do anything like that." He looked at me.

"Number Five, if you don't stop this-"
"Stop what? I just want to know where my sister is! Why can't you tell me? Where is she?" I shouted. "She's gone."

I pushed father. "She wouldn't do that. Stop fucking lying and tell me where she is." I demanded. My head spun with thoughts about her. Leilani wasn't the type to do this...or did I not know my sister at all?

"WHERE. IS. SHE." he said nothing. I grabbed the dagger from my back pocket. "Tell me where she is or I'll kill you."

"Five, I think you should put the knife down." Allison said. I shot her a glare. "I bet you know. Since you know every thing. Or does your boyfriend know?" I teased her and she didn't answer.

"You guys don't want to tell me anything? Okay, okay. I'll go find her myself." I spacial jumped to her room.

"Lei?" I asked. Her room was empty. Besides a letter that lay on the bed. I picked it up.
-end flashback-

I pulled out the letter from my pocket. "Tell me if she wrote this or not."

"Dear Five,

I know you're the one who stormed into my room and picked up this letter. I know you really want to know where I am. To know if I'm alive.
Father told me to write you this. He said that I should lie about where I'm headed and that I'm actually just running away to live a normal life. I'm not.
Father, he feels threatened by my powers. He feels threatened that I can know everything he thinks at every given moment. That I can copy everyone's powers and use it. He's afraid that I can hurt him. He's just afraid of me.
So he's decided to kill me. He said that he's just going to take me out on a solo mission, but I know that's not the case. I'm useless without one of you. Sure, I can move things with my mind. But it's not an amazing power. He's going to take me somewhere and put a bullet through my skull. He's afraid that I'm going to survive, so he's going to make Allison erase my memories of the Academy.
Including you.
Five, I don't know how to tell you this, but I love you. More then a brother, more then a best friend. I love you more then anything in the world.
I love the way your eyes sparkle when we run around the manor. I love the way we always sneak out to the ice cream place at night. I love the way you smile, I love the way you know what you want. I love your inflated ego. I love your caring personality. I just love everything about you.
I'm sorry. I know I'm going to cause you a lot of pain. I'm really really sorry. Allison is going to make you forget about this moment, but do me a solid and keep this in your pocket. And always make sure you wear your four leaf clover. I'll always be wearing mine.
I'm going to miss you. You'll one day understand this Letter, why I wrote it. You'll understand how I feel one day.
I've Loved you for a thousand years and I'll love you for a thousand more.
Thank you for everything. Thank you for being there for me when no one was. Thank you. I wish that one day, instead of just calling you Five, I could call you by , or love.
Which ever works best for you.
I love you, stay strong and keep on drinking that forbidden coffee.