Street Daytime, Sarah and Dean is walking along a street carrying a bag from Fat Mack's Bar-B-Q Rib Shack. He checks his cell phone, which says NO MESSAGES and they both stop in front of a blue and gray Dodge Challenger, looks around, then uses a hook to break in they both look in disgust at a pile of garbage on the passenger seat and Dean says "Geez. Have some pride." Sarah sweeps the garbage onto the floor and Dean hot-wires the car "Yeah." They both get in and close the doors behind them and the radio is on "Ooh! That make me hungry. You're listening to... Dean pulls down fluffy dice that were hanging from the rear-vision mirror ... the morning chaos with me, Bananas Foster." Dean says "The hell I am, ass-hat." Dean moves to change the channel, but then pauses "And now for the news of the weird – two very odd murders, to be exact. Mediums are dying in Lily Dale, the most psychic town in America. So if you want to know your future..." Dean reverses out of the parking spot and drives off "...stick to that 900 line, 'cause is it me, or should those guys have seen it coming?"
Lily Dale, New York Daytime, Dean and Sarah shows their badges to a police officer and looks around the room where the séance was held. He discovers a tape recorder under the table and plays the recording, which is of rustling noises. He moves a lever on the floor and there are mumbled voices. He presses a switch on a chair and the curtains move "O spirits of the further... am I going to win the Powerball?" Dean presses a large lever under the table and there is a knock "I'm gonna be rich!" Sarah laughs and says "Keep wishing maybe one you'll be rich." Street Daytime, Shop signs advertise psychic, palm and tarot readings. Dean and Sarah walks along the street. He stops at a poster for the Annual Lily Dale Psychic Festival featuring Imelda Graven (Crystal Ball), Grandma Goldy (Talking Board) and Nikolai Lishin (Kinetic Mind) They enters the Good Graces Cafe. A blackboard at the back says "Special of the Day: You!" and "Soup of the Day: A State of Bliss"." Waiter asks "Hello! First time at Good Graces?" Sarah says "Yes." Waiter says "Well, we're 100% locally sourced, biodynamic, and you get a free affirmation with every order." Dean says "Think I'll source a taco joint." Waiter says "All right."
Dean and Sarah turns to leave and then they both hear Sam's voice "Just coffee, black, extra shot." Sam is sitting at a table, reading a case file Dean asks "You always wear a suit to get your palm read?" Sam doesn't reply or smile, "Yeah. Not surprised you caught this one. It's on every morning zoo in America. You mind?" Sam moves his hands noncommittally, Dean and Sarah takes a seat across the table and Sam moves his case file to his lap and Sarah knows that Sam doesn't want Dean there but of course Dean didn't noticed and Sarah remained quiet and then Dean says "So, we uh, we went to the scene. Wires, speakers, enough E.M.F. to make your hair stand up. Don't even think about getting a reading. Oh, and, uh, if this hadn't have been two psychics that bit it... I would have just chalked this up as being, uh, dumb and accidental and I know, I know. This whole town's supposedly calling ghosts. But that takes some serious spellwork and some serious mojo. The only books this lady had were Oprah crap. When was the last time you actually saw a real psychic? Huh? Pamela? Missouri? Anyway, this Dean towards Sarah and Sam " is good. And, uh, how you been?" The Waiter asks "And what can I get for you two?" Dean says "I'll have Uh, pancakes, side of pig. Coffee, black." Sarah says "Coffee, three sugars and Milk Please."
Waiter says "Fantastic. You are both a virile manifestation of the divine." The Waiter smiles broadly and leaves and Sarah still remains quiet and Dean asks "What did he say to us?" Sam scoffs, shakes his head and looks away "Oh, it's funny? Yeah, no. Go ahead. Laugh it up, Sam. Hilarious." Sam says "Dean.." Dean says to Sarah "Oh, he speaks." Sam says "Look..." Dean interrupts again and says "Sam. Look, we're all here, All right, the chance of either one of us leaving while people are still dying out there— Dean makes a "zero" sign with his hand and clicks his tongue "You might as well bite the bullet and work with us on this one." Sam says "I don't know if I can." Dean says "I'm not asking you to open up a can of worms, okay, I'm not even asking you where the hell you've been for the past week and a half." Sam simply says "Good." Sarah finally speaks and says "I think Dean is trying to say let's try and stop the killings. That's it." Sam says "Okay." Dean says "Okay? Good." A woman stops at their table and stares at Sarah, Sam and Dean, Dean asks "Can I help you?"Woman says "You're the brothers and girlfriend from the—" Sam says "Oh, no, no, no, no. The Winchester guys and Moore girl on the news a couple weeks back? No – we get that a lot." Dean says "Yeah, no. Those depraved killers got put down like the dogs that they were. Us on the other hand, we're completely harmless."
