Cupcake

First Glee Club

"Hey Finn!" Puck shouted walking towards him.

"What?" Finn asked getting off his motorcycle.

"Let's make glee club more interesting" He said with a smirk.

"How? It's already a fucking loser town!" Finn said grabbing his bag.

"Exactly...and who is the biggest loser there?" Puck asked, still smirking.

"I don't know." Finn said, a little annoyed.

"Rachel Berry" 

"Which one is that again?" He asked, confused.

"Brunette...short..." He said, Finn still looking confused.

"Selfish and a huge diva " 

"Oh that girl." Finn said annoyed again.

"What about her?" He asked.

"We make a deal" Puck said smirking again.

"What kind of deal?" Finn asked, looking at Puck.

"Whoever can make her fall in love with them first wins a hundred dollars" He said, full-on smiling now.

"Ok" Finn said, neutrally. 

"Only rule...we have to date her until the end of the year and then we HAVE to break her heart." Puck said, still smiling.

"Ok" Finn said, now smiling.

Mr. Shue walked up to them.

"You guys ready for your first day of glee club?" Mr. Shue said excited.

"I guess..." They said reluctantly so he wouldn't know their plan.

Everyone in the choir room was chattering and whispering about who the two new members were. Some people thought they were just more chaperones and some guessed students that were quite low on the totem pole.

When Puck and Finn walked in everyone's jaws dropped to the floor. Some people were disagreeing and some were just straight terrified.

"Are you two lost?" Rachel asked with a lot of attitude.

"With all due respect Mr. Shue, I don't think this is going to go well." Kurt said, looking at them judgmentally. 

"You guys don't belong here." Rachel said, gesturing at the door for them to leave.

"We don't want to be here either cupcake." Finn said in a condescending voice.

Rachel rolled her eyes and Finn and Puck went to sit in the back.

Finn looked at Puck and looked back at Rachel. 

"Today we are doing duets!!" Mr. Shue said excitedly.

Finn raised his hand,

"Yes Finn?" Mr. Shue asked, expecting something inappropriate. 

"I want to be with cupcake." He said smirking.

Rachel rolled her eyes at him again and sighed.

"Sure..." Mr. Shue said a little confused and second-guessing himself a little bit. 

"Seriously?" Rachel whispered a little too loud.

Mr. Shue took Rachel and Finn's names out of the hat.

"Puck you're with Quinn." Mr. Shue said, looking at Quinn. She had a little bit of a disgusted look on her face.

After glee club:

"Hey cupcake!" Finn shouted after glee practice.

"Stop calling me that!" Rachel said, looking at him annoyed.

He laughed a little and nudged her arm.

Come on. You love it!" He said still laughing.

Rachel rolled her eyes and closed her locker.

"Why me?" She asked.

"What?" He asked pretending to look confused but he couldn't hide his smile.

"Why did you pick me? For a duet partner?" She asked as she started walking.

"Where you going?" He asked clearly avoiding the question.

"I'm going home, where are you going?" She asked looking back at him.

"Don't we have to practice?" He asked, raising his voice so she could hear.

Rachel looked back at him and smirked a little then walked away. 

This is going to be a little harder than I thought. Finn thought to himself before going home.

In bed that night he couldn't stop thinking about the bet...or was it Rachel he couldn't stop thinking about?

I hope you liked this chapter!! (Yes I know I use a lot of exclamation marks...I can't help it!)  Thanks for reading!! Please vote!! 💖

                                           Lots of love,

-Samantha 💕