Buttahbenzo Stories

45 Stories

Picture Perfect by SpariaForever
Picture Perfectby SpariaForever
Lucy and Ian get closer then expected, Ashley and Shay play a prank on Troian, who is hiding a dark secret of her own. What else? Read to find out...
pretty little liars imagines/preferences gxg by pagingfandoms
pretty little liars imagines/prefe...by pagingfandoms
liars x reader gxg g!p smut fluff request more Mona • Hanna • Emily • Alison • Spencer • Aria
Emison:True Love by HosielovesPosie
Emison:True Loveby HosielovesPosie
Emily has always loved Alison and it turns out Alison loves Emily she just hasnt told her. It's about time she does. Even with her biggest secret ever. Will she tell Emi...
Stargazing (Laurinah) by bluedinah1997
Stargazing (Laurinah)by Kai
Sequel to Hey, I'm Gay (Laurinah) 6 months after Dinah proposes to Lauren, she's left standing at the alter. Will they get back together or are they better off apart?
adopted by shay Mitchell by Gagas_Italian_Pussy
adopted by shay Mitchellby YOUR MOMS A HOE
1 year old Oakley gets adopted by shay Mitchell
And Beyond by OnlyJustADream23
And Beyondby OnlyJustADream23
Sequel to 'To Infinity'... Buttahbenzo oneshots, set a while after the first story. Prompts always welcome of course!
To Infinity by OnlyJustADream23
To Infinityby OnlyJustADream23
Just a little ButtahBenzo story! There will be a 2nd book but I don't want to give away too many spoilers!
Rosewood Day Academy by Anonymously-J
Rosewood Day Academyby Anonymously-J
This story is about the Four girls Alison, Spencer,Emily, and Hanna. They all go to rhe same boarding school. They are the best of friends and of course they're popular...
My Girlfriend (PLL) by oceans8isgay
My Girlfriend (PLL)by im that person
2 girls with feelings for one girl. Shay Mitchell is the girl Ashley Benson, and Sasha Pieterse fall for. But one day, Ashley invites Lindsey, Shay, Sasha, Lucy and Troi...
Until my heart stops beating [ButtahBenzo] by Xxsk8ergurllxX
Until my heart stops beating [Butt...by train wreck
Ashley Benson and Shay Mitchell, the best of friends. But what will happen if one of them or maybe even the both of them has a hidden desire that only Troian and Tyler k...
Adopted by Ashley Benson by AlwaysForever95
Adopted by Ashley Bensonby AlwaysForever95
Ashley is still filming PLL, but she is ready to have a child. Follow the journey of Ashley being a mother.
Hannily Forever and Always by 3buttahbenzo3
Hannily Forever and Alwaysby Buttahbenzo.3
When Emily's dad died she blocked out everyone, even her bestfriends. She blocked out Paige too. Later on after a tragic accident Han and Em realise they love each othe...
Secret Lovers (ButtahBenzo) by shookmila
Secret Lovers (ButtahBenzo)by camzwhoregay
Shay Mitchell x Ashley Benson =BUTTAHBENZO! *** As the TV Series Pretty Little Liars ends, will Shay and Ashley see each other again? Or will they have to face different...
Pretty Little Liars Emily and Aria by Skater_The_Scorpion
Pretty Little Liars Emily and Ariaby Skater_The_Scorpion
Every ones always loving on sparia emison and Hanily what about Ariely
•Pretty Little Liars One Shots• by SpobyPllMyLife
•Pretty Little Liars One Shots•by An old pll fan
One Shots about lots of couples from pretty little liars and the Cast ❤ •REQUESTS ARE OPEN•
ButtahBenzo Texts  by emisongirl
ButtahBenzo Texts by Tina
Shannon and Ashley are dating this is texts messages between them both.. Lucy, Troian also appear in the texts.. None of them are famous..
Love At First Saik • Buttahbenzo by FredrikaLee
Love At First Saik • Buttahbenzoby local homie
They're best friends with benefits. Shay is secretly in love with Ashley, And Ashley is secretly in love with Shay. One problem tho, they're best friends and one shall n...
Your my little girl/ Shay fanfic by Lol_lila99
Your my little girl/ Shay fanficby Emma_h
It's a fanfiction about Shay Mitchell. How will she manage live with a hit Tv show and her two year old daughter where she has also no idea who her father is....
She's Not Me • (ButtahBenzSha Short Story) by fartsywizard
She's Not Me • (ButtahBenzSha Shor...by R. A. Greene
"You'll be seeing my face again, I'll be crossing your mind, you'll be dreaming of places we went, and then you'll wake up to find, That she's not me." (Songfi...