Noah Centineo Imagines

My Sister's Fake Boyfriend-Peter Kavinsky

What's worse than watching your sister date a cute guy? How about the fact that the guy she is dating just happens to be the only boy you've ever fallen for. Oh, and it's all fake.

When Lara Jean told me that she was dating Peter Kavinsky to fool everybody, I have never felt sicker. At that moment, I didn't recognize my sister.

~•~

"What do you mean you don't really have feelings for Peter?"

"It's not that hard to understand, Y/N. Josh came around the corner with my letter in hand. I panicked and kissed Peter to avoid talking to Josh. Then, Peter and I got to talking. I want to keep Josh off my back and he wants to keep Gen off his. So, we came up with a plan, one that helped both of us."

"Don't you feel weird about fake dating someone?" I stuttered, nervously tucking a piece of hair behind my ear.

"Not really," she shrugged not looking up from her phone. I just hummed as I stood up and started walking out of her room. "Y/N," she stopped me. "What's wrong?"

"Nothing," I stuttered. I quickly left her room before she could see the tears building up in my eyes.

~•~

To give her the benefit of the doubt, Lara Jean didn't know about my crush on Peter. No one did. I suffered in silence.

I waited by the front door for Lara Jean to come down so we could head to school. When she was finally ready, we started to leave.

"Wait," I said, stopping her. "You didn't grab your keys."

"Because I'm not driving." She said, opening the door.

"You really have to get passed this whole too-scare-to-drive-thing. It's sad," I sighed as I followed her.

I froze on the front porch when I saw Peter getting out of his Jeep.

"You guys coming?"

I looked over at Lara Jean to see her shrugging. "What? He offered to take us to school. It's part of the whole couple thing."

She started walking towards Peter, but I didn't move. "Y/N," she sighed when she noticed I wasn't following her. "Come on."

"Actually," I stuttered. "I'll just ride my bike to school."

"What are you talking about?" Peter laughed. "Y/N, the school is like 15 miles from here. Just hop in."

I hesitated, really not wanting to be stuck in a car with my sister and my crush. I sighed, knowing I didn't have much of a choice.

The whole ride to school, I sat in the back and didn't tare my eyes away from the window. I took a sip of my Korean yogurt but froze when I saw Peter watching me in the rearview mirror.

"What?" I asked softly.

"What are you drinking?" He asked.

Lara Jean looked over her shoulder at me and sighed. "It's a Korean yogurt drink Y/N is obsessed with. She drinks one every morning instead of eating breakfast," she said before I could.

"Can I try it?" Peter's question caught me off-guard. I didn't realize I hadn't answered until Lara Jean sighed, turning back towards me.

"Y/N, just give him some," she whispered. I cleared my throat as I handed it to him.

I held my breath, laughing slightly when he looked surprised. "Wow," he chuckled. "That's really good."

My breath got caught in my throat when he turned around to face me as he pulled up to a stoplight.