Could only Imagine

Chapter 2

We talked a lot and I got to know them all very well.  I was about to ask if they were hungry when the door bell rang. Cole went to go answer it and I made myself not stare at his back. Even his back was hot. But, besides that few seconds when I first opened the door, Cole didn't act weird or any different to me.
"Pizza's here!" Cole yelled opening the door wide. A guy who looked our age came in with a box of pizza. Cole took it from him as he took off his shoes. "Will!" Cole exclaimed.
"What?" the guy named Will asked, confused.
"You ate the pizza again!"
"NO I DID NOT!" Will yelled, taking the pizza from a laughing Cole. Will came over and put the pizza on a table in the center of the pile.
"Oh hi!" He says to me when he sees me. "You must be Emily! If u didn't already guess, I'm Will."
I shake his hand and ask, "Why did Cole joke saying you ate the whole pizza?"
"He loves food and once he ate four pieces of a pizza of piece pizza on the way bringing it to us," Gabe laughs. Will smacks him with a pillow in return. We are all laughing by then.
"Have you herd their music before?" Will asks me.
"I am not sure. I have herd of them but I don't think I have herd it," I explain.
"Well why don't we watch one than!" dana decides. Alex grabs her laptop. She pulls up Crome and goes to YouTube.
"What video?"she asks.
"Do one with Will in it so we don't have to watch an extra one," Cole suggested.
"Will was in it?" I ask.
"Oh yah. We originally also had Dalton form FAH but he left, Then we had David S, and he left," Cole explains as Alex pulls up a video called Im5 2014 mashup. When she played it, we were all laughing at Will and Cole. Secretly the whole time I couldn't keep my eyes off Cole. Once I could swear that Cole was watching me. After the video I asked when it was released.
"The day after we announced will was leaving, why?" Dana asked me.
"Let's watch it again with that in mind."
we watch it again and I could tell Alex noticed it too.
"What about it?" Gabe asked confused.
"So if you were a fan and you were still getting over Will leaving, and you watch this. Really listen to the lyrics that will songs and watch it again," I explain, and click the replay button. Alex and I watch the boys faces in amusement seeing them notice the irony.
"Oh my gosh I never saw that!" Cole says after it is done sitting back. All the boys nod in agreement.
After we were done eating Will asked, "So what do you want to do now?"
"We could do spin the bottle," Gabe suggests.
"And what should you do if it landed on me for you?" Dana asked.
"I would kiss u," Gabe states.
"But u and I are boys!" Dana exclaims looking at Gabe funny.
"So?" Gabe asks a tiny hint of a smile on his face. Dana hit him with a pillow and we all laughed. "Do you have any other ideas than hater?" Gabe asked dana.
"What about hardcore truth or dare?" Dana suggests. I could swear that Cole glanced at me, but it was most likely wishful thinking.
"What's that?" I ask, thinking I know.
"You can ether do the dare, or take off an article of clothing," Alex explains.
"Sounds fun!" I say.
"I'll just watch. You guys can play," Will says stepping back a bit.
"Nope, if I'm playing your playing," Cole says pulling will beside him.
"Since it was my idea, I'll start. Gabe truth or dare?" Dana asks Gabe.
"Truth," Gabe replies sticking is tongue out at Dana.
After a moment of thought Dana asks "would you really have kissed me in spin the bottle?"
"Hell no!" Gabe exclaims hitting Dana with a pillow. We all laugh then Gabe asks "Alex truth of dare?"
"Dare unlike you wimp," she says teasingly.
"Just for that, I dare you to sit in my lap for the rest of the game unless you have to get up for a dare," Gabe decides.
"You call that a punishment?" Alex smiles and sits down in his lap.
"um.. Dana truth of dare?"
"Dare."
"Um.. I dare you..  to eat a spoon full of ketchup!"
"Oh that's easy," Dana teased. Alex just smiled as he came back with a spoon full of ketch up. He put it in his mouth and gagged. We all were on the ground laughing as he ran to the kitchen to get water. "Ugh that was terrible!!" Dana complained and we all laughed harder. After we had all calmed down, dana looked between Cole and I. "Emily truth or dare?"
"Dare," I say after a moments hesitation.
"I dare you to spin a bottle and who ever it lands on you have to kiss for 30 seconds. I had a moment of hesitation, but decided I would rather kiss someone that take off my shirt. I grab a bottle from the kitchen and then place it in the middle. I take a deep breath and spin it. It lands on Cole. I let out the breath I didn't realize I was holding. I crawl up to him and take a deep breath. I look into his eyes and I see he is slightly blushing. His brown eyes seem to engulf me as I lead forward. I try to look away from his eyes but I just can't.  Finally I kiss him. I kiss him and in the back of my mind I hear them counting. I realize suddenly that he is kissing back. I kiss with a bit more passion and more truth. In the back of my mind I realize that I like Cole. Just than I herd a loud "30!" and I pulled away. I am trapped by those perfect eyes for a second more than I pull away. 
"Dana truth of dare," I say looking at him. I have an evil glint in my eye.
"Dare?" he repays hesitantly, more like a question.
"I dare you to streak outside to the corner and back," I smile at him my eyebrows raised.
"God no!" he replies taking off his shirt. "Cole truth or dare?" Dana asks him.
"Dare," he replies not missing a beat.
"I dare you to lick three things blind folded."
He shrugs and he ends up licking a lamp, Gabes arm, and Dana'a foot. after he could se again we looked at each other and agree, we are going to get Dana back.
"Dana truth or dare?" Cole says
"Dare."
"I dare to to streak to the end of the corner and back," Cole says with an evil smile on his face. Dana sits there in contemplation. It is that, or only being in his boxers. Finally he take off his pants. Cole and I look at each other with small smiles.
When it was my turn again, I asked Dana "Truth or dare?"?
"Dare."
"I dare you to streak to the right corner, down to the left and back," I says smiling sweetly at him. With a "humph" Dana got up and headed for the door, Cole and Gabe following behind. When he left Alex and I started laughing and then we ran to our balcony to watch the show.
----------------------------------------------
By the time the night way over, I had removed my socks and beanie, Alex had removed her jacket and socks, Gabe and will were shirtless and Dana was still in his boxers. Cole was shirtless and also had taken off his beenie as socks. He had amazing abs. Alex had gotten tired and went into her room and soon Gabe followed. Dana had passed out on the couches and Will had to go home. that left me and Cole talking.
"So Emily, about that kiss," Cole said hesitantly.
"Yah?" I ask my heart fluttering.
"I think that was one of the best kisses I have ever had," he confesses, looking down at his bare feet.
"Me too," I say looking down and blushing.
Just then, Gabe comes in and says "Dude! I forgot we have practice tomorrow!"
"Didn't Dana say it was canceled?" I ask, a bit annoyed that he ruined the moment.
"Oh yah I forgot sorry! We should head  back to the house anyways."
Cole nods and looks at me for a second and then he got Dana up. after they were gone I closed my eyes and imagined the kiss. I had said it was the best kiss, and I wasn't lying. I just didn't say it was my first kiss.