Forest Daytime, Bobby, Sarah, Sam and Dean are walking through the forest and they look up at a bloodied arm hanging from a tree and Dean says "Well, I guess we found Phil." Bobby says "Wait a minute. Something's not right here." Dean says "Yeah, no kidding, Bobby. There's a corpse in a tree." Bobby says "Something bad's about to happen." Dean says to Bobby "Yeah, well danger's kinda on the W2 – that's why we got the guns." Blood drips from Bobby's cap,He puts his fingers to his head and sees more blood on his fingertips when he lowers his hand "Or something bad's happened already." Inside a Old House Daytime, Sarah, Bobby, Sam and Dean enter and Bobby removes his cap and touches his head. There is a small amount of blood on his forehead "Balls." Sam asks "Y-you want to tell us what's going on?" Dean asks "Yeah, what's going on with your head?" Bobby says "I got shot in it!" Dean says "You What?" Sarah says "Bobby, we've been with you all day." Dean says "Yeah, I think we would have noticed if you took a bullet." Bobby says "I didn't take one here. I-I took one out there, i-i-in the real world." Dean says "You lost us." Sam asks "Look, Bobby, you – you want to sit down, seriously?"
Bobby replies with "No, there's something I gotta tell you. I-I... Dammit, I can't get at it." Sarah says "Well, it – it's okay, take your time. We're – we're right here." Bobby says "No, no, not you, you. Real you. Out – out there, in the waking world. Numbers. Numbers. Where's paper?" Bobby walks over to the table, on which there is a pen and notebook, and writes "I didn't have time before to tell you what... Bobby writes "454895" in the notebook "...they're cookin' up. You need to know." Bobby puts the piece of paper from the notebook in his jacket pocket and Karen says "Well... Bedroom Daytime Karen is sitting on the bed in a nightgown. There are candles on the bedside tables, Bobby is standing in the doorway holding a glass of red wine "... you just gonna stand there or hand it over, Bobby?" Bobby asks "What the hell? Karen?" Karen asks "You were expecting Farrah Fawcett?" Bobby says "No. She always calls first. pause "That's what I said the first time this happened."
Karen asks "What are you talking about? Gimme!" Karen holds out her hand, Bobby looks down and notices the glass of wine and Bobby simply says "Oh." Bobby gives Karen the glass of wine, "This – this is just like it was. You're beautiful." Karen says "Quit sweet-talkin' and come here." Karen takes Bobby's hand "I feel like we haven't talked in ages." Bobby replies with "I know just how you feel." Karen says "Listen, I have something I want to say to you. No excuses this time, okay? Just sit, Bobby." He sits down on the bed and Bobby says "I know what night this is. I remember this." Karen starts by saying "I've thought about this a lot. I really... Karen and Bobby simultaneously "...sat with this..." Karen hits Bobby lightly "Don't make fun of me." Bobby says to Karen "I wouldn't. But right now I gotta..." There is the sound of thunder, "I don't remember a storm coming in the night this happened." Bobby goes to the window and sees a full moon and a sky full of stars. The stars all disappear and the reflection of the moon in the window fades Bobby sees a Young Boy running from behind a shed towards the house "Mother Mary. I've got a messed-up fruitcake." Karen asks "What Bobby?" Bobby says "Nuthin'. I gotta go. I'm sorry, darling." Karen says "Bobby, wait! Don't go."
Street Nighttime, Bobby looks around at lightening and hears thunder. He is behind Rufus, who is standing outside a building wearing a pest control uniform and Bobby is wearing the same outfit as Rufus and he says "Number-one trick, is act like you know what you're doing, Bobby." Bobby says "Rufus?" Rufus asks "What, I can't give you advice now? All of a sudden you know everything? You know, I can always go wait in the car." Bobby says "No, wait. I – I need your help. Bad." Rufus says "Yeah, damn straight you do." Bobby says to Rufus "No, listen to me, Rufus. I'm gonna die!" Rufus says to Bobby "Oh, now that's a realistic view of the mortality rate on a ghost hunt." Rufus is holding an EMF reader, which lights up and makes noises "Whoa, whoa, Nellie, red line. All right, baby boy, here we go." Bobby says "No, Rufus!" Rufus enters the building, Bobby looks around. It is now raining, the Young Boy from earlier on runs down the street and then Rufus opens the door of the church again and asks "Are you coming, Bobby? I mean, we're not getting any younger here!" Bobby says "Coming." He looks down to see the Young Boy in front of him, The Young Boy clasps Bobby's arm and says "God's gonna punish you." Bobby hears the sound of breaking glass and looks behind him to see a broken glass of milk on a tiled floor. When he turns back, the Young Boy is gone and Bobby enters the church.
