A killer's wish (Yandere Ticci Toby x reader)

____Chapter Ten____

///Y O U  T H R I L L  M E///

Tension was spread throughout the room. Toby was weak but had still managed to keep his head high and show his angered face.  Nate was still in shock that he had suddenly been hit and it pissed him off that Toby was the one who had done it . Who the hell did Toby think he was? (Y/n) was his friend and Toby only meant bad news for you.

You were frozen in place staring at the two men who sent each other deathly glares. Your stomach was in knots and you feared that if you said a word one of them would begin to fight. It was almost as if they were two animals ready to pounce on each other.
You mainly stared at Nate horrified that Toby would do something bad to him. You may have never seen Toby actually kill a person but knowing he was capable of doing such a thing kept you on edge.

"Who the hell do you think you are--!?"

You shouted for Nate to stop but the he had already swung his fists at Toby. The killer stepped back on time causing Nate grow furious each time he tried to hit him. The killer eventually hit Nate directly on the nose, making him stagger backwards. He held his nose looking down at the hand that was stained with blood. Nate clenched his fist furious that Toby was able to hit him. Toby held up his fists up, ready to throw another hit.

You wanted to intervene but you had a feeling they weren't going to be reasonable. You glanced at Toby seeing the lethal look he had clear on his face. You couldn't help but yell out for Toby not to hurt your Nate. Toby's eyes grew wide realizing you were trembling in fear, he didn't want you to be scared. You didn't want him to hurt Nate. Toby knew you cared for Nate and if if this is what you wanted Toby wasn't going to do it as much as he really wanted to your wants came first.

The 'fight' continued and Toby tried not to fight back. Nate was chasing after Toby trying grab him and take him down, if this hadn't been a serious situation this would have been amusing to you. They chased around the room jumping on and off of beds, trying to corner each other, again; it would have been something you'd ve laughing at later. The chasing had lasted for about a minute until Nate finally gave up, angrily looking over at you.

"This is so stupid! Why are you defending this idiot!? He's nothing but bad news for you!" Nate shouted. You felt those weights of guilt push down onto your chest. As much as you wanted to tell Nate why you needed to leave with Toby, you knew he'd only freak out some more.
I mean, what would you do if your friend came to you saying that a ton of serial killers were going to come after them?

Would you believe them or just think they were insane?

You'd most likely think they were insane and an odd liar. . .

"Nathan please, you're making it a bigger deal than it should be." You said, holding very little confidence in your voice. Nate felt so frustrated with you that out of impulse he grabbed you by the back of you arm and shoved you behind him. You were shocked by the abusive action, you suddenly felt paralyzed. You trusted friend had just pushed you into the floor as of you were some type of object..

"I already told you, you are not leaving with him!"

With those sudden words a pillowcase was roughly shoved onto Nate's face. Toby was the one to begin suffocating Nate from behind. A murderous glare was in his eyes. Nate tried to scratch and grab the pillow off but Toby was far stronger than him. You watched in horror but a scream had erupted before your own. Effie had came in to finally see what all the comotion had been about. To her surprise, she found Nate almost being suffocated to death. You yelled for Toby to stop, he easily complied dropping the pillow out of his hands.

Nate fell to his knees coughing and gasping for air. Effie was horrified by the scene and began calling for the police. Toby became paranoid and reached for Effie's phone. He took hold of it and smashed it onto the ground. Toby then took you by the hand and raced out of Effie's home. Everyone was left in utter shock. You weren't sure how to feel, you mainly felt like an idiot for not telling them your situation but you also felt that the outcome still would have been the same.