My sweet sadist (Eyeless jack x male reader)

The Unspoken Truth

This episode is entirely in EJ's POV

When I woke up I thought I was in a crazy dream, (Y/n) was standing over me. I could see him up close, I almost got lost in his beautiful golden brown eyes.
"Oh good you're awake" he continued
"Slender told me to come wake you after Jeff almost killed me... again"
"Wait Jeff what?!"
"Yeah he tried killing me"
Oh Jeff is so gonna get it! But I can't really do anything or they might find out I'm gay. If they find out who knows what they'll do with me!
"Oi, so mr. leaky eyes is awake finally"
"Can you stop with the stupid nicknames Jeff?!"
I look around the room as I make it to the bottom of the stairs. The humans I captured yesterday were playing Uno with Ben, Jane was watching Sally and Lazari while they were playing dress up with Toby, Brian and Tim we're watching in amusement as the girls put makeup on Toby.

"Uh... hey Slendy?"
"Hm? Oh Jack what do you need?"
"Could we talk in private?"
"Sure"
Slendy and I stepped into the other room and I could sense that he knew something.
"So what is it you wanted to talk about?" Slender man said as I tilt my head down.
"Uhm... there's something I've been meaning to tell you for a while now"
"And what would that be?" Slendy asked looking a little bit confused.
"Well... I'm gay!" I said flinching a little bit half expecting Slendy to hit me.
"Oh Jack..." I was completely ready to be kicked out.
"I'm so happy you told me" Slendy said as I slowly raised my head
"Wait... what?!" I said in confusion "what do you mean?! I thought you would kick me out!"
"Kick you out?! I could never do something like that" at this point I was at a loss for words, all I could do was sit there starring "you are an important part of our weird little family, what in Hades makes you think I would kick you out?!" I shook my head and said "can we not talk about this anymore?" Slendy nodded his head and I walked out of the room.

Sally walked up to me, looked at me kinda confused and then asked in a calm manner "what's 'gay'?" At this point we had everyone's attention "I heard you say to Slender that you're gay!" She blurted out. I could feel my face getting red but luckily I had my mask on so the others couldn't see it. Everyone was looking at me now and I was about to faint when I heard from across the room "well Sally when you're gay it means you like the same gender" I looked over and it was Ben who said it "I don't understand" Sally said, Ben put his arm around my shoulder and pulled off my mask, revealing my red face "well Sally this big guy right here" Ben pointed to me "he likes guys" Sally had a disgusted look on her face, her words then followed as "EWWWWWWWW, guys are gross!!!" I looked at Sally in confusion "I'd rather kiss Lazzari then kiss a guy" everyone started giggling except for Ben, Slendy and Me. Sally looked around the room in confusion she then looked at me and said "if you like kissing guys that's fine, Jack!" At that exact moment everyone stopped laughing and my face turned bright red. Jeff looked over to me and said in a loud voice "I'm Bi so I don't really care" then everyone agreed with Jeff, "being gay is ok" they all said almost in perfect unison.