My Boyfriend's Brother

Chapter 3: Do You Know What, Garrett? I'll Do It

Charlotte's POV

After Garrett gave me an ultimatum about the future of my relationship with Marshall, I decided I need time to think before making a big decision involving my relationship. When we both get back to Marshall and Mrs Overboe, they were already watching a movie called 'The Hangover'. Before sitting beside Marshall, Garrett made his attempts of flirting to get my attention by winking at me and slapping my ass. He's pushing over the edge, I love it. what am I saying, I shouldn't like it but I do, what is he doing to me? To make his attempts of getting closer to me easier for him, he kept on touching my thigh under the blanket that was laid across me and Marshall on the couch. At one time I did hit his hand because of it. He didn't react but Marshall caught me hitting the blanket near my thigh. He said, "Are you ok?" I simply replied and once again, lied through my teeth."Yeah, I'm fine just some stupid fly keeps annoying me." The fly being Garrett.

After the end of the movie, had decided to go to bed. I had realised how fast time was running out. I had to tell Garrett what my decision was about his ultimatum he gave me earlier. He said something. He must have thought I'd forgot to tell him, but honestly, it's all I could think about all night. He said, "Who here has had a one night stand?" I couldn't believe it, He's telling marshall so subtly to make it seem like it's my fault. In that single moment, I was ready to tell him. I spoke up "Garrett, can I talk to you for a minute?" He got up and walked to the kitchen. I couldn't tell Marshall was talking to his brother like that, it wouldn't look good, so I said: "Baby, why we have an early night tonight, I don't want your parents thinking we did anything." He replied "Ok babe sure" He went upstairs. After I said, "I'll meet you after I've talked to Garrett." He nodded and I walked briskly to the kitchen to tell Garrett my decision.

Garrett confidently said "Very romantic, wanting an early night for your boyfriend so you can have a quickie with me" I replied, "I'm not playing Garrett I cannot believe you said that to marshall. Are you trying to make me look bad?" He looked slightly upset. "I honestly can't believe I was gonna tell you I liked you!" Garrett was shocked."What?" I froze, but I then said"I was gonna be honest with you and say that I liked you. I've liked you ever since we hooked up at that party and I haven't stopped. Do you know what? I'll do it. I'll cheat on Marshall. I cannot have Marshall knowing about me and you having sex the same day I met him." Garrett smiled deviously "Touching little speech, babe." (EASTENDERS FANS WILL GET THAT REFERENCE) I knew he was trying to be clever. I don't think he understands that I'm trying to be serious about this. I added, "It's not a speech, Garrett, I do really like you. I'm willing to do this to save my relationship, but Marshall cannot know."  Garrett replied "Ok and don't worry about your secret. It's safe with me." He winked at me and he turns to leave but, I stop him "Garrett, just between us, I do love your side when you do act like a dick, It's very sexy." He seductively replied."Don't you worry about that, babe It's not going anywhere." He winked then left the room.

Now don't get me wrong, a lot of the time it is annoying when he's a dick to me. But I must admit it's very sexy too. It's just when Marshall's around it gets annoying and too much for me like we're gonna get caught.

After getting over the fact of Garrett's ultimatum and my decision, I head upstairs to see Marshall, who's oblivious to the fact that as of now I'm cheating on him with Garrett. When I had got to Marshall's bedroom, he was already asleep. So I decided, quite a risky move but to sleep with Garrett in his room. Walking to Garrett's, Every step I took I was thinking about Marshall. What he would think if he found out about me sleeping with his brother, not only the first time at the party but a second as well? Let alone the fact that I'm cheating on him with Garrett too at this very moment. Well, he's not gonna be impressed with either of us, that's for sure.

I walked into Garrett's room. Luckily, he's still awake. when he saw me he said, "Couldn't resist me, could you babe?" I shook my head, I then said: "Obviously not." Garrett was once again shirtless, just like previously that evening, I could resist checking him out. "I was thinking that we could recreate that night of passion we had that night at the party." He smirked and said "Ooooo sexy, I like it." I walked towards his bed, he kneels at the end of the bed and when I get to his bed. He kissed me. We start to make out, He then threw me on the bed, got on top of me and well, you can picture what happens next. Let's just say, I did get my wish of recreating the night at the party. Maybe even better than that night.

The next morning, I woke up naked not knowing what happened the night before, but also in a room that was unfamiliar to me. I turn around and I was face to face with a sleeping Garrett. I whispered to myself "Oh sh*t." After I said that Garrett almost immediately started to stir. He'd woke up and looked to me and said "Morning babe, I thoroughly loved last night, I hope we can do it again sometime. You've definitely improved since the party." I rolled my eyes."I actually can't believe we slept together. I can't believe I cheated on Marshall with you, of all people." Garrett replied with a cocky remark of"Don't pretend you didn't want it to happen, you were all over me again, just like that night at the party. Also judging by my abs, you Obviously enjoyed last night." He winked and got up. I took one look at his abs, they were covered in love bites. Oh, god. I clearly enjoyed it last night. Garrett went to get a top on.

What's Marshall gonna say when he sees them. When he came back, he said: "I think you should go back to Marshall, he might be wondering where you got to." When I got up, someone knocked at the door. Oh crap. Garrett ran over to me, kissed me and said: " Get under the bed." I got under the bed and Garrett went to open the door "Morning bro" Sh*t, Its marshall. "have you seen Charlotte anywhere?" He added, Garrett said. "Umm after our chat last night she said to tell you she was going on a run, so she'll be back soon." Marshall then replied"Oh, ok. I might go and make her something to eat before she goes home. Do you want anything?" Garrett said, "No, I'm fine, thanks." I heard the door shut so I stood up, luckily Marshall was gone. I then spoke up "That was lucky, Also how am I meant to pull off going for a run in Pjs?" Garrett then spoke up "You can borrow one of my ex's tops and jogging shorts I'm sure she won't mind." I replied, "Ok, but why do you have your ex's clothes?" Taking the clothes from him and heading to the bathroom."When we broke up, she left them here that day and never came back for them." I nodded and went to get changed into the gym clothes which fitted quite well and just my style, I might ask Garrett if I could keep them. Sounds like he doesn't have a use for them.