Chapter 5

524 11 4
                                    


He starts to attack you head on with the knife, but you grab the blade and maneuver it so that it doesn't strike you. He growls and attempts to stab you again, but you kick his legs, causing him to fall backwards and let go of the knife, you grab the knife off the ground and hold it to his throat. " Who's the weak one now?" Jeff huffs in response, gets up, takes his knife, and sits across from you at the table. Ben stands up and rests his chin on your head. " That was quite impressive ( y/n )." You let out a squeak of surprise, which makes Ben smirk. " What ~ are you embarrassed?" Toby leans over and grabs your arm, pulling you closer to him, causing Ben to fall flat on his face. At that moment Masky and Hoody pop into the kitchen, and when they see how Toby is holding you, they aren't happy. "Rogers, Leave ( y/n ) alone." Toby leans over and whispers in your ear. " Is it okay if I use you to mess with them?" You give your head a small nod and he smiles. Toby pulls you closer to you so that you're pressed up against his chest. Masky lets out a growl of anger, but Hoody gives him a warning look. Toby rests his head on top of yours. " What if I don't want to give you ( y/n )? ( She's / He's / They're ) really comfortable." You blush a little, but no one seems to notice. Ben gets off the floor and just stares at Toby in surprise. " Damn Rogers, didn't think you had the guts to fight Hoody and Masky." You clear your throat. " Who said anything about fighting?" Ben chuckles. " Well, seeing as Toby is attempting to take Hoody and Masky's ( Girl / Boy / Partner ), it's pretty obvious that there's going to be a fight." You blush a deep scarlet. " Whoa whoa whoa! Who said anything about me being someone's ( Girl / Boy / Partner )?!" Ben smirks. " So you're free ~?" Toby Masky and Hoody all turn to face Ben. " SHUT THE HELL UP ZELDA." Ben laughs and sits at the table. Toby lets go of you, and you go sit down at the seat you were previously sitting at. Hoody looks closer at your outfit and growls. " ( y/n ), why are you wearing Toby's sweater?" You giggle a little. " What? You jealous that I'm wearing Toby's hoodie?" Hoody blushes furiously under his mask. Toby hands you another stack of waffles which you eat very quickly. After finishing, you ask a question that's been bugging you quite a bit. " So, where's Slenderman?" 

So, there's Chapter 5! Seems like everyone's pretty chill with you being in the mansion, but how will Slendy react? Find out in the next chapter lol! If there's anything I can do to help improve the story, please let me know! 

- Talon 

Hoody and Masky x ReaderWhere stories live. Discover now