Eyes Close (Jeff The Killer × Reader)

CHAPTER TWELVE

"What the f*ck did I just walked into?"

We soon stopped our little celebration and turned to the voice behind us

"Oh, hey J-Jane!" Toby and BEN said in unison

"Are you guys done yet?" She said putting her hand on her waist, leaning a bit

"Slenderman said it's my turn to watch her" she pointed to me

BEN and Toby started to take the TV, and X-Box, I passed the controller to BEN and they waved me goodbye. Jane soon sat on the chair, she grabbed a knife from her boot and a stone from the corner and started sharpening it

"Your name's Y/N, right?" She asked her attention still focused on sharpening the knife

"Yes. And you must be Jane?" I gave a little quick nod and proceeded to start a conversation. I was back to sitting at the corner of the cell, leaning my head against the wall

The room was filled with silence, the only thing we could hear was the blade being scraped. I soon noticed that the sunlight in the room was moving upwards that means, it must be close to lunch time 'Damn it, I'm hungry' I scratched my head and sighed 'THIS ROOM IS TOO QUITE' I's not like I don't like loud people or places, but this is just too damn silent 'Maybe if I start a topic...?'

"You seem to... Dislike Jeff?" I sounded like an idiot for asking, but it was the only thing I could come up with

"Dislike? I absolutely despise him" she gritted her teeth and harden her grip on the knife.

I didn't know if I should feel relieved that she replied back or scared that she has a knife and we're the only people in the room

"I may not know why, but in a way I also hate him for killing my Aunt..." She stopped sharpening her knife and looked at me, I noticed that a tear rolled down my cheek

Jane took a few steps further, dragging the chair behind with her "You're not the first..." She hesitates for a moment "He also killed my parents and... My sister" She said putting back the knife from her boot sighing

"I'm surprised you didn't kill him yet" I say a bit sketchy

"Oh, trust me. If Slenderman wouldn't allow killing proxies, this knife would have been in his head a long time ago" she says gesturing to her boot where the knife was placed

"I-I'm sorry.." I whispered but I'm pretty sure Jane could hear it

She shakes her head "It's not your fault" she clenched her hand into a fist "Jeff is the one that should apologize.. No, even if he apologizes I will never forgive him" even under her mask, I could see that she was crying underneath it

For some reason, I stood up from my corner and hugged her even though there were the metal bars. I still hugged her and patted her back, to my surprised she hugged back after being stiff for a moment of shock. From the way she hugs back I could tell she longed for this type of comfort. All these days? months? years even, of her suffering 'She would just be a normal teenage girl, if her family wasn't murdered by Jeff... Like me" I could feel her tears on my shoulder now (A/N: All you Jane lovers our there, this is for you UvU)

She took off her mask, wiping her tears and sniffling a few times. She was very pretty her face was not as pale as the rest of her, but it was porcelain, pink cheeks, her pink lips and her green eyes complementing them, I could even see a bit of brown strands of her hair 'So it was a wig?'

I stared at her in amazement "It's funny how you remind me so much of my sister. She would often do this to me" she chuckled and we pulled back from the hug

"If it helps, I can be your sister well if you want?" I said smiling but asking at the same time

"I would like that, thanks Y/N" we both chuckled and I feel her ease up a bit

"Thanks too, I can finally know how it feels to have a sibling" I say still laughing

"Trust me it's torture but then again it feels like your not alone, that you feel safe and sound and they make each moment memorable" Jane said letting her memories of her sister flash in her head

'Yeah, it's pretty awesome"