Love Tangle One Shots

Which Ending? Carter x reader x Henrik

     "(Y/n), would you please meet me in my room?" Henry asks me, giving me an angelic smile. 

     "I need her outside. That'll have to wait, Henrik." Carter jumps into our conversation. Lately, Carter and Henry have been really cold to each other. And not like the, 'Henrik is being immature and Carter scolds him.' More like Henry want my attention and Carter jumps in to veer it away. They both demand my attention, glaring at whoever gets it first. 

     "She likes me more so she'll go with me. Right (y/n)?" Henry asks me, grabbing my arm and pulling me close. Carter simply lets out a, 'tch.' Wait... 'Likes me more...' Does Henry mean that in a, 'I was her friend first, or a, she has a crush on me,' way? I used to have a crush on him but it died out quickly. Same for Carter. I mean, I still have slight crushes on them, but I never thought of the possibility either of them liked me.

     "(Y/n), who do you choose?" Carter demands an answer out of me while pulling me away from Henry and into his own arms. 

     "Which ending do you choose?" Henry, realizing he can't pull me into his own arms again, grabs my hand and smiles at me.

     "I choose..." I lead off and look at both the people in front of me. Suddenly, my crush that lasted the longest filled my head. All my feelings I thought that left flooded back to me. 

Henrik's Ending: 

     "Henry... I guess," I mutter out the last part as quietly as possible. I see Carter look slightly disappointed, then nods and curtly walks off. 

     "I'm so glad you chose me over him. I'm much more fun, wouldn't you say?" He gives a mischievous smile and grabs my hand. He leads me up to his room and sits me on the couch. 

     "Say, (y/n), have you ever kissed a boy?" He asks me. I can already see where this is leading and give a nod. 

     "Several," I laugh a little. 

     "Then you must be experienced in it," he says, giving a little frown. 

     "I wouldn't say experienced or good, but I'm definitely used to how it feels," I say awkwardly. 

     "Let's test out how good you are then," he smirks and kisses my lips, lightly grasping my chin with one hand. 

Carter's Ending:

     "Carter." I nod firmly. Henry looks really shocked and then starts to pout a little. He leaves with a little, 'hmph,' and Carter turns towards me. 

     "Did you really not know we liked you?" He asks.

     "Not a clue," I say as Carter lets out a sigh of disbelief. He mutters something about how it was obvious. We talk and go up to my room, sitting on my bed.

     "Carter, how many times have you been kissed," I ask. He blushes in embarrassment and responds with, "zero." 

     "Lets change that then," I say, leaning over and kissing him on the lips. 

Neither: 

     And as those feelings came flooding back I realized the main feeling was annoyance. I didn't want either. Henry starts to tug on my arm, waiting for an answer. Carter even tells me flat out to pick quickly.

     "You know what, just stop. Stop glaring at each other when the other talks to me. I don't want either of you! Let go of me," I break out of their embraces, both looking shocked, mouths agape. 

     "I'm sick and tired of it. You both demand for my attention, forgetting that I have a life too. My life isn't just picking and choosing which one of you I want. Don't start getting mad at each other over a girl! Just like how I tell my friends to stop letting guys ruin their friendships, don't let a girl ruin yours! Good bye," I let out an exasperated sigh and walk up to my room.