Eli x Reader x Aesop

571 14 1
                                    

Requested by Ishyce



(Your writing in your diary btw) It has not been long since I arrived here at the manor and I already have notice some strange things. Like Eli the Seer and Aesop the Embalmer have been trying to... Well... Get a little too close to me. 

Constantly I would catch them staring at me. Not in a zoning out way but more of love way.

At first I was surprised knowing that two men have fallen in love with me because my self esteem needed to be fixed badly. But now I'm happy yet confused cause my heart belongs to both of them. When they do confess their feelings to me I don't want to pick one... I want to choose both.

Currently I am seated at the table with all the other survivors I have finished my dinner at now I feel like some fresh air and think about my love life. So I will head to the garden.

Signing off!

~ (Y/N)

And with that I closed my book put my plate on the kitchen counter and made my way to the garden. Finally I sat at a bench in the garden perfect place to stare at the stars. Tonight is lovely because the moon is full and blue. The moon shines onto the flowers making the garden look very beautiful I'm surprised nobody comes out on this night.

I just sat there and listened to the crickets chirp and thought about the two handsome boys. You have no idea how much I want to kiss them!

Then in the corner of my eye I see not one but two shadows. My thoughts are replaced with confused and scared ones. "W-Who's there?" I shouted. "You don't need to be afraid darling." A familiar voice replied almost immediately.

Then the shadows a merged from the darkness it was... Aesop and Eli!? They started to approach me and blush formed on my face. "We have something to ask." Eli said. "What is it?" I nervously asked. I think I might know what he's about to say.

"We've fell in love with you since we first laid eyes on you. Now is the moment for us to ask the big question... Who do you love (Y/N)?" I knew it. I didn't want to break their hearts so I did what I thought was right. "I-I love both of you! Please... Don't make me choose!" I managed to say.

I felt like crying because I don't want to break their hearts.

"(Y/N)... If you love us both... Then..." Aesop paused to look at Eli for him to nod. What did that mean? Is it some guy language? "Then we don't mind sharing you!" He said with a smile.

My face went bright red at that moment. I didn't expect that kind of answer! But before I could say anything to both took one of my hands to pull me up so they could kiss my cheek. I felt to relieved knowing they're okay with me loving them both.

To show my appreciation I kissed both of them on the lips. Their reaction made me giggle. This has to be the happiest day of my life...




Sorry this is short because it's 10:42 and I have school tomorrow. I might remake this idk. Also thanks for 99 views! It's not a lot but I didn't think people we look at my stories!

 Also thanks for 99 views! It's not a lot but I didn't think people we look at my stories!

Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.
IDENTITY V ONESHOTS -DISCONTINUED-Where stories live. Discover now