Slenderman
Today was a sort of weird day for Slenderman. You two were in your room just relaxing, for once, instead of reading like all time. He was looking at you with a small smile. You looked at him and flashed him that smile he loved so much. His face turned a faint red and he immediately looked away from you. You found that weird since you were a bit oblivious to the fact that he was almost head over heels for you. He loved everything about you that it could be considered obsession. He moved over a bit and looked out the window calmly to stop himself from blushing even more. "Hey, you okay?" You asked him causing him to jump and look at you with a confused yet adoring face. It was as if hearing your voice was the best thing ever to him. "Yeah..I'm perfectly fine..Oh would you look at the time? I should get going, have a lovely night (Y/N)! Until next time." He ended his little frantic sentence with a kiss to your forehead. He then vanished into thin air and left you sitting there confused and blushing like crazy. Were you getting these strange feelings as well?
Ben Drowned
Why was he acting so weird lately? Recently, Ben had been acting all clumsy and shy around you for some reason. You had a feeling it was because he liked you, but you didn't want to jump conclusions. That would be a bad decision and you didn't want to risk getting your heart broken. It was kinda clear that you liked him as well, but he was so nervous around you that he couldn't see that. Right now, you were sitting your room waiting for Ben to come and visit you for a chat. He said he had wanted to talk to you about something important, so here you were waiting in your room now. The thing you didn't know was that he was sitting in your computer, just watching you very closely. He was trying to figure out if he should tell you what he's been feeling recently or not. For some reason, he decided not yet and just went back to the mansion. You waited there all day but just decided he wasn't coming. It hurt a bit, but you didn't mind it too much. I mean, you were used to being left alone.
Masky
"Where to next?" You asked the boy walking next to you as you made your way to the Starbucks. Masky said he never had one so you were taking him to one right now. "Hm..It doesn't matter.." He replied as he looked at the place and stared in confusion. He thought it was a bowling alley or something at first, but now he realized it was a coffee place of some sort. When you arrived, you both walked in side by side, but he hid his face since he had his mask off. You told him he couldn't go out in public with it on, but no matter how much he didn't want to, he still did it because you gave him the puppy dog eyes he loved so much. "Go sit over there, I'll go order the drinks." You told him as he nodded and walked over to a table and sat down. Once you got the drinks, you went back to the table and sat down across from Masky. "Here, I got you the same as mine. You'll like it." You assured him as he stared at suspiciously then took a sip. You watched him while you sipped from your drink that you didn't realize you were staring. He noticed and a faint blush crept onto his cheeks. "What are you staring at?" He asked as he almost choked on the drink. You giggled at him and shrugged. "Just no reason." You told him and kept drinking your drink like it was nothing. You then realized that Masky would do anything for you. That could mean two things, he either liked you or was just being friendly.
Hoodie
What would you do if a really shy guy liked you and didn't know how to tell you? Nothing. Really, you knew he liked you because he made kinda obvious but he didn't say it out loud. You didn't wanna make him feel bad or anything, so you just left it alone. "(Y/N), can I t-...talk to you a-about something?" He asked quietly as you sat up in your bed and looked at him. You held in your laughter as you saw him laying on the floor on his stomach with his face basically in the floor. It seemed as if he had fallen, but you would have heard him. "Sure." You responded and moved your legs over a bit so he could come sit next to you. He got off the floor and walked over to the bed with his head low. "Well.." He started as he sat down on the bed and fumbled with his hands shyly. "I-..i..w-w..wanted.." He couldn't finish his sentence and just got off the bed before you could stop him. "Hey! Where are you going?!" You called out to him as he climbed out the window quickly, while you got off your bed to get him. You were too late since he had already left. What the f**k was that all about?
Jeff the Killer
"Wanna play a game?" You asked Jeff as you both were sitting in your backyard. It was dark and you were under a little fort made of blankets and pillows. He nodded and you smiled happily as you pulled out your phone. As you picked a song to play, he stared at your face in a loving way. He didn't know this feeling and it was annoying at first, however he decided to give up trying to stop it. "Ok, i'll go first. What's something you like about me?" You asked randomly and looked up from your phone. He blushed a bright red and looked away from you quickly. "Umm...Your hair..I guess.." He mumbled and you laughed a bit from his response. 'Everything about you.' He said in his head since he couldn't say it out loud just yet. "Ok, my turn. What do I like about you?" You mumbled as you looked at him and smiled widely. "Your smile! That's something I love, and then everything else is a close second." You said to him as you held your hand up for a high five. He gave you a high five involuntarily and just let his hand fall to his lap. As you continued playing the game, he kept replaying your words in his head.
Eyeless Jack
"Come on, you should taste it." EJ kept saying to you as he was shoving a kidney towards you. He wanted you to try one since you always said they must taste gross. You wouldn't dare put that thing in your mouth, but he kept trying. "No EJ!" You yelled at him which caused him to freeze in his spot and stare at you. He put the kidney down on the plate slowly and just stared at it. You felt bad about yelling at him like that, but you didn't know what to say now. "(Y/N), You know..I wanted your kidneys..Because they're special, like you..." Was all he asked before getting up from his chair and heading towards the front door. You were shocked by what he said but got up to stop him either way. "EJ! Wait, I'm sorry!" You kept apologizing, trying to get him to stop, but he didn't. He just walked out the door and ran into the woods without looking back. The rest of the night, you were just pacing your room full of guilt. Why did you have to yell at him like that over something so silly? He was just in so much confusion on why you got upset with him so easily. Usually you would laugh if he tried to get you to eat a kidney, but today just seemed different. But why was he bothered by it so much? Because it's that stupid beating in his heart when he was around you that he shouldn't be feeling.
Laughing Jack
You know what the silliest thing to see is? LJ in a skirt, that's the silliest thing. Or at least you thought it was. And that laugh of yours was the most adorable thing to LJ's ears. He couldn't get enough of it. And when you would squeal in excitement at something, it made his dead heart flutter a bit inside. How were you able to do this to him? That was the question he had in his head every time you came to his carnival. "LJ! LJ! LJ!" You were currently running around the carnival looking for him like crazy. He had started a game of hide and seek earlier, but it was hours since you were trying to find him and it was getting darker. Now, he knew you were afraid of the dark terribly, so he didn't make it too dark. But right now, it seemed he was too lost in your voice that he didn't realize what was happening. He did snap out of his little daydream when he heard someone crying. That someone was you of course. "I'm sorry, (Y/N)." He said to you as he appeared in front of you and pulled you close to him, then hugging you as if you would vanish if he didn't. You wiped your tears and smiled up at him. He almost fainted at the smile that he adored so much.
