Creepypasta Parent Scenarios

My Kid Killed Someone | Story Time

(A/N: I noticed that l left Eyeless Jack's last chapter in a bit of a cliffhanger. This is supposed to be a continuation of his part.)

"Fuck! Fuck! Fuck! What are we going to do?!" The Smiling man asked. "Shut up! I'm trying to think." The Eyeless man said. "My Prince, I know you're in there." A feminine voice said, then there was a loud banging on the door causing the young child of the Eyeless man to start crying. "Is that a baby I hear? THAT SLUT JANE BETTER NOT BE IN THERE WITH YOU!" The feminine voice yelled banging on the door louder. "God if you are listening, I'm sorry for all my wrong doings. I'll turn my life around and become a better person. Just please don't let that psycho in." The Smiling man said getting down on his knees to pray. "You can stop... whatever that is, I've got a plan." The Eyeless man said. "Oh good, what?" The Smiling man asked standing up. "You go hide in the kitchen or something and I'll answer the door and tell her you ran into the Rakes territory." The Eyeless man said. "The Rake is going to disembowl her. I like it!" The Smiling man said going into the next room. "Wait!" The Eyeless man said. "What?" The Smiling man asked. "Take (Y/n) with you if things get messy I don't want her to see." The Eyeless man said.

"OK sure." The Smiling man taking the sleepy baby with him. The Eyeless man exhaled before opening the door. The Eyeless man looked down at the small girl. She was about fourteen years old with long black hair with a fuchsia highlight in the front. Pale white leathery skin, stitched open eyelids and more noticeably a smile carved into her face. The Smiling girl looked up at him, "Jackie! You're here too!" She squealed in delight. The Eyeless man cringed at the name she gave him, but kept his cool. "What do you want Nina?" He asked. "I was looking for my Prince Jeffy, I saw him run in here. Probably to get away from that bitch Jane." The Smiling girl said. "Uh huh, well he's not here, I think he ran over into the woods or something, you should check there. Good luck with your chase and I wish you all the best of luck." The Eyeless man said trying to close the door. "Oh I'm not leaving just yet, I get to spend time with you." The Smiling girl said walking inside. The Eyeless man became annoyed very quickly. "I told you once, I told you a thousand times, I don't swing that way." The Eyeless man said.

"Oh that's just because you hadn't met the right girl yet. But don't worry I'm here now." The Smiling girl said. The Eyeless man shuddered, "Nina I'm 27, you're 14, even if I liked girls. Which by the way I don't, if I dated you I'd be a pedophile." The Eyeless man said. "Oh no it's okay if we dated I'm very mature for my age." The Smiling girl said. Before the Eyeless man could say anything, the pair heard a bang come from upstairs and a familiar male voice curse. "Jeff! I knew you were here!" The Smiling girl yelled. "Nina! Don't you dare go upstairs!" The Eyeless man yelled, not wanting her near his daughter. He chased the young female upstairs, the Eyeless man having a lack of perception was not as quick as the smiling girl up the stairs. The Eyeless man heard the sound of skin being sliced and immediately began worrying about his daughter. He didn't care if it was the Smiling girl, heck he didn't even care if it was the Smiling man. All he cared about was his daughter and if she was alright.

Who knew what the Smiling girl would do if she saw her in the Smiling man's arms. And it wasn't beneath the Smiling man to sacrifice a child to save his own skin. When the Eyeless man made it upstairs, there was a heavy intoxicating smell of blood. The Eyeless man followed the smell, he could feel his heart rate speed up. He was hoping and praying his daughter was alright. He finally came to the source of the smell, his daughter's room. He shakily opened the door to find blood on the floor along with a mangled corpse. "... (Y/n)? Jeff? Are you two?..." The Eyeless man asked getting worried. He received no response, only deafening silence, "... Please... Don't be dead... Please don't leave me alone again..." The Eyeless man said sadly as more of the black substance ran down his mask mixing with the blood. The Eyeless man could feel his entire psyche shatter at the thought of the child he had grown to love more than anything being dead. And he wasn't there to protect her, like he promised he would.

Then the Eyeless man felt a tug on his pants, he looked down to see his darling daughter, she was covered in blood from crawling over. "Dada!" The child yelled. The Eyeless man picked up the child hugging her tightly, but not tight enough to hurt her. He began crying again, but this time it was from happiness. "I was so worried, don't scare daddy like that again." The Eyeless man said. The child kissed his mask, the way babies do with their entire mouth open. "Jeez that was a close call huh." The Smiling man said coming out of hiding. "You're alive too?" The Eyeless man asked. "Yep, that crazy bitch never saw it coming." The Smiling man said. "You really did a number on her." The Eyeless man said putting his daughter down who crawled over to the mangled corpse. "Oh man how I wish I could take credit. But it wasn't me sadly." The Smiling man said sighing. "If you didn't kill Nina then who did?" The Eyeless man asked. "There was one other person in the room with Nina and I." The Smiling man said. The Eyeless man looked at him perplexed trying to think who this mysterious third person could be.

The Smiling man pointed behind him to the young child happily playing in the cavaties of the mangled corpse "Listen I know my kid is a bit odd and macabre, but I doubt she was able to do that." The Eyeless man said. "Oh no she did, when Nina came she 'told' me to go on the floor. I initially didn't know what she meant, but I did as she said when I caught on. Then she started pressing on one of the floor boards. As Nina got closer these wire things flew from one end of the room to the next. It all happened so fast I didn't even have time to register it when I saw Nina split into three parts." The Smiling man said. The Eyeless man didn't say anything as he walked towards his child. "Darling did you trigger one of the traps daddy set up?" He asked kneeling to look at her. The child just babbled before holding up a kidney to his face. "Food." The child said. "Yes darling that is food." The Eyeless man said. "Your kid has the making of a great killer." The Smiling man said. The Eyeless man looked towards his daughter who was breaking the ribcage of what was left of the Smiling girl. "Maybe." He said taking the child away from the corpse. He should be happy right? He's child was following in his footsteps right?