Ship: Ally x Reader
Request: Anal sex with Ally
Warnings: anal sex
"Stay still sweet girl." Ally's voice was steady as she held your hips tightly in her grip. The stretch was impossibly tight, and you answered your girlfriend the feeling of the strap on slowly being slid in your ass was painfully intense, but somehow Ally's soft voice soothed you. You hadn't expected it to hurt this much. You had figured that the multiple different sized butt plugs and the way Ally had given you such sweet sensations while she fingered your virgin ass, would have made it easier. And maybe it had but the feeling still made your eyes water and drew blood from your bottom lip as your teeth sank into your flesh. It was something you could handle but the sensation of something being somewhere it had never been before, made your heart panic.
"You still doing okay baby?" Ally cooed from behind you, her hand that wasn't guiding the pink cock into your tight rosebud, lazily caressed the soft skin of your back. The action reminding you that even though you were facing away from her, in a very vulnerable position, she was still there with you. You nodded, hiding your face in a pillow. Your free hand fisted the light purple sheets while the other was reached down, instinctively pushing on Ally's thigh. You released the breath that had been trapped in your lung as you felt her movement still.
"I need you to tell me you're okay Y/N." The dominating tone that had been absent the last time she spoke was back and it was mixed with uncertainty. You lifted your heavy head from the pillow and looked back at Ally through your long hair.
"I-I'm okay Miss." It wasn't a lie, the sensation had begun to change to something unfamiliar and pleasurable. There was something about calling Ally by her proper title that shot lightning straight to your cunt. You moaned and instinctively pushed back against her, the dildo easily sliding up to the hilt into your prepared ass. Now you realized why the prep was important as the intense sensation sent both pain and pleasure you. You could barely hear Ally through the pre-orgasmic buzzing in your head but you smiled as you made out her filthy words.
"There's my greedy girl. Such a good slut for me."
YOU ARE READING
AHS Shorts Shorts: Sarah Paulson's Characters Collection
FanfictionCollection of all my Female x Female American Horror Story Fanfictions! -Cordelia Goode -Ally Mayfair-Richards -Wilhemina Venable -Billie Dean Howard -Bette and Dot Tatter -Audrey Tindall -Sally Mckenna *I don't own any of these characters other th...
