Chapter 16

2.6K 42 2
                                    

They both stared at y/n seriously and she avoided eye contact, then Alex walked into the kitchen.

Alex: can I get my baby back?
M: umm no
Pinto: till you say what her and Carlos did
Alex: umm... you sure?
Y: don't alex
Alex: baby's words I can't say... sorry bro
M: I respect that

Alex helped y/n off the counter and helped her to the living room, and he did he sat her in the couch and Carlos layed onto her lap as she played with his hair. Moments later y/n layed her head on Alex's shoulder as she slowly drifted to sleep, Alex picked her up and took her to the room and stayed there with her. At that moment pinto and mattia had a chance to question the now slightly drunk Carlos.

Pinto: so what have you and y/n done?
Carlos: what do you mean?
M: yeah like what Alex mentioned
Carlos: oh... we've made out before and fucked like twice
Alv: twice?!
K: Alex knows about this?
Carlos: yes twice and yes he knows, we told him because we dont keep secrets, and he was fine with it because this happened freshman year and last year
M: thank god it wasnt recently
Ale: would that be bad?
Ro: what's the worse that could happen?
Carlos: Alex is very protective of her, he always fights with payton because of it, he always tries getting with y/n but she always tells him to fuck off and that Jaden would have a better chance than him
R: so she would voluntarily fuck someone else?
Carlos: no she says that so he can leave her alone or I step in and fuck around
Alv: what do you mean?
Carlos: so Alex gives me consent to kiss her if payton gets on her nerves and I do sometimes and he gets mad but it's funny, that's also another reason destiny doesn't like y/n
K: well cause you kissed her obviously
Carlos: no, shes jealous of y/n because she's too 'close' to us but shes wack
M: why dont you break up with her?
Carlos: shes like a rebound so I can try my best to get rid of my feeling for y/n
Pinto: you still like her?
Carlos: yes dude who wouldn't, I mean have you seen the way she smiles, her little giggles, her one dimple that shows when she smiles, the way she playfully rolls her eyes, the way she looks so good without even trying, and the way she smells like coconut and roses, the way her lips pucker up when shes sad... I can go on and on about her bro like I've fell hard for her
Njb: holy shit you're a simp
Carlos: yepp... but I especially love the way she plays with my hair and the way she places small kisses on my cheeks and forehead, and the way she hugs me makes my heart melt
Ale: maybe you should go to sleep
Pinto: you're really exposing yourself a lot bro
M: c'mon let's take you upstairs so you can sleep
Carlos: ok I guess

As mattia helped Carlos upstairs all the other boys stayed in shock about the way he talked about her, the little things he admired about her made it sound so sweet and cute. As they all continued overthinking they saw y/n coming downstairs slightly limping due to her ankle, Carlos ran back down to help her.

Y: thanks Carlos, can you take me to the kitchen please?
Carlos: of course

He ran to the kitchen as he carried y/n and placed her carefully on the counter, he got her a glass of water and she drank it.

Y: thanks Carlos
Carlos: anytime y/n... also umm can I tell you something?
Y: sure about what?
Carlos: I still like you y/n, like a lot I've tried so hard to get rid of them but they've just become stronger and stronger
Y: w-woah i-i d-dont know how to reply to that
Carlos: I know and maybe I was hoping for me and you to try things out?
Y: Carlos, baby, you know I would but I dont date
Carlos: i know, sadly, but can I get a kiss?
Y: umm if Alex is ok with it
Carlos: I'll be back

He ran out the kitchen and upstairs and woke up Alex quickly, Alex got mad and hit him with a pillow.

Carlos: I got a question, chill!
Alex: what is it?
Carlos: can I kiss y/n? Like whenever I want now?
Alex: why?
Carlos: because, I need an answer!
Alex: sure just dont fuck please
Carlos: thank you!

He ran back downstairs and back to the kitchen, the boys all looked at him confused. Once they saw y/n they knew what was happening so they decided to eavesdrop into their conversation.

Carlos: so I asked and he said yes but no fucking
Y: you actually asked him?
Carlos: yes I did now shut up

He pulled y/n into a kiss and all the boys stood there in shock, they knew he was basically cheating on destiny. As they over thought everything, y/n and Carlos started making out. He started grabbing her ass as they made out, y/n had he arms around his neck as they made out. The boys were thinking how to make them stop before things escalated, mattia got an idea and he ran outside taking his clothes off.

M: sorry guys. LETS SKINNY DIP

That made both y/n and Carlos to quickly stop kissing and made them both go outside quickly, they saw all the boys naked in the pool and y/n's eyes went wide and she limped back inside. Carlos just laughed and Alex walked out confused.

Alex: umm mattia I think you broke your sister shes just froze on the couch, and I'm pretty sure its because she just saw all of you naked
Pinto: but it worked
Alex: what worked?
Alv: Carlos and y/n were making out
Alex: and?
M: you arent mad?
Carlos: I asked before I did, besides if i didnt i would voluntarily let him beat my ass
Njb: what about destiny?
Alex, Carlos: what about her?
Ro: arent you dating her?
Carlos: shes a rebound
R: damn... I know how being a rebound is
Alex: must suck bro, anyways I gotta make sure your sister doesn't die, c'mon Carlos
Carlos: coming

They both walked back inside as the boys continued swimming naked, as they were they saw something shocking.......






Word count: 1113

The Unknown Twin - New Jersey boys Where stories live. Discover now