a/n: hi again!! this story i wrote as a crossover b/t riverdale and american horror story. and they are based off the characters in season one of ahs. enjoy!! also, the beginning is only a mention of betty and jughead. it may not seem like a bughead fic, but just make sure to read until the end 😏 warning: this is NOT a soft fic
cheryl blossom wasn't about to turn down the opportunity for a sleepover. especially if it was on her 18th birthday.
cheryl is the epitome of nightmares. lives, breathes and sleeps chaos. that's what she's known for. so a fun, high school sleepover was exactly what she was going to plan. but, who knew she couldn't control chaos?
of course she would invite her beloved toni, but she also decided to invite veronica lodge. her cousin betty cooper was busy that night, saying she would be out on "rendezvous", as cheryl liked to call it, with her beau, jughead jones.
so right now, cheryl walks into pop's chock lit' shop, eager to get hers cherry red claws on a cherry phosphate that she adored. she was cheryl blossom, of course. red, cherry...it's like the color was made for her. but she was also picking up a burger and chocolate milkshake for her tt.
she sat down at the counter, sitting on a red barstool. she greeted pop with a sweet smile, and ordered herself a cherry phosphate and toni's meal. he said he would have it right out for her, so cherry tapped her nails on the counter impatiently. she sighed to herself, looking around as she waited impatiently to get her order. diners weren't really her go-to, but it's what her sweet toni loved, and she wasn't about to let her down.
but cheryl was strung from her thoughts, upon hearing the bell come from the front door of the diner. she turned her head, raising an eyebrow at a woman she's never seen before. tall, dark cat eye sunglasses, and luxurious golden hair that was perfectly straightened without a single flyaway in sight.
the girl walked up to the front counter, a few feet away from cheryl. she heard her order a burger and vanilla milkshake to-go, and cheryl had to admit...the girl was definitely a sight for sore eyes.
cheryl smirked, immediately getting an idea. because when would cheryl never get a sinister idea? she was born for chaos. practically adored it.
"excuse me? are you lost, darling?" he asked with a smirk on her cherry red lips, her voice almost sounding like the purr of a cat.
the girl turned her head slowly to look at cheryl, pulling her sunglasses off effortlessly as she did so. only to reveal a shade of dark brown orbs.
"no, i don't think so. i live just outside of town. so i thought, why not grab a greasy burger instead of indulging in burnt lasagna? so no, i'm not lost, wannabe emma stone." she snapped back with a smirk, before turning her head away.
cheryl bit her bottom lip softly, immediately intrigued by the woman. she was firey, sassy, and someone cheryl definitely wanted to know more about.
"i'm cheryl blossom. what's your name, may i ask?" she asked with a teasing smirk on her lips.
"madison." the girl stated, as if it were a fact. "why?" she asked, looking at cheryl with a fierce look.
and cheryl got the most insinuating idea.
"come to a sleepover at my house tomorrow night. it's my birthday, and i'll be having a couple of my closest companions over for a night of fun and games. oh, and bring a couple guests as well. it'll be lots of fun." she said with a devilish smile, picking up the order pop just brought out for her.
"be at thornhill mansion. 8pm sharp. we'll have pizza and snacks so...just some clothes and a blanket is all you need. toodles!" cheryl spoke with a wink, and waltzed out the door. she knew this was an amazing idea, and she wasn't about to let it go to waste. she was going to get to know this girl, and whoever she brought along with her.
