1 Dare//Payton Moormeier

Caught

A/n: I just watched Payton's live with Christianityhotlineofficial it was the best thing ever other than when Toochi was like add me and then boobies were seen she had a swimsuit tho. Payton was like nope 😂. I hope someone screen recorded that.
——————————————————

Sara's Pov

Payton asked if I wanted to go to his house and I said sure I needed some time to just think without being questioned. I love the girls but they want to know everything. Payton knows when I just want to chill. We told the guys and the girls. Jackson whispered something in Payton's ear. I didn't hear what he said but Payton said "shut the fuck up Jackson" "you're not denying it" Jackson said. "Omg we aren't gonna do anything Jackson!" Payton told Jackson. "Ya surree" I waved to the girls and said "ttyl girls" Payton grabbed my hand and we walked off to my car because I didn't trust the girls and Payton came in Jackson's car. I went to get in my car when Payton asked "can I drive?" "Umm sure, just don't crash my car" "I won't I promise" he said with a reassuring smile. I tossed him the keys and got in on the other side. Payton was fixing the rearview mirror when he noticed how many bags were in the back seat. "How much did you girls buy?" "Not that much honestly" "that's a lot of clothes" "no it's not" "maybe for you it's not but like I literally buy that in like 6 months" I laughed a little then said "I don't usually buy that much I just was having fun and it took my mind off everything I guess" "and what would everything be?" He asked. "You" I said quietly. "What was that I didn't hear you" he said with a smirk. "You heard me" I said. "No I didn't" "I've been thinking about you" I confessed. "Oh ya what about me?" Payton said glancing at me. " nothing important" "Are you sure?" "Yes I'm sure Payton!" "Ok ok I'm sorry" "it's fine it's just, the girls always do this they question me and they know how to get anything out of me and it annoys me" "when I'm with you I can just chill" "I see where you're coming from" Payton said. He looked at me and smiled a little. I returned it. We sat in silence not an awkward silence a nice peaceful one. Until I broke it by saying "what did Jackson say to you?" Payton blushed the tiniest bit but he still did. "N-nothing" "are you sure" I said mocking him from earlier. "Ok fine he said don't forget to use protection" "ohhh" I said laughing a little. The rest of the ride to his house we just made small talk. We got to his house and got out of the car. Payton unlocked the door and went in, I was just trailing behind him. Once Payton had shut the door he asked me if I wanted anything to drink. What a gentleman. I said "no I'm good" "Do you wanna watch Netflix" Payton asked. "Ya" I said. We went up to his room he sat on his bed and I stood in the doorway because I didn't know if I should sit down or not. "Are you just gonna stand there all day?" "Well where do I sit?" "In bed with me" he said in a duh tone. "O-ok" I slowly walked over to his bed and sat down. "Why are you so nervous?" Payton asked me smirking. "I'm not nervous" "Yes you are" "No I'm not!" "Ok fine, I want cuddles 🥺" Payton said in a baby voice. I giggled and then laid down and put my head on his chest. We watched Netflix for about an hour. I lifted my head and said "can we get some snacks?" Payton looked at me and nodded his head. I went to get off his bed but Payton pulled me back down. "Paytonnn I need you to let go of me so I can get the snacks" "I guess I'll have to carry you then" Payton said lifting me over his shoulder.  "PAYTON! Put me down!" I said trying not to laugh. That didn't work cuz we both bursted out laughing. Payton finally put me down in the kitchen. I sat on top of the counter waiting for Payton to get snacks. I was on my phone when Payton told me "put your phone down I want attention" I laughed and then put my phone down. "Do you have the snacks?" I asked. "I mean I don't really need to get any when I've got a snack sitting in front of me" Payton said. I blushed and said "smooth Moormeier smooth" "I know" he said pretending to flip his hair. We both laughed. We both stopped laughing and we were just staring into each others eyes. We both started to lean in and BOOM! We kissed. And it wasn't just a little kiss we were having a full on make-out sesh. I put my hands threw his hair. Payton put one hand on my waist and the other on my thigh. I slowly slid my hand under his sweater signalling him to take it off. He didn't have a shirt on under. My finger traced his abs. Payton put one hand under my shirt telling me to take it off. I took off the cropped sweater and the mesh. I still had on the little bra thing. Payton started kissing down my neck leaving small but still visible hickeys. He moved back up to my lips this time it was my turn. I slowly kissed down his jaw then to his neck leaving a few hickeys. We started making out again and then he started rubbing my inner thigh. I let out a quiet moan. I could feel Payton smirking. His hand went further up all the way to my kitty he was about to slip a finger in when the front door swung open and we could hear Jackson, Dylan, Moira and Kylie talking. We looked at each other and I quickly put the mesh thing back on and my cropped sweater. Payton put his sweater back on. Luckily you couldn't see the kitchen very well from the front door. I quickly jumped off the counter and went to the bathroom cuz I knew my makeup would be smudged then I realized Payton would have lipstick on him so I quickly grabbed his arm and pulled him back and said you have lipstick on your face. He looked at me and then said "don't you have those makeup wipe things" omg I do. I quickly grabbed one out of my pocket and opened the package. I wiped all the lipstick off his face. I told Payton I was going to the bathroom. I ran to the bathroom to fix my makeup. My lipstick was smudged so I just wiped it off and put a new layer. I was all good to go I walked out of the bathroom to the living room where everyone was. I sat down beside the girls and they smirked at me. I didn't understand until I realized we both had hickeys on our necks. I went bright red and the girls started laughing. "Stop it's not funny" I said with my head in my knees because I was embarrassed. Moira said "yes it is Sara" then Kaylie said "you gotta loosen up a little" then out of nowhere Jackson said "haha you owe me $20" "Fuck" Kaylie said under her breath. Payton and I looked at them funny because we were confused. Dylan finally said "they made a bet, Jackson said you guys were gonna fuck and then Kaylie said you weren't" so I said "then Kaylie gets the $20" "we didn't fuck" Payton said. Then Jackson said "the hickeys say otherwise" "Just because we have hickeys doesn't mean we fucked" Payton said. "Ok then what did you do?" Moira asked. Payton knew I wouldn't say it so he said "we made out ok" my face went red I looked down so they couldn't see. Jackson said "so you're telling me that you were alone for 2 hours nobody home and you didn't have sex" "technically they almost did but we got here" Dylan said. Jackson looked at him and said "what do you mean almost" Dylan then said "when we walked in They were in the kitchen and I saw Payton didn't have his shirt on and I saw Sara's sweater and mesh thingy on the ground and I saw where your hand was Mr.Moormeier" he said smirking at Payton. I looked at Payton and then I got up and went to the kitchen to get a drink of water. I was getting water from the sink when I felt someone's arms go around my waist I knew it was Payton. I put my glass of water down and turned around. He looked at me and said "look I know that's embarrassing but we both know that Moira and Jackson have probably already had sex" I started laughing. He started laughing too. Then he started tickling me. "S-S-t-O-p P-a-Y-t-T-on!" I said in between laughs. We were standing up so I sat down so he would stop but he didn't he sat down with me and started tickling me again. I was laying down and he was over top off me tickling me. He finally stopped and laid on top off me. "Payton I can't breath" I said laughing a bit. "Are you calling me fat?" He said in a girly voice. "Yes now get off of me!" He rolled off of me and said "I'm offended" with his hand over his heart. I just laughed. We got up and walked to the living room. For the rest of the day we just watched movies and ate food 😂.

A/n:Idk how I feel about this chapter. I have no excuse for not updating last night I fell asleep on my phone when I woke up I was literally holding my phone so tight in one hand 😂.

1710 words