You (Jeff The Killer X Reader~Soulmate Au)

Chapter Six: Jeff has an Ex Girlfriend

||A/N: the artwork in the media is mine, it is of my OC who is based off of my irl looks. I do apologize for adding myself into the story but you'll understand why later on also comment who you ship her with! I will be giving her a love interest~Butterfly/Flutter||

||Your POV||
It's been maybe a week since the living room spirit form incident and things in the mansion have been going well.

I am currently sat on the couch next to Jeff watching BEN play video games and seeing him rage quit a few times.

EJ is reading in the chair next to the couch but he perks up and faces the door randomly.

"She's back" was all he said causing everyone to stop what they were doing and look at the door as well.

"Are you sure Ej? She's been gone for a month" masky asks him and EJ simply nods.

And then the front door opens and a black bag is thrown into the living room.

"I'M BACKKKKK!!!!" Is yelled out from a short girl who walks into the mansion.

She has brown hair with pink bangs, a grey sweater, pink choker, pink shorts, black fishnets, one pink thigh high sock and on black knee high sock, black combat boots with pink laces, and a very noticeable pink mask covering her face.

"Who's that?" The girl and I say at the same time looking directly at each other.

"(Y/N) don't talk to her" Jeff says protectively wrapping an arm around me.

"Ah I see. Hi I'm Flutter, but I'm better known as Heartbreaker. I'm Jeffery's Ex girlfriend and you must be the soulmate! I'm so excited to finally meet you!" The girl says taking off her mask to reveal her vibrant green eyes.

She's pretty, really pretty and she seems nice, but she's Jeff's ex? From how long ago?

Questions fill my mind and I start going into spirit mode but quickly snap out of it when I see Jeff angrily look at the short girl.

"Why did you have to mention being my Ex Flutter?!" And the boys exploded

"Excuse me Jeff but I'm not gonna fuck with your soulmate if that's what your wondering! I just feel like she needed to know what I am to you Woods! I don't hold grudges over soulmates like you do. It's not my fault I got my mark your the one who ended things because of it and I still haven't found my soulmate so I don't understand why you even hold a grudge against me for it!" Flutter angrily says back crossing her arms over her chest as she tells him off.

I kinda like her but I'm not quite sure why Jeff hates her so much when he has a soulmate marking too.

"I- I don't hold a grudge! I ended it cause I got my soulmark and didn't want you going off and killing my soulmate Arsyn!" Jeff stands up getting closer to the girl until he's towering over her and looking down at her but she stands her ground.

So they refuse to be on first name basis I assume.

"Oh like I would even do that! I am not you Jeff. I don't go off and kill soulmates! You know damn well I won't ever be mad at you for finding her; in fact I probably would've helped you find her if you wouldn't have shut me out and acted mad at me for three years!" Flutter exclaims pushing the male away from her and facing me.

"I apologize for my behavior at the moment. Yes I am his ex, but i am happy he found you if you need anything you can come to me I'm not as rude as this bitch acts like I am" and with that the pink and black clad girl grabs her bag and walks up the stairs making sure to harshly shoulder check the smiling killer on her way.

"I like her" I say breaking the silence that started to form causing Jeff to look at me shocked.

"You like that bitch?! Why!"

"She stood her ground and told you off all while being polite to me.  Honestly I think I'm gonna help her find her soulmate where's her room?!" I reply before jumping up off the couch and running up the stairs in a hurry to find her.
~~~

"I never introduced myself I'm (Y/N) (L/N) I don't have a killer name yet but EJ seems to call me runaway and it's started to stick around here. I think your cool and wanna get to know you" I say to the green eyed girl who opened the door and moved out of the way for me to enter her room.

As expected it was black and pink with lots of anime, band, and video game posters.

"Yay! I think we'll get along greatly my actual name is Flutter Arsyn I'm a reaper which means I collect souls and all that jazz and can even go to the afterlife! Oh and I know your a Dybbuk all the spirits are talking about you" Flutter says smiling at me flashing her sharp fangs.

And that was the start of a new friendship.

~~~

"Okay okay... where's your soulmate mark?" Flutter asks me giggling and trying to suppress more laughs from the jokes we've been telling

"My forearm where's yours?" I reply showing her my forearm where the intricate tattooed photo of the paper white murderer was and she inspects it amazed.

"Mine is on my left side on my ribs. It's a knife as strange as that seems" she says lifting her sweater to show a beautiful marking of a knife with flowers in the blade part.

||A/N: pretend it's a girls chest, also whatever pasta you guys choose for Flutters soulmate will have a matching tattoo of that basically being the one on the photo so ye||

Her soulmate is definitely a pasta and I think they are in this mansion, maybe it's EJ he seemed to know she was coming back before she entered the mansion and seemed rather excited she was back.

Or maybe it's Masky he seems to be close to her.

"Wow that's pretty! I bet your soulmate is a pasta though" I say as she puts her sweater down.

"Well I hope so, I got my mark three years ago when slender called a huge pasta meeting that every single pasta was at. That day I had met EJ, Masky, toby, hoodie, liu, and LJ. They were all on a four month long mission so when I first joined the mansion I didn't meet them. So those are the options haha" Flutter explains and I smile knowing I guessed two do the possibilities.

So Jeff has an ex girlfriend...
and she's now my best friend who I am gonna help find her match!