Music starts playing as a vehicle pulls up outside of Burger Heaven and Garth gets out, wearing sunglasses, and there are two girls standing outside of the restaurant Chloe and a teenage girl are talking to each other outside, Garth says "Ladies." They both look over and the Girl asks Garth "What do you want, Top Gun?" They both laugh and then Garth says to both of the girls "For starters, I'd like a little respect." He holds up a badge and both of the girls stop laughing and Chloe says to him "Sorry, Officer. We didn't realize." Garth says to the both of them "All's forgiven. Take a seat and tell me about Trevor McCann and other night up at Widow's Peak." Both girls spoke the same time which causes Garth to say "Okay. Well, at first it was just like he was super-drunk." Chloe then says "All right. It was weird 'cause he was super-drunk." Garth points to the girl and says "Whoa. You, Go."
The Other Girl says "It was Jenny Greentree." Chloe says to her friend "Shut up! Okay? She's just a dumb legend." Garth says to the girl "Hold up. Who?" Chloe says to Garth "Jenny Greentree, My dad says she really died in the woods and she's buried in the town cemetery." In the Town Cemetery, Garth is digging in front of Jennifer Greentree's headstone and he says "All right, Jenny G." He pours Salt into the grave "Your ganking days are over." He then lights a match and throws it into the grave and says "You've been Garthed." He walks back to his car whilst poison plays.
Ray is sitting in a car with a bottle of alcohol beside him and he pushes a button on his cell phone Chloe leaves a voice mail and she says "Ray, where are you?" Ray drinks from another bottle and she continues "You should be with your family right now. Don't do anything stupid. Please." Ray hits a button to stop the message and takes another drink. He gets out of the car, carrying a rifle and he walks through the woods with his rifle, he sees a long-haired woman in a white dress through the trees and runs towards her. He pauses and looks around, then screams as he is dragged upwards his His legs shake and there is the sound of flesh tearing. Blood runs down his legs and onto his boots and the ground, Ray goes still.
Garth is talking on his phone in front of a food van that reads "Guanaco Salvadoran Cuisine." He says on the phone "Yeah, I clocked out put it to bed problem solved and I'm headed your way, so, uh... fire up that hot tub." He chuckles and continues "No, I heart you more." Garth gets into his vehicle and opens a take-out container whilst driving over the police radio an Operator says "Abandoned vehicle out by Widow's Peak. Uh, we got another body up here. Guy's torn to shreds." That confuses Garth and then says out loud "What?! No way. How is that possible? I Garthed her!"
Dean is talking on the phone in the passenger seat, Sam is in the driving seat and Sarah is in her usually seat in the back, she was sound asleep which is something she rarely has which is concerning both Sam and Dean, Dean says to the person on the phone "All right, well, call us if he wakes up or, you know, anything yeah fine thanks Meg." She hangs up, "What a bitch." Sam asks Dean "So, Cas is the same, then?" Dean says "Yeah down to the drool." Dean looks over to Sarah who is still sound asleep and Sam asks "Hey I know you're worried about Sarah but it's obvious she cares for you and so do you, I do as well let's just hope she sleeps for a little longer." Dean turns and says "Yeah you're right so how's is your custard?" Sam focused on the road of course replies with "It's all right. It's getting better. Just wish it wasn't like the damn tape from "The Ring." I mean, I feel like I'm okay 'cause I passed on the crazy."