Caleb Mayhem, the lead guitarist of the famous rock band Elwin'sRevenge, becomes inconsolable after the murder of his fiancé, Lennox. Waking up after a night of drinking, he finds himself six years in the past nearly five months before they first met, and when her killer first began to stalk her. Now that he is living his 21 year-old-life again, Caleb soon finds out that the woman he loves lived a very different life before she met him. He finds her working behind a bar instead of in school, with piercings adorning her face and colors in her hair, the complete opposite of the Lennox he once knew. And her attitude is one to match. Even just getting her to hold a conversation with him is a struggle. But as the weeks go by and they get closer, Caleb realizes that Lennox's life contains dark secrets. Secrets of her life that Caleb never knew. With Lennox dealing with issues from her own past including the murder of her twin sister Ellie, she confides in Caleb that someone is following her. With a trail of assaults on sorority girls leading their way, Caleb and Lennox work together on finding a killer, falling in love again, and learning to cope through the loss of losing someone they love.